3 ms·
> Standardization and federation comes at a cost. At a cost that provides long term interopraibility benefits. But these just care about short term rip offs an
by shmerl 11y ago
> Standardization and federation comes at a cost.
At a cost that provides long term interopraibility benefits. But these just care about short term rip offs and as well causing interoperability problems for their users (i.e. preventing communication with other services). We must be extremely lucky this didn't stay like that for e-mail.
> they gain nothing by just being yet-another-protocol.
That's the point. They measure their gain in how much they can mess up their users (by preventing them from communicating with users of other services). While gain should be measured in how useful such services can become (enhancing, not crippling communication).
> That being said, Facebook does let you chat via Jabber
It's not federated (which defeats the main purpose).
> I use it (with Messenger on OSX), and it works, but it's a completely mediocre experience devoid of what makes FB Messenger special.
If they wanted to improve things and thought that XMPP can't reach that goal, they could propose their non XMPP chat as IETF standard. Same as Google could do with Hangouts and so on.
- gkoberger 11y agoGo find someone who uses Facebook Messenger and has never heard of Hacker News. Ask them if they care about interoperability. They won't understand the question. They have a FB app on their iPhone and facebook.com on their desktop, and they won't understand what you mean. If they want to message someone "on another service", they'll just use that other service.
- shmerl 11y ago> Go find someone who uses Facebook Messenger and has never heard of Hacker News. Ask them if they care about interoperability. Many do complain about it, but can't do much to fix it. People either end up installing 20 different clients to reach those who use other services (imagine installing 20 browsers to read different sites or 20 e-mail clients to use different e-mail accounts), or simply don't communicate with those users when that number grows annoyingly large. This problem affects everyone, and it's pretty apparent even to those who don't visit HN.
- drumdance 11y agoI don't install 20 different clients, and the ones I do install are ones where I want to keep things separate. I don't want Slack messages showing up in my Facebook messages. I don't want Facebook messages showing up in Apple Messages on OSX.
- matt_kantor 11y agoStandard protocols and interoperability do not preclude this. Plenty of people have separate work email addresses from their personal ones.
- shmerl 11y agoIndeed. Separation of accounts and profiles isn't really related to artificial separation of existing services which prevents interoperability. Accounts should be separable according to user's preferences, and not according to how services decided not to federate. It's pretty self explanatory.
- nl 11y agoAnd interestingly most people use separate clients for their work and personal email accounts.
- nl 11y agoI've replied up-thread about this, but while it's true that some people complain about it, many also see this as a strength. Plenty of people are quite happy to install 20 IM clients in order to keep different aspects of their life separate. If you doubt this, think back to the numerous HN threads where people complain about how they want to keep the Facebook profile separate to their LinkedIn profile. It's unclear why this is different.
- shmerl 11y agoYou are mixing up the need to separate accounts / identities (which even single client can easily do even for the same service), and artificial separation of services caused by the lack of interoperability. Those are completely unrelated issues (first is something that user should have a choice to do, second is something forced on the user). I explained it here as well: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10856612 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10856612
- TeMPOraL 11y agoYes, and go ask those same people about e-mail interop, and they'll again roll eyes at you. They don't care about it because they don't have a fucking clue. They're just happy it works. And it's ok. I don't have a clue about how the washing powder works, but I know I can clean any clothes with any powder. I am not an electrical engineer, but I know I can buy any random light bulb and I know it will work with any of my lamps. I know next to nothing about logistics, but I am confident that I can use the same address with any random company to have my package or letter delivered to a person. The world runs and grows on standardization. That's how we progressed from medieval times to industrial revolution! By standardizing tools and measures used in manufacturing! A lot of it we got by accidents of history. Now it needs to be forced against the market. It has to be, and those of us who have a clue need to fight for it. What's sad is that the new wave of companies try to transplant their greedy and egotistic ideas from the world of software back to the real world. Any light bulb compatible with any lamp? That's about to become a thing of the past, thanks to the IoT bullshit.
- finnn 11y agoTwo days ago, the first day of the quarter, our professor put us in groups and told us to exchange contact info. For reasons surpassing my understanding, they all hated email, someone suggested Facebook, but not everyone was on it. Someone suggested iMessage, again, not everyone was on it, so we ended up using SMS. An interoperable standard.