3 ms·
You're not wrong, though there's more than that. I never understood the "game of skill" argument, though. Pure gambling (e.g., flipping a coin) has no skill wha
by basseq 11y ago
You're not wrong, though there's more than that. I never understood the "game of skill" argument, though. Pure gambling (e.g., flipping a coin) has no skill whatsoever. Due to the chaotic nature of the world, nothing is pure skill (simple commerce, e.g., still has small risk). Poker, online sports, etc. has an element of skill to it, but also an element of risk. I can run endless statistics on blackjack hands to improve my odds of winning, but they're still odds. In the same way, DFS power players can have a massive advantage, but if Tom Brady breaks his collarbone in the first quarter, it's still luck. You are gambling that your skills are better than the other guy's (and the chaotic nature of the universe won't screw you).
I think DFS fails in two ways:
1. Corruption - All the stories in the last 6 months about FanDuel employees using insider knowledge to gain an edge on DraftKings, for example. That is screwing the fan, pure and simple.
2. Creating a Predatory Environment - The issue here is allowing power players to "rape and pillage regular players". In the same way that I'm not going to enter the WSOP, I'm going to have a much better experience playing against those at my skill level.
You could probably throw "false advertising" in there, too, but we'll let the FCC deal with that.
- maqr 11y ago> I never understood the "game of skill" argument, though. I'm not sure if this is really on-topic, but I think you'll find this interesting if you're not aware of it: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Skill_testing_question https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Skill_testing_question
- Spooky23 11y agoYou're missing the corruption of the game angle as well. Fantasy sports is worse than most forms of gambling because the scope of stakeholders is so broad. With lots of legit, liquid money in play, it doesn't take a rocket scientist to figure out that you can corrupt players and coaches to massage the stats, or those same players and coaches can participate through proxies. With horse racing, which is the closest thing to this stuff, there are a few different sets of stakeholders with different interests. Owners, trainers and jockeys who are cheating are pretty easy to identify. End of the day, you're better off trusting the dice.