4 ms·
> Both Ripple and SCP create money out of thin air. So does fiat, and fiat works. It may not work well all the time for 100% of use cases, but in general it wo
by geofft 11y ago
> Both Ripple and SCP create money out of thin air.
So does fiat, and fiat works. It may not work well all the time for 100% of use cases, but in general it works well.
As long as the mechanisms by which money is created out of thin air are well-understood by the people receiving this money (which they are for fiat) and the recipients give informed consent to that (which they... sorta do for fiat), this doesn't seem like a negative.
- bduerst 11y agoPrecisely - most major currencies today ditched their deflationary practices in the 20th century.
- kang 11y agoSo does paypal. I was comparing decentralized currencies.
- geofft 11y agoBut why is creating money out of thin air bad, regardless of whether a currency is centralized or decentralized? (Other than that it sounds scary.)
- XorNot 11y agoFiat money works because governments pay for services in it, and demand taxes in it. If you are not a government, fiat money does not work for you.* * Quasi-government entities have a long history of issuing currency like this - company scrip was one such practice, but its important to note that this is a situation of a company becoming more government-like.
- geofft 11y agoI'm a little confused, I think I paid for groceries last night in fiat currency and I certainly got goods in exchange for them, and I don't believe the grocery store was run by the government. Can you clarify what you mean by "does not work for you"? I suspect we mean different things by the phrase.
- XorNot 11y agoThe general "you". You (some entity) can't issue your own fiat currency successfully unless you are sufficiently government-like.
- geofft 11y agoSure, but a) I have no interest in issuing Bitcoin or any other currency, just using it as long as it works, and b) if I were to issue an altcoin, I would be creating money out of thin air!