4 ms·
> Of course small phones would fare badly when nothing good is for sale! It sounds like you're treating the introduction of new phone models as an exogenous ev
by jessriedel 11y ago
> Of course small phones would fare badly when nothing good is for sale!
It sounds like you're treating the introduction of new phone models as an exogenous event, but that's crazy. That's like saying "Of course people don't ride horse-and-buggies any more; hardly anybody make them! That doesn't mean cars are the future."
If manufacturers are introducing fewer models, it's because there is reduced demand for them.
- Eric_WVGG 11y agoYou need some period of overlap in order to measure reduced demand. If every horse dropped dead the day cars went on sale, that says nothing about reduced demand for horses. Thank you for introducing me to the word "exogenous"
- sigmar 11y agoThe samsung note was released in 2011. I'm not sure what the average upgrade cycle is at the moment, but IMHO that seems like sufficient overlap that owners of the original note would have returned to smaller phones if they preferred them. They don't.
- maccard 11y agoAnecdotally - I would guess between 2 and 3 years based on the habits of my friends family and colleagues.
- AJ007 11y agoTrying to switch back to a smaller screen is tough, even if you didn't want a big phone to begin with. Often I don't want to have a huge phone with me at all, but then I don't have a choice. The long term may be some sort of personal communicator (watch or otherwise.) Small screen, advanced input when necessary by voice. When people want to read things, write messages, watch video, play games, etc, then they can pick up their phablet -- which is effectively a phone sized tablet that fits in your pocket. The Apple Watch probably is the step towards this direction. However, because it needs the iPhone it misses the full use case, for the moment.
- delinka 11y agoI think your argument has missed how this particular market has worked in the last nine years. People flock to the "new hotness" every year not because they demanded its features, but simply because it's the new hotness. Only afterward do they realize that this new big phone isn't what they wanted. But the companies pushing ever larger phones don't produce a new hot small model. Then they eliminate the old models slowly. It's only when the new hot phone comes in a variety of sizes that we will know what the demand truly is. Back when cars were supplanting the horse-drawn carriage, people had choice for years. Even today, if you prefer, you can get a horse and the carriage to drive around in. But you can't find specialty shops building that small phone you want.
- jandrese 11y agoAlso, people flock to the "new hotness" because it is what is supported. If you try to find a small Android phone today you're going to be stuck on some ancient version of the OS with no upgrade or security fix options and probably iffy support for newer technologies like LTE. It's hard to keep a smartphone for more than a couple of years because the industry moves on and drops you like a hot potato.
- Arnt 11y agoThat's good justification for there being few such models, but I see no decent small phones. http://www.heise.de/preisvergleich/?cat=umtsover&asd=on&asuch=hand&xf=2249_55~148_Android~152_3 http://www.heise.de/preisvergleich/?cat=umtsover&asd=on&asuc... says that right now, android phones up to 55m width have at most 512MB RAM, so they'll be sluggish or worse.
- cbr 11y agoAre the "mini" versions of the flagships (64mm) too big? http://www.gsmarena.com/samsung_galaxy_s5_mini-6252.php http://www.gsmarena.com/samsung_galaxy_s5_mini-6252.php http://www.gsmarena.com/htc_one_mini_2-6345.php http://www.gsmarena.com/htc_one_mini_2-6345.php
- Arnt 11y agoThe iphone was 58mm, right? Those are about 10% bigger than that, so IMO they are too big to be used in an argument about small phones.
- bobajeff 11y ago>If manufacturers are introducing fewer models, it's because there is reduced demand for them. That assumes manufacturers solely pay attention to demand before making and selling a device. Which is wrong. They pay attention to what carriers want. Which is usually what will help them sell expensive data plans. Also, companies care about what Samsung is selling. In Samsung's case they care about what components they themselves supply to other companies (SoC's, OLED's etc.). So it's in their best interest to keep them in demand.