4 ms·
So the idea is that private enterprises are able to run refugee centers cheaper and more efficiently than the government. Unfortunately, it doesn't work and is
by bjourne 11y ago
So the idea is that private enterprises are able to run refugee centers cheaper and more efficiently than the government. Unfortunately, it doesn't work and is a myth. It's a myth that fits hacker news because we are all entrepreneurs here..
Private companies have just as much waste as the government. One random example: Pension funds. The private ones are all more expensive than the government run ones. A share of the income needs to go to marketing and profits -> higher prices. Common sense.
All across the board it is the same situation, and it has been shown in study after study. Health care, train operators, retirement homes, banks, military... , banks.. When private enterprises take over prices go up and the service level goes down. Again, it's common sense, a number of private companies fighting for market share and profits are more wasteful than one government organization run with zero profit.
I forgot. One counter-example is telecom which has benefited from privatization. But it is an area in which a lot has happened in the last two decades so it is not clear privatization is the sole cause of it.
I was asked for links:
http://www.sns.se/sites/default/files/konkurrensens_konsekvenser_pod_2.pdf http://www.sns.se/sites/default/files/konkurrensens_konsekve...
http://www.su.se/om-oss/press-media-nyheter/pressmeddelande-arkiv/sjuksk%C3%B6terskors-arbetstrivsel-f%C3%B6rs%C3%A4mras-efter-privatisering-1.7179 http://www.su.se/om-oss/press-media-nyheter/pressmeddelande-...
http://www.railwaysarchive.co.uk/documents/McNulty_InterimReport2010.pdf http://www.railwaysarchive.co.uk/documents/McNulty_InterimRe...
Maybe use Google Translate to read them.
- arvinjoar 11y agoCan you point me to, let's say, three of these studies?
- stevesearer 11y agoWould love to see the studies you reference. I'd wager a guess that in some cases prices would rise when private enterprise take over because the government run enterprises are operating at a loss and making up the difference with taxpayer dollars (Amtrak).
- jazzyk 11y agoThe issue is not necessarily ownership, it is the existence of competition. Unfortunately, for most (all?) government services, there is no competition - hence the inefficiencies. But private companies are prone to the same, if they don;t operate in markets open enough.
- legulere 11y agoCompetition can also mean inefficiency. A good example is the comparison of the mobile network infrastructure in Sweden and Germany: In lower populated regions you will usually only find one network called Sweden. It's a cooperation of the mobile providers that allows them to save money by not deploying infrastructure four times. In Germany such cooperation is forbidden because it's considered anti-competitive. Subsequently mobile service in Sweden is both better and cheaper, even with a way worse situation (lower population density). Every time you have competition you have the inefficiency to have some structures several times.
- jazzyk 11y agoYou picked a very specific segment (infrastructure-based services), but in that segment, the "public roads" model needs to be applied: just like roads are public, and used by private cars and private trucking companies for a fee (usually taxes or tolls). Same should apply to cable/fiber networks - the municipality owns the infrastructure, and there is only one cable = no need to dig up the town three times over.
- ersii 11y agoPlease elaborate on your random example, being "pension funds". What pension funds are you talking about? Are you talking about AP7 (Which has two funds, one equity fund and one money market fund)? (Swedish: "Sjunde Allmäna Pensionsfonden" English: "The 7th General Pension Fund"). I would caution you to be less general and provide more specific statements that you back up by facts. Currently it's hard to realize what you're trying to convey and the provided documents aren't solidifying what you're trying to convey either. Speaking of the provided links, here are some context of the documents: 1) The "konkurrensens_konsekvenser_pod_2.pdf" document is in Swedish and has the title "Konkurrensens konsekvenser" (English: "The consequences of competition"). The document is 279 pages. 2) The su.se link is a press release from SU (Stockholm University) with the title "Pressmeddelande: Sjuksköterskors arbetstrivsel försämras efter privatisering" (English: "Press release: Nurses work satisfaction worsened after privatization") and it's announcing an article published in "Journal of Occupational and Organizational Psychology, 82, 45-65" by Falkenberg, H., Näswall, K., Sverke, M., and Sjöberg, A. (2009) by the name "How are employees at different levels affected by privatization? A longitudinal study of two Swedish hospitals" (Article in English). 3) The "McNulty_InterimReport2010.pdf" document is in English and has the title "Rail Value for Money Study: Interim Submission to Secretary of State – September 2010". The document is 28 pages.
- bjourne 11y agoThe studies all support what I wrote. I guess you have to read them in full or find their abstract and read that. Regarding the pension funds, yes AP7 is one example. It is the fund with the lowest management fee (incidentally has also been one of the highest yielding pension funds). The usual excuse given is that it is a "lazy fund" and "just following the index". But no private actor has been able to offer a similar "lazy fund" with lower fees.
- seivan 11y agoDoes AP7 beat Stockholm index? Which is free on most Swedish brokerages. Actually on NordNet all Scandinavian index-funds are free. You're asking me to believe that a government run by Kaplan, Romsson, 100-dagar-Fridolin and that SSU-Douche who stole money will be the "competent" part in your equation? There is no black and white. Sometimes smart people in government do better. Sometimes entrepreneurs do better. You're biased from growing up with intelligent people running Sweden and believe that to still be the case. Sanandaji would like a word with you.... Both Avanza and NordNet allows you to get free Index-funds. When I say free I mean with no courtage or cut from profits. No costs.
- bjornsing 11y agoEquating profits with waste is just plain wrong. Profits are economic resources that can be directed toward other uses, while wasteful spending is just that: economic resources essentially destroyed.