5 ms·
I really am not a fan of the hyperminimalistic "we can do anything trust us!" landing pages that every text-for-personal-assistant seems to think is brilliant m
by minimaxir 11y ago
I really am not a fan of the hyperminimalistic "we can do anything trust us!" landing pages that every text-for-personal-assistant seems to think is brilliant marketing copy.
There are examples of Magic+ requests, but no real-world examples of outcomes and whether the request was filled successfully to the customer's satisfaction.
Relatedly, the $100/hr is suspicious because it's impossible to audit the time spent by the assistant. (Contrast with flat fees stated upfront from the normal service.)
- seangrant 11y agoI feel like the whole thing is being oversold. They're making huge claims on this page and I have no idea whether or not they're true. > Never says no > Hits 100% of promises and expectations I'm sure these are achievable...
- patmcc 11y agoGiven unlimited funds, anything possible is easy for the guy writing the cheque. If I was willing to foot the bill, you could probably do any of the example magics listed (assuming you had my details/logins to email/calendar) in an hour or two.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- Reedx 11y agoYeah, pretty hyperbolic. There are a lot of cases where they will have to say no or "sorry, we'll have to set that up for another time". Some requests are simply not always possible. To pick one of their examples: "I need to rent out the Exploratorium this weekend." What if someone already rented it out? Or it's under construction? Or there's a special event? Or *?
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- Nadya 11y ago>Anything you want. As long as it’s not illegal. Seriously. I think murder falls under the illegal category of exception.
- derefr 11y agoI wonder whether one could use Magic to hire a prostitute in Nevada, given that they're a California company presumably incorporated in Delaware. Which is a more localized version of the question I really want to ask: if Magic ever expands outside of the US, could I use it to order Cuban cigars to be shipped to Canada from Cuba? The US would never have to import them—so no illegal/trade-sanctioned act is occurring—but an American company is still profiting from the exchange.
- tempestn 11y agoAren't Cuban goods legal in the US now? Ah, apparently only sort of: http://www.washingtonexaminer.com/can-you-buy-cuban-cigars-now/article/2567534 http://www.washingtonexaminer.com/can-you-buy-cuban-cigars-n...
- Someone1234 11y agoWhere's the "Uber of assassins" when you them?
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- cmikec 11y agoThanks for bringing this up. We've adjusted these bullet points to make them more accurate.
- cmikec 11y agoThanks for the feedback. Magic has been in an interesting position as a startup ever since our website went viral in Feb. 2015. Starting then, we've had more demand than supply for our product every single day. That's why we never iterated our original landing page -- marketing was never our biggest problem, in fact it was our smallest. That said, I completely agree with you, that there would be much more powerful ways of communicating that you can trust us. Most of our signups come from word of mouth from real users at this point though, so it's not as much of an issue. For our $100/hr Magic+ product, we display detailed reports daily to users that show exactly how time was used down to the second. I agree that communicating this correctly is key. If you're interested in trying it, I'd love to hear your feedback on how we display this information.
- bby 11y agocan you show us an example of such a detailed report, without us having to use the service? thx
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- daurnimator 11y agoEasy enough to send a link to a webpage. Or ask you for your email to send it to you.
- cmikec 11y agoCurrently these reports are sent via email. We may have an app at some point in the future, but currently SMS and email are more than sufficient.
- thecrazyone 11y agoA screenshot would suffice, no? Looks like you're dodging the question.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- Kiro 11y agoMagic was the first though. All the other hyperminimalistic landing pages are just copies.