3 ms·
This system really can't help but fail open. The researcher handwaves in this direction, 'because “you don’t want these to alert and go off every time you turn
by jerf 11y ago
This system really can't help but fail open. The researcher handwaves in this direction, 'because “you don’t want these to alert and go off every time you turn on the microwave,” Beardsley notes', but either it fails open or trips an alarm; practically speaking there is no middle ground. Changing the color of a light in a different room in the middle of the night is as good as a no-op.
I'd submit that what this really proves isn't that the Comcast system needs this or that tweak... what it proves is that this sort of security can't be done wirelessly. Wireless equipment can not help but assume that if it can't hear from its sensors, the situation must be OK, and they can not help but be jammable with hardware that really isn't that sophisticated.
The solution to both problems is a decently-shielded wire. It is impractical for a thief to jam, and continuous active communication that trips in a fraction of a second if severed from the hub is trivial and reliable.
I like WiFi as much as the next guy, but it seems to me a lot of people badly overestimate what wireless is capable of sometimes.
- FireBeyond 11y agoOne presumes that if your system is set to disarmed, as it would likely be if you're using your microwave, this could be ignored, but in Armed - Away mode, differently.
- lost_my_pwd 11y agoThe system I have is wireless and despite being in a 3000+ sf home with many potential sources of interference, I have not had any communication issues. When a perimeter sensor, one that guards against intrusion, drops communication, the system will take action dependendin on whether the system is armed or not. If someone is home using the microware, the alarm is typically not armed; not that the microwave has ever caused an issue anyway. I don't see why this is not the behavior for xFinity's system as well.
- pm24601 11y agoYou are also missing the point that there is no indicator of communication failure, no log, etc. In my fire alarm when the batteries are going dead there is a chirp that lets me know of a pending failure. The Xfinity alarm system could do that as well. Instead the alarm system is worse than useless. I can buy a box that always has a green light on it which is exactly what this "alarm" system is doing when there is an extreme failure.