3 ms·
If I may rephrase (and steelman) the parent's point: Reality does not neatly format itself for easy plug-and-chug into your formulas. To appropriately respond
by SilasX 11y ago
If I may rephrase (and steelman) the parent's point:
Reality does not neatly format itself for easy plug-and-chug into your formulas. To appropriately respond to reality, you must be good at recognizing when there's a mapping to a well-tested formula, technique, or phenomenon.
Therefore, if you require problems to be phrased in a way such that that's already done, that means you're not good at that domain; blaming the phrasing of the problem is missing the point.
Indeed, 90% of the mental work lies in recognizing such isomorphisms, not in cranking through the algorithm once it's recognized, and this is a hard skill to teach. (Schools that teach how to attack word problems have to rely on crude word-match techniques to identify e.g. when you want to subtract vs add vs divide.)