3 ms·
Anyone is free to fork OpenJDK, as long as they don't call the result Java (unless they fork and choose to pass the TCK). The situation is no different from oth
by nl 11y ago
Anyone is free to fork OpenJDK, as long as they don't call the result Java (unless they fork and choose to pass the TCK). The situation is no different from other large open-source projects.
Unless I'm missing something, this is no longer the case. Oracle is arguing that they own the API and the only legal implementation is theirs (ie, Java). Just renaming is (say... "Android") is insufficient.
Forking is going to be legally on very shaky ground at least.
- matharmin 11y agoOracle does own copyright on the APIs (according to the Federal Circuit), but they do provide it in OpenJDK under the GPL. That means anyone is free to fork it, under the terms of the GPL. What Google did was copy the APIs, remove the copyright notice (arguing the APIs aren't copyrightable), and release the code under a different license. You can't do that under the GPL terms.
- curt15 11y agoPublic Knowledge, an ally of the FSF, actually recommends independent implementation (like what Google did with Java and glibc) as a method for escaping the GPL: >If a developer does not want to be subject to the licensing terms of a library, he has a few options...Another option for a developer is to do what Google did when it created Android, and create replacement code libraries that are compatible with the existing code libraries, but which are new copyrighted works. Being "compatible" in this context means that the new libraries are called in the same way that the old libraries are--that is, using the same APIs. But the actual copyrighted code that is being called is a new work. https://www.publicknowledge.org/news-blog/blogs/gpl-does-not-depend-copyrightability-apis https://www.publicknowledge.org/news-blog/blogs/gpl-does-not...
- merb 11y agoForking is totally legal. You need to do some things however. Don't call it OpenJDK since OpenJDK is copyrighted. Don't remove the Copyright inside the files. License new code as the same license as applied to OpenJDK. If that is happening you are completely free.