4 ms·
Calif. awarded $2.25B for high-speed rail
- josh33 17y agoBecause near-term job creation is the government's job, right? If this were such a good idea, it would have been privately funded. It's nice to know I'll be paying for another state's rail system for years to come
- ryanwaggoner 17y agoOther funding sources for California’s bullet train include $10 billion in voter-approved bonds and cash from private investors, which the California High-Speed Rail Authority hopes will provide about $10 billion.
- patio11 17y agoCalifornian voters are in the unique position in American history where they can unilaterally approve bonds that will probably be repaid by other people's taxes. (Its similar to the position California unions have been in for the last few decades, where they can unilaterally approve pay/benefits raises which will be repaid by other people's taxes. These two situations are not unrelated.)
- kevinh 17y agoActually, you won't. California pays out more in federal taxes than it gets back. It's more likely that your state is getting money from Californians.
- waterlesscloud 17y agoOf course, it's all deficit spending anyway, so no one will have to pay for it! Wait.
- jsz0 17y agoThat's one way of looking at it... Another way is CA is a huge part of US federal tax revenue. They are basically subsidizing other states via the taxes they pay the federal government. If you have benefited from the protection of US armed forces, or the safety of modern air travel via the FAA, or the safety of modern food & drugs via the FDA you are reaping the benefits of CA's population. I use those specific examples because they are programs most people would not dispute as being essential government services. In my opinion it's a very wise investment for the country. We want CA to keep being rich and prosperous so they can keep giving us lots of tax revenue in the future.
- dnsworks 17y agoI absolutely dispute our armed forces as "essential government services" in it's current incantation, especially the TRILLION DOLLARS of our federal tax money that has been used to fight two needless wars in order to increase oil profits.
- dkasper 17y agoTransportation infrastructure is a great investment in the future: where would we be today without our highway system? With air travel becoming more of a hassle each year it'll be great to have an alternative. Note that about 8 billion in total was approved, SF to LA is only one of the routes planned.
- patio11 17y agoI think transportation infrastructure is a great solution to yesterday's problems. Look at the newspaper industry: some commentators think their problem is that delivering news on dead tree is overly expensive relative to what people want to pay for it. Even if you accept that diagnosis, increasing investment into dead tree processing, dead tree distribution, and dead tree delivery is not the way forward. I use trains to commute to my job as a computer programmer. My commute is fairly inexpensive, hassle-free, and uses the best distribution system for human bodies the world has ever seen. My commute is also a jaw-droppingly stupid waste of resources. My company and I waste three hours a day five times a week shuttling a few pounds of grey matter and a pair of eyeballs from one glowing screen to another glowing screen. The glowing screens connect to each other instantly, for so cheap next to my (cheap) train passes it doesn't even make sense to measure.
- dnsworks 17y agoYour company doesn't waste 15 hours a week, you do. If you weren't commuting, would you work an extra 15 hours per week? That's 15 hours of your life that you're losing, not 15 hours of productivity.. But otherwise, I do agree with you.
- dlsspy 17y agoI'm very productive on trains. Often more productive than in office settings.
- donaldc 17y agoThree hours a day five times a week? If I were in that situation, I'd either move closer to my job, or find a job closer to where I live. Unless the train had wifi...
- pragmatic 17y agoHopefully this one won't lose $32 per passenger. "The Pew Charitable Trusts SubsidyScope Project has just released a new report that finds 41 out of Amtrak's 44 routes lose money." http://reason.com/blog/2009/10/27/riding-the-subsidized-rails-of http://reason.com/blog/2009/10/27/riding-the-subsidized-rail...
- daydream 17y agoWhy would it need to make any money? Look at roads: they cost huge amounts to build and maintain, yet the vast majority don't bring in any direct revenue whatsoever. Let's turn this statement on its head, and reframe it as a question: why isn't all mass transit free? (Yes, I understand economically why this isn't the case, and I still think it's a worthwhile viewpoint/question to ask.)
- houseabsolute 17y agoRoads aren't free. You pay a toll to the government for their use every time you go to the gas station. And they shouldn't be free, although gas should be taxed additionally for its environmental externalities.
- maigret 17y agoI don't know how it is in the US but in Germany taxe revenues can't be bound to their sources, that means the government can (well, have to) spend the oil tax on whatever he wants.
- houseabsolute 17y agoIt doesn't matter as long as the amount it costs to maintain the roads is collected in fuel taxes.
- jordanb 17y agoGas taxes pay for the interstates, but they don't cover the local road network in most parts of the country. Road maintenance is a massive part of most municipalities' budgets and it comes from general tax revenue.
- ecq 17y ago$33B for Afghanistan but only $2.25B for California?
- phamiliar 17y agoDon't forget the $30B for Israel to keep occupation of Gaza. So a total of $63B for foreign occupation, and a total of $8B for domestic infrastructure transportation.
- dnsworks 17y agoSadly, the new California "High-speed rail" is slated to go 75MPH.
- mkinsella 17y agoAccording to the CA High Speed Rail Authority [1], a trip from San Jose to Los Angeles is 384 miles and will take 2hr9m. That is an average of 180 MPH. [1] http://www.cahighspeedrail.ca.gov/map.htm http://www.cahighspeedrail.ca.gov/map.htm
- dlsspy 17y agoThat's fascinating. If it costs even the same as air travel, I might just use it spontaneously. A 40 minute flight easily takes two hours these days.
- dnsworks 17y agoInteresting. This is completely different from the hyped up CAHSRA plan about 6 months ago that was saying "high speed raiL" when what they really meant was "catching up on existing track maintenance"
- potatolicious 17y agoHonestly, if all they did was take old rail tech and make sure passenger rail gets its own track (instead of being preempted by freight) I'd be pretty happy already. This is where the bulk of the speed limitations come in.
- shrike 17y ago129 min trip includes several stops, Fresno, Bakersfield, Palmdale, etc. The actual hardware will support speeds of ~200 MPH. [1] http://www.railway-technology.com/projects/california/ http://www.railway-technology.com/projects/california/