4 ms·
There are multiple fad diets that are popular in the US that boil down to 'low carb'. I often wonder if it isn't anything subtle, just that processed carbohydr
by maxerickson 11y ago
There are multiple fad diets that are popular in the US that boil down to 'low carb'.
I often wonder if it isn't anything subtle, just that processed carbohydrates are incredibly energy dense. 100 grams of sugar or flour has twice the calories of 100 grams of beef (prepared bread still has more calories per gram than beef). 100 grams of greens or non starchy vegetables almost doesn't have calories.
- coldpie 11y agoI have a tricky time talking to people who subscribe to fad diets. I don't want to discourage people from caring about their health. The fact that they have gone from eating whatever to trying to control their diet is a positive step and I want to encourage them for doing that in the first place. But then there's garbage crap like paleo and "cleanses" that are ridiculous and can be actively harmful. So how do you tell someone their diet is stupid while not insulting them for caring about their diet? Mostly I settle for trying to give them well-written articles by scientists and nutritionists to read, but at the end of the day, I'm not their main source of information and good information gets drowned out in the hours spent on Pinterest. It gets even trickier with diets like gluten-free. The vast majority of people on gluten-free diets do not have any gluten allergy. But, as you said, cutting down carbs would vastly improve the health of most Americans. So, cutting out gluten also cuts down on carbs which leads to a healthy outcome, even though there is actually no reason for them to cut down on gluten itself. So their reason for cutting down on carbs is wrong, but the final effect is good. Is this misconception worth correcting? Can I tell them they don't actually have an allergy and it's OK to have a bagel or a beer if it fits their calorie requirements? Would that be defeating the ultimate goal of improving their health? In the end, mostly I just butt out. Let people do whatever they feel is best to their bodies and I'll continue to do so to mine: "eat food; not too much; mostly plants."
- Someone1234 11y agoYeah. You can often boil most successful fad diets down to: - Eat much less sugar. - Eat some less bread/rolls/cake (or other flour based products) It is almost impossible to over-eat on veggies, they are just too filling for their calorie content.
- mod 11y agoThat's my opinion. I use low carb diets because I go around at a calorie deficit but I feel full all the time. Protein and fats are very filling.
- noondip 11y agoFat has more than twice the calories of carbohydrates.
- Ded7xSEoPKYNsDd 11y agoBy what measure? I assume you refer to mass whereas gp talked about the effect on satiety.
- noondip 11y agoBy the measure of calories. > Carbohydrate provides 4 calories per gram, protein provides 4 calories per gram, and fat provides 9 calories per gram. http://fnic.nal.usda.gov/how-many-calories-are-one-gram-fat-carbohydrate-or-protein http://fnic.nal.usda.gov/how-many-calories-are-one-gram-fat-...
- Ded7xSEoPKYNsDd 11y agoSo that's calories per mass as I suspected. Now how much does 1g of carbs affect satiety in comparison to 1g of fat? (I'm not aware of any useful studies in that regard, but I'd be very interested.)
- noondip 11y agoThink of it this way - for the calorie price of a tablespoon of olive oil (all fat, nothing nutritious), you can have a huge, ~10 oz salad filled with veggies, fruit, whole grains and legumes. Have a look at PubMed for "low-fat vegan" clinical trials - people are put on plant-based diets with no calorie restriction and end up losing weight. Also, this recent video does a great job explaining energy density in foods: http://nutritionfacts.org/video/eating-more-to-weigh-less/ http://nutritionfacts.org/video/eating-more-to-weigh-less/