10 ms·
No. The Federal Circuit has subject matter jurisdiction, not geographic jurisdiction. Their decisions are binding precedent throughout the United States.
by bitwize 11y ago
No. The Federal Circuit has subject matter jurisdiction, not geographic jurisdiction. Their decisions are binding precedent throughout the United States.
- rayiner 11y agoThey don't have subject matter jurisdiction over copyright. Their decision on a copyright case isn't binding in other circuits.
- josaka 11y agoI think that is correct. This case is a little misleading because there were both patent and copyright claims at the district court level. As a result of the patent claims, the Federal Circuit had jurisdiction over the entire case, even though the copyright claims were to be adjudicated under 9th Circuit precedent. If they had only brought copyright claims, this appeal would have been heard at the 9th Circuit Court of Appeals.