3 ms·
Because this happened: > Website owners should ensure that they secure their own website control panels, to ensure that new subdomains beyond their control are
by zamalek 11y ago
Because this happened:
> Website owners should ensure that they secure their own website control panels, to ensure that new subdomains beyond their control are not created without their knowledge.
You're a bank and haven't secured your DNS control panel correctly. Someone comes along, and using your vulnerable DNS, registers logon.bank.com (instead of login.bank.com). Now it is the bank's fault to begin with, but end-users are going to see that green padlock and will get pwned. You can point fingers all you want at the bank but that situation could (and should) have been avoided.
Let's Encrypt could be seen as a "vulnerability amplifier." With the previous PKI, even if you gained authority over logon.bank.com you wouldn't be able to get that green padlock in the title bar. There is a very good chance that someone at the CA would have made a phone call to someone at bank.com. With the current Let's Encrypt approach this scenario becomes plausible because no check is made with the parent domain to find out exactly how paranoid it is about subdomains.
Nobody is blaming Let's Encrypt, but they can help.
- pfg 11y agoIt's completely unclear whether what you're saying is factually correct. If the attacker controls the bank's DNS, which seems likely given that they're able to create an A record for a subdomain, they can likely also add TXT records for bank.com, which is what traditional CAs often use to verify ownership. They could probably also modify MX records to redirect confirmation emails to a server under their control. Other CAs don't have a magic solution that automatically detects malicious domains. Issuance of DV certs is completely automated at any major CA. There is no manual review unless the domain is on some kind of grey- or blacklist, and I highly doubt that they have a list of every domain used by a bank. There have been numerous counts of unauthorized certificates being issued by almost all CAs, what makes you think they're somehow that much more smarter than Let's Encrypt on this topic?
- eridius 11y agoThe green padlocks are only for EV certs. Let's Encrypt doesn't do EV certs (nobody automatically issues those). There's a reason why browsers visually distinguish between EV certs and DV certs, and it's because DV certs don't indicate anything at all beyond the fact that the cert owner is able to serve HTTPS at a given domain.