2 ms·
You engage me in a semantics debate in a condescending tone and then are wrong. Manslaughter does not require 'intent to commit harm'. Yes, there are prosecuti
by shkkmo 11y ago
You engage me in a semantics debate in a condescending tone and then are wrong. Manslaughter does not require 'intent to commit harm'.
Yes, there are prosecutions of reckless/negligent drivers. However, the fact remains:
1) Most traffic fatalities are the result of human error.
2) Most traffic fatalities do not result in prosecution.
I can't find numbers to back up #2 but this semi-anecdotal evidence is telling:
http://www.wnyc.org/story/283394-killed-while-cycling-why-so-few-fatal-bike-crashes-lead-to-arrest-in-nyc/ http://www.wnyc.org/story/283394-killed-while-cycling-why-so...
This quote in particular makes my point:
> “We as a society have chosen to drive these big cars," said Joe McCormack, Assistant District Attorney for the Bronx. It’s his job to prosecute traffic crimes. "And we also as a society have chosen not to criminalize every single small mistake that just has a dramatic consequence because you're driving a car,” he said.
- tptacek 11y agoI think it's actually you who have decided on the semantic debate, since the reason we don't charge lots of people with felonies for killing people with cars is pretty apparent from the comment I just wrote. I also don't think you read my comment carefully. As a reset: here's what the state must prove in a manslaughter case: First, the defendant unlawfully killed someone; Second, while in a sudden quarrel or heat of passion, caused by adequate provocation: a) the defendant intentionally killed someone; or b) the defendant killed name of victim recklessly with extreme disregard for human life; and Heat of passion may be provoked by fear, rage, anger or terror. Provocation, in order to be adequate, must be such as might arouse a reasonable and ordinary person to kill someone. Maybe you'd rather look at a vehicular manslaughter statute? Here you go, California's: To prove that the defendant is guilty of this crime, the People must prove that: 1. The defendant (drove under the influence of (an alcoholic beverage/ [or] a drug) [or under the combined influence of an alcoholic beverage and a drug]/drove while having a blood alcohol level of 0.08 or higher/drove under the influence of (an alcoholic beverage/ [or] a drug) [or under the combined influence of an alcoholic beverage and a drug] when under the age of 21/ drove while having a blood alcohol level of 0.05 or higher when under the age of 21); 2. While driving that vehicle under the influence of (an alcoholic beverage/ [or] a drug) [or under the combined influence of an alcoholic beverage and a drug], the defendant also committed (a/an) (misdemeanor[,]/ [or] infraction[,]/ [or] otherwise lawful act that might cause death); 3. The defendant committed the (misdemeanor[,]/ [or] infraction[,]/ [or] otherwise lawful act that might cause death) with gross negligence; AND 4. The defendant’s grossly negligent conduct caused the death of another person. This describes only a tiny percentage of vehicular fatalities. Again: we don't prosecute people for errors. We prosecute them for doing things intentionally, or, as I said, for causing grave harm recklessly.
- shkkmo 11y agoI didn't intend to engage in a semantics debate and I did read your comment carefully. You might carefully re-read your comment to see how I got that impression. > we don't prosecute people for errors. We prosecute them for doing things intentionally, or, as I said, for causing grave harm recklessly. We usually don't prosecute for intentional errors. That is precisely the problem: we are far to lax with incompetent/reckless drivers. Do you think that if the costs associated with causing injury/death due to your own 'errors' were higher, we wouldn't see more careful drivers?
- tptacek 11y agoYou asked why the lack of criminal prosecutions for automobile fatalities wasn't a "failure of justice". I answered, and answered again, and now answer yet again: because our system of justice generally avoids prosecuting people for things that aren't crimes.
- shkkmo 11y agoYour argument appears to be: 1) We don't prosecute people for things that aren't crimes. 2) Thus our system and standards for prosecuting people for things that are crimes is just. I don't see the step from 1) to 2). I would guess you are making the following assumptions that I would disagree with: a) We do a adequate job of enforcing the current laws. (Prosecutions tend to be fairly rare due to low priority and lack of investigative resources) b) The current laws on the books are just. (The standards for recklessness are weighted toward DUIs and tend to exclude other types of intentional misconduct.)
- tptacek 11y agoNo. You've shifted the goalposts. You began the thread by trying to argue that a lack of prosecutions for vehicular fatalities was evidence of injustice. But it isn't: it's evidence for the fact that most traffic fatalities don't involve conduct we recognize as criminal. Now you'd like to litigate whether we should pass laws that criminalize more kinds of driver error. I'm not interested in that discussion, and I don't have to be, because it's not germane to the argument you made up thread, except in a Calvinball kind of way.