5 ms·
Ah microwave beamed rockets. Such a wonderful sounding idea, and yet so difficult to pull off. For those of you who know Keith Hensen his Solar Power Satellites
by ChuckMcM 11y ago
Ah microwave beamed rockets. Such a wonderful sounding idea, and yet so difficult to pull off. For those of you who know Keith Hensen his Solar Power Satellites are best launched into orbit with laser powered (or more generally ground powered) rockets. And the concept is mathematically sound, just the notion of having a multi-gigawatt laser pointed up at things in orbit is so destabilizing.
The summary for this link and for ground powered rockets in general, is that the amount of energy you can get out of an Hydrogen/Oxygen reduction reaction is about about it as far as chemicals go, but you can combine a lot of energy sources into a single transmission beam and if you can transfer that energy to your propellent you can do much better in terms of rocket efficiency.
The diplomatic challenge is that you need to be able to create a large directed beam of energy that you can steer at orbital (or near orbital) velocities that can reach into space. And while it is great when you're pointing it at some heat exchanger which is converting heat to thrust, its rather unfortunate if the target is a satellite just going by overhead taking pictures perhaps.
So really, in the current political climate, it's a non-starter. Not from a physics point of view but from a stir up the rest of the world point of view.
- beamatronic 11y agoCould you not hide a powerful ground-based laser anywhere you have a significant existing infrastructure? If there was one at say, Area 51, would we have any way to know?
- VLM 11y agoEven with local power storage the grid demand would be noteworthy and you'd notice some impressive power lines going into the desert just to keep up with average demand. Even if 99% of the transmitted signal were absorbed, the reflected signal would be staggering, strongest signal you'd detect on the ground, probably. The world has a couple radio fences at Graves and some NAVSPASUR sites which broadcast (well) under a megawatt continuous and are pretty trivial to detect when a satellite blows thru the fan shaped beam. Then again, who's listening on (obscure microwave ISM frequency) for 10 minutes at 2am one night. Possibly no one would notice. The existing fences are well within the ability of serious ham radio operators to use for meteor scatter predictions and stuff like that. Supposedly when the fences hit the moon its quite a bloop of signal, so I've heard. As a side note its funny to try and estimate the total wattage of millimeter wave magnetrons and solid state power amps manufactured to date by humanity and compare to the plan, its depressing. Lets say someone with a three letter agency outright bought the entire production line at triquint... Even optimistically how many millenia would it take to produce the GW required? Hmm... In this way the idea is very manhattan project like in that the hard part isn't deciding to do it or even getting the cash, but building the infrastructure to build the infrastructure two maybe three layers down to finally build the actual device. You would notice if "they" did this at area 51 because of the world wide shortage in foundry capacity followed by a staggering production glut. The world wide famine of stuff you need to build the stuff you need to build the foundry to make the amplifiers would be noticed. OK so the entire world supply of machines to build positioners that are used in foundaries has disappeared from the market, interesting. Something everyone is very careful not to discuss is a very small scale like a hypersonic anti-missile missile for a naval ship is "reasonable-ish" or less unreasonable anyway. Rather than talking about mach 25 orbits of tons, or building naval ships to carry dozens of mach 5 self propelled interceptor missiles, why not build naval ships that carry hundreds, even thousands, of microwave boosted mach 5 interceptors? And speaking of death beams, strategic scale will be hard to build, but something that can near vaporize an incoming sea skimming cruise missile guidance electronics is much more scalable / reasonable. I would imagine Somali style boarders would find the RF to be unpleasant. So the emitter array will be dual purpose. So I suspect there's something like this system installed and operating at a very small cheap scale at some naval research facility right now. Area 51 was all about the air force. Now if I disappear after posting this, we'll know I was at least partially correct...
- stcredzero 11y agoI would imagine Somali style boarders would find the RF to be unpleasant. So the emitter array will be dual purpose. There are already truck mounted microwave systems that are tuned to cause immense pain on your skin, for crowd control.
- wiz21 11y agoIs it me or we already have other of ways to blow satellites ? Such as : a rocket that just happens to go in the wrong direction, a missile, another satellite that goes in the wrong direction...
- pixl97 11y agoShooting a rocket at something in space is very obvious, akin to shooting someone in a crowd with a canon. Everybody that is not deaf and blind (sensor arrays or radar of some type in this case) is going to notice. Changing the orbit of another satellite is very noticeable too. Much like if you were in the desert and a car came over the horizon straight at you, you'd have a very long time to do something about it. A heat beam is a little more concerning. It is a threat that presents itself in seconds, not minutes or days. If it happens at a point where you don't have your own IR optics watching space you could miss it and be very confused as to what occurred to your sat.
- extrapickles 11y agoNot hitting other satellites is actually a service that the US Gov already provides if you are pointing large lasers in the sky (see the laser clearinghouse). They give a the laser operator a set of windows in which they will not hit a sat if they turned the laser on. The bigger challenge is while microwave emitters are cheaper, the beam director becomes quite expensive as it has to be massive (thanks to diffraction). Even with lasers, your final optics need to be big, but still easy enough to move at orbital velocities (think something like what telescopes used to track regular rocket launches use). What the article didn't mention, is you will need 2 ground power sites. The first one applies most of the energy needed to get into orbit, and the second site, located over the horizon from first, circularizes/finalizes the orbit. This makes site selection much harder as you need to find 2 places that are not too close, yet not too far, both with little weather to get in the way. Disclaimer: I'm involved with a company that does laser power transmission/laser rocket research