5 ms·
The Atkins diet, as it's frequently called, does often work. But, it's really unhealthy. You shouldn't do this forever, only in limited bursts. Humans have a p
by dahart 11y ago
The Atkins diet, as it's frequently called, does often work. But, it's really unhealthy. You shouldn't do this forever, only in limited bursts.
Humans have a physiological aversion to the very idea of eating less, evolution baked it into our bones. Because of this, there's a lot of money in books, articles, and videos that offer weight loss alternatives that don't involve consuming fewer calories.
But, what makes us fat is eating more calories than we use. You can get fat on a high carb diet. You can also get fat on an all protein diet, though not as easily.
- noondip 11y agoExactly this - except, you shouldn't do it ever - see http://www.atkinsfacts.org/ http://www.atkinsfacts.org/
- oldmanjay 11y agoI'm trying to be charitable here, but I want to let you know that linking to sites that are basically giant collections of logical fallacies doesn't really make it seem like you have a strong argument. It may be interesting to note I have no stake in the low-carb game, in case you think you need to attack me on that front in response.
- noondip 11y agoPlease explain how they are logical fallacies. Most of the site's content is literal quotes from leading medical and science professionals. No stake in the low-carb game? You are kidding, right? Atkins is a for-profit, multi-million dollar corporation, akin to anyone else promoting a diet based on excessive animal product consumption.
- Ded7xSEoPKYNsDd 11y agoThe site is a giant appeal to authority. On the 'Atkins Facts' page I didn't manage to find a single fact about why Atkins is bad, only a bunch of quotes saying that it is.
- noondip 11y agoYou couldn't find a single fact? That's odd, because this was written right on the front page: > In fact there does not seem to be a single major governmental or nonprofit medical, nutrition, or science-based organization in the world that supports the Atkins Diet. As a 2004 medical journal review concluded, the Atkins Diet "runs counter to all the current evidence-based dietary recommendations.
- DrScump 11y agofunny how so many statements on that page are marked with footnote numbering, yet no actual footnotes or references are provided.
- noondip 11y agoNo? What do you suppose this is, then? http://www.atkinsfacts.org/printer_friendly.html#8 http://www.atkinsfacts.org/printer_friendly.html#8
- DrScump 11y agoI "suppose" it's a separate page that is not directed to by any of the footnote indicators or visible from the page with the footnote indicators.
- dwc 11y ago> Humans have a physiological aversion to the very idea of eating less, evolution baked it into our bones. I'm not so sure about this. I recall reading (but can't find right now) about some Asian cultures (IIRC) that find eating too much to be unpleasant, as it makes you feel sluggish bodily and slows your thinking down. "Too much" for them being something like what Westerners would consider "satisfied".
- norea-armozel 11y agoPretty much what you said is true. What I find interesting is the question of why humans evolved to be able to switch into ketosis, though. I think it's odd since plant matter would be more abundant even during the last Ice Age than say animal proteins would it not? And the fat content of insects I assume isn't very high comparably to other animals. So, why did we get it or rather what was the environmental factor that selected for it is what I'm asking (I guess).
- basch 11y agois ketosis something other apes dont perform? naturally i just assumed ketosis preceded humanity and was something we inherited.
- DrScump 11y ago(Other) Great Apes are primarily carnivores, with some being vegetarian.
- norea-armozel 11y agoI have no idea. It just seems odd to me that assuming a relatively low protein/fat intake is easily done then why have a metabolic pathway for it? My guess it's to work with fat stores over long periods of starvation (get fat in Spring/Summer/Autumn, 'starve' in winter).
- DrScump 11y agoWhat I find interesting is the question of why humans evolved to be able to switch into ketosis, though Well, organs and muscles have to run on something... most of them can run fine on ketone bodies, and it's more efficient to produce them from animal foods than to force gluconeogenesis on everything to run on glucose.