3 ms·
* Day to day there was wild variation in diet ... at the end of the week the average daily calorie intake was very consistent/predictable I think this is quite
by dspillett 11y ago
* Day to day there was wild variation in diet ... at the end of the week the average daily calorie intake was very consistent/predictable
I think this is quite normal and why people recommend not measuring yourself every day. The average person's daily calorie burn is generally not as stable as they think it is unless they are closely following a plan.
You can calculate base rate then add the standard percentage for a normal relatively sedentary lifestyle to guestimate your normal daily output but that ignores the fact that you body's daily routine is not fixed. In your working day you will walk around more or less some days, the difference won't be massive but if you are micromanaging (which you probably shouldn't: that can lead to over-worrying and potentially to certain physiological eating disorders) it counts, your social hours will vary too and probably more so on a day-to-day basis then your working and "doing nothing" hours, your environment will vary, particularly by temperature which will affect what your body does to maintain internal equilibrium, and unless you eat exactly the same food at exactly the same time every day there are differences there: different foods take different amounts of time to digest, have their energy extracted, and have their waste pass on through, have different water content which adds to the natural variation in what you drink, different amounts of drugs (caffeine and alcohol for most people) that affect water intake/output in the body is an issue and so forth. There are extra complications for a woman: changing hormone levels over the course of their regular reproductive cycle can make quite a difference to water retention and hunger levels.
Basically: your body's routine does not follow an exact 24 hour cycle - this is why your weekly diet is a lot more predictable than your daily one, over the longer time the natural variances average out.
But we do have mechanisms that alter out hunger levels to try make sure things do even out over time. There are things that these mechanisms don't account for though: problems such as diabetes and other illnesses that affect energy absorption and use, and it is generally believed that a high sugar diet "breaks" these systems because they are geared towards slow-ish release foods and the energy in compact food high in small sugars is very quickly either used or stored away (so you have the energy ready for use, but you become hungry because the food is so easy to break down that it has already passed the parts that register hunger).
I monitor my intake very closely, having gone (over the last ~30 months) from ~18.5 stone to ~10 and wanting to stay somewhere near there. I weigh myself every day or two but only really watch a fortnightly average as a key value because I know there will be daily variations both that are due to either my routine not being very routine or sometimes are far less intuitively understandable.
It is actually easier for athletes because they can measure their extra calorie output with some accuracy, and if you are training a lot then this output is going to be more significant than the random daily variations. Their incoming diet is likely to be far more predictable than that of the man on the street too. I'm not an athlete by anyone's definition but I do exercise "recreationally" these days (mostly running, some strength/tone work, some cycling & walking for fun/exercise not just to suit commuting requirements) and I do notice the results being more predictable in periods when I do quite a bit of that compared to times when I do very little.
- TeMPOraL 11y ago> I think this is quite normal and why people recommend not measuring yourself every day. > I weigh myself every day or two but only really watch a fortnightly average as a key value(...) That's the key. I was always under the impression that the reason for advising people against weighing daily is because you can't rely on general population to understand the concepts of moving average and low-pass filtering. Personally, I try to weigh daily (easier to keep a habit this way), but I care only about the 7-day moving average.
- dspillett 11y agoThat is similar to my reasoning: I've kept to the changes I've made over the last couple of years by making them habit. My general morning routine, when I don't oversleep are am otherwise in more of a rush than usual, is now "wake up, feed the cat, lavatory, check and note mass, dress, breakfast while checking messages, go to work/other". Weighing myself weekly, or possibly even less often, would almost certainly suffice - but doing it more often keeps it habit and much reduces the risk that I'll simply stop doing it at some point. Similarly with exercise, while I don't have a fixed schedule except where there are things I do with a group of people I do try do something (sometimes something small, but not nothing) at least every other day. If something is a habit you notice when you miss it (your routine feels wrong because of the "forgotten something" feeling) which I find helps my self management. Of course you have to be careful not to care too much about the routine and the occasional missing something, or there is a risk it can become mentally unhealthy (which may be another reason people are careful about recommending daily measurements - it needs to become a habit not an obsession).
- jhallenworld 11y agoI've discovered that my sneaky digital scale has hysteresis: it shows the last reading unless the new reading is more than 1/2 pound different.
- TeMPOraL 11y agoAll bathroom scales are witchcraft. Analog ones always seem to have the precision of ±10kg and generate an aura of untrustworthiness around themselves. Digital ones behave as if they were haunted. Every once in a while, usually when the upward-opening crescent Moon passes through an astral node on the sky, my digital scale just picks one of two or three values at random. The values are around 1-2kg apart. I learned to just step on and off it until it either settles on a single result, or I get tired and just end up averaging last three or five measurements.