4 ms·
FBI Turns 18-Year-Old with an IQ of 51 into a Terrorist
- breitling 11y agoCan someone with more insight into this please explain if this can be considered entrapment? The suspect probably would have done or said nothing if it weren't for the "investigators".
- afarrell 11y agoHere is a webcomic drawn by an attourney which explains what entrapment actually is: http://lawcomic.net/guide/?p=633 http://lawcomic.net/guide/?p=633
- J_Darnley 11y agoWhy wouldn't you link to this page to start with? http://lawcomic.net/guide/?p=674 http://lawcomic.net/guide/?p=674 And I would've said that most of these plots foiled by the FBI come as close as possible to entrapment without actually being so. They provide means, methods, opportunities, and it seems in some cases plenty of motive but not the initial spark.
- afarrell 11y agoThat is a better page to link to. His site isn't really optimized for people to link to, so I just linked to the start of the entrapment sections.
- fnordfnordfnord 11y agoThat comic doesn't explain "what entrapment actually is" but rather it explains how a few trite but common misconceptions about the law as it pertains to those circumstances are not precisely entrapment. I don't think his reasoning is very good. ie: "It's amazing that this myth has stuck around so long when tons of undercover arrests prove it wrong every day" I'm not sure how an arrest can prove that since an arrest is not a finding of fact. IMO lawcomic is rather biased toward a prosecutor's definition of what s/he thinks the law ought to be. Maybe it's my own cognitive dissonance about the difference in what the law is and what I think it ought to be, but I don't have a favorable opinion of lawcomic. Now you've posted it here in defense of the prosecution of a mentally retarded man/child for an offence which he is probably incapable of committing without a non-trivial degree of assistance, and most likely would not have committed if he'd simply been left alone. Even though this case the prosecution may prevail in court, IMO it does not serve any useful purpose for the gov't to aggressively ferret out easily manipulable people by manipulating them until they sufficiently incriminate themselves.
- afarrell 11y ago> in defense of the prosecution I should clarify that I do not condone the actions of law enforcement here. I just think that I think lawcomic is an interesting introductory resource.
- Someone1234 11y agoMaybe we should just toss "terrorists" into the nearest river, if they float they're a terrorist and get hanged, if they sink, then they die but are innocent... Wait, no, that's the Salem witch trials, for some reason I always mix up terrorism accusations in 2015, and the Salem witch trials from 1692... A lot of these cases seem to come up. They seem to fall into two "camps," legitimately dangerous individuals collecting resources for a future event (guns, bombs, etc) and fishing expeditions where they try to borderline entrap the gullible or stupid. The question is: Do the agents not ever question what they're doing morally? If you need to talk someone into committing a crime are you really serving justice? And if you aren't serving justice then what is the point in any of it?
- fnordfnordfnord 11y ago>Do the agents not ever question what they're doing morally? Somewhat perhaps, but the victims are morally inferior to the agents, so the ends (career advancement for the morally superior agents) justify the means (unjust oppression of the inferior). It's a lot like when Islamist terrorists justify the killing of kafirs; but it's okay in this case because the injustice is committed by educated people wearing nice clothes, and for a good reason (justice!, or the children, maybe? or something else which I can't recall at the moment but I'm sure it's good for America).
- DanBC 11y agoCompare this to the case where someone with a learning difficulties[1] was groomed for terrorism purposes; they are clearly seen as the victim of a crime and the person doing the grooming is convicted of a crime. http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-32521780 http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-32521780 > Commander Richard Walton, head of the Metropolitan Police's Counter Terrorism Command, said: "We continue to appeal to anyone who may have knowledge of people with similar intentions. The earliest we can intervene to prevent terrorism the better. > "We also remind the public that there is currently a need to protect vulnerable or impressionable adults or children from this brand of Islamic extremism." There's lots of really terrible[2] things about the way the UK treats people with learning disability, but we try not to imprison them for stuff other people manipulated them into. [1] UK usage, this is taking over from "learning disability" because that community strongly rejects the disabled label. It used to be defined by low IQ. [2] Winterborn view, Mazars, etc etc. There's a long list of terrible care homes providing abusive horrible care.
- nitwit005 11y agoMy retarded uncle is really into military subjects and nazis. He has run up other people's phone bills calling 900 number white supremacist phone numbers. I didn't even know that was a thing until it happened. I gather white supremacist groups attract certain types of mental illness. I'm sure the Muslim version of him would be into jihad. Going to arrest a lot of people if you start locking them up...