3 ms·
I see two solutions. You can do nutrition studies on animals that are most like us. And you can study people in structured environments like the military, spa
by ars 11y ago
I see two solutions.
You can do nutrition studies on animals that are most like us.
And you can study people in structured environments like the military, space, or prison and accurately track what they eat.
- TeMPOraL 11y agoAnd the best option I think actually seems to be mass surveillance. Just take that somewhat structured environment, where people stay all the time, and surveil the shit out of it. Without telling the subjects. Task a group of people to objectively observe and note what is being eaten and how it affects people's health. A pure observation like this could provide a lot of useful data, that would be free from biases introduced by subjects underreporting things or simply changing their behaviour because they know they're being studied.
- deegles 11y agoHow about grocery store loyalty cards? A big study could be done by offering everyone a $x gift card if they fill out a survey about their family, get a baseline medical test and promise to get another one in say 1 year. Changes in diet could be induced by mailing them coupons for specific foods and tracking their use.
- TeMPOraL 11y agoAn interesting proposal, but I see following problems with it: - You have both zero control and zero objective input on what subjects are actually eating. They can ignore your coupons, they can lie or omit (by simply forgetting about) what they've eaten. They can buy stuff without using loyalty card (and probably will, in different stores - just how many people shop in one and only one store?). - The data would be very imprecise - while individuals would do the medical tests, unless you're targeting singles, their grocery shopping will go towards the household, and you have no idea who ate what. - I'm not confident that mailing them coupons would change their diet, unless you've got yourself either very poor, or very cooperative subject. The outcome I expect is that people would mostly ignore the coupons if they don't feel like eating the thing you want them to. In the end, while interesting, it seems less precise than the current questionnaire/journal/self-reporting based approach.