3 ms·
Google did a clean-room implementation of copied APIs. Those APIs are licensed under two licenses, and Google chose neither. All you need to do is choose one an
by pron 11y ago
Google did a clean-room implementation of copied APIs. Those APIs are licensed under two licenses, and Google chose neither. All you need to do is choose one and comply with it.
All the ruling means is that if you copy an API you should either comply with the license (Google didn't comply with either possible licenses) or don't, but have a good fair-use defense, such as non-profit use and/or interoperability (neither applies to Android, but that hasn't been ruled yet).
Now let me say this again: It has been in Google's best interest to keep people's confused about the ramifications of this court case, because Oracle's legal's department is fierce, and if you believe that they might come after you, too, you'll support Google's position. The reality is that whichever side you're on and regardless of the outcome, the ruling in this court case will not apply to the rest of the industry (because Google's use of Java's API was very unusual).
- icebraining 11y agoGoogle's use of Java's API was very unusual How is it different from any other reimplementation of an existing API?
- pron 11y agoBecause usually reimplementations are done in a way that would allow programs/libraries written for the original platform run on your platform, i.e. reimplementations are usually done in a way that makes them drop-in replacements to the original as much as possible. That is not the case with Android. Running existing Java programs is a non-goal, and reusing libraries is only a goal as long as it helps Android's separate ecosystem (Java libraries -- for any Java standard -- work on Android only if they happen to use the subset of APIs implemented by Android; this is not due to any real limitations or lack of developer resources, but simply because being a drop-in or near-drop-in replacement for Java is not a goal for Android). I will note again that Google is free to use OpenJDK however they like -- they don't need to be compatible or anything -- as long as they comply with the GPL license.