3 ms·
Because it's based in faith that something will happen, not a rational determination based on facts on hand.
by moron4hire 11y ago
Because it's based in faith that something will happen, not a rational determination based on facts on hand.
- AndrewKemendo 11y agoWhat? We are actually building this stuff... It's about as much faith as Doug Englebart had about the PC.
- moron4hire 11y agoNo, we're building ELIZA with larger databases. You can't take any research we have on hand today and say "a natural extension of this leads to consciousness". Part of that is because we don't even understand what consciousness is. Part of that is because we don't have any realistic work beyond pattern matching. That's why it's not rational. There is no fact you can exploit to come to this conclusion. That's called "faith", regardless of the particular subject matter. A little faith is important. We didn't know if the first astronauts would survive orbit, and we didn't really have any data to prove it unequivocally. We just had faith that our limited understanding wasn't missing anything and the only way we could find out would be to put people in orbit. We found out soon enough. But it's really, really a bad idea to call something rational when it's really faith, just because you don't want to be associated with religion.
- AndrewKemendo 11y ago"a natural extension of this leads to consciousness" Did I say that? In fact I didn't. I don't care what you call anything, the fact remains that AGI doesn't exist today, but we can work on the best guesses at what we think will get us there. That is the exact OPPOSITE of faith if there ever was one. We are working on computer vision with segmentation. That's a tiny subsection of supervised learning. By the way you say pattern matching as though it's some trivial thing. In fact that's what a hefty portion of our brain does to understand anything - so it's actually very important and our visual system (eyeball to cortex to representation) is arguably the most important part of that. I couldn't care less about whether a computer has consciousness anyway. I think the whole consciousness argument is a waste of time (which is why I called it a rabbit hole previously). I think you're hung up on this religious thing and not able to discriminate between actually building things that may be able to lead to AGI versus writing novels and daydreaming like so many "futurists."