4 ms·
Refreshing to see a critique talking alternatives instead of another fanboy post on Bitcoin's blockchain. Monoculture is a good word for it. Almost all the rese
by nickpsecurity 11y ago
Refreshing to see a critique talking alternatives instead of another fanboy post on Bitcoin's blockchain. Monoculture is a good word for it. Almost all the research and attention is going in one direction when there are many valid directions worth exploring with fewer issues than Bitcoin. Some leverage proven approaches in finance, databases, or transaction processing. Just need extensions, more analysis, open implementations, etc.
So, I look forward to more articles like this to draw attention to solutions other than Bitcoin architecture. Another thing I look forward to are links to interesting alternatives like SCP and Interledger in this. I haven't reviewed them yet but brief descriptions seemed more exciting than "Cut-and-Pasted-Coin launched yesterday while promising to change the world."
- kanzure 11y ago> Another thing I look forward to are links to interesting alternatives like SCP Some "see also" on that topic, then .... https://www.reddit.com/r/Bitcoin/comments/3u1m36/why_arent_we_as_a_community_talking_about/cxbamhn https://www.reddit.com/r/Bitcoin/comments/3u1m36/why_arent_w... http://diyhpl.us/wiki/transcripts/scalingbitcoin/sharding-the-blockchain/ http://diyhpl.us/wiki/transcripts/scalingbitcoin/sharding-th... https://github.com/vbuterin/scalability_paper/blob/master/scalability.pdf https://github.com/vbuterin/scalability_paper/blob/master/sc... (Unless you don't mean the SCP that was presented during Scaling Bitcoin Hong Kong, and rather the other more widely known SCP....)
- nickpsecurity 11y agoAppreciate the links. Those are interesting ideas on reducing the load and increasing the speed. NatanealL's idea is closer to how I'm looking at it because I'm starting with our current model and trying to improve its deficiencies. Banks already manage their own transactions and records while interbank operations deal in huge chunks. Prevents need of global verification of individual transactions. Plus, knocking out the miners and leveraging stored value in an existing currency can simplify things by removing some obstacles they discuss. Bitcoin's problem is a lot harder than the general problem of decentralized payments and contracts on cash-backed currency. I prefer to stick to the latter as it solves todays problems pretty well.
- brighton36 11y agoIf there's no work - it's not a blockchain. Distributed ledgers are a completely parrallel movement that was taken up by those who wanted to leverage the marketing momentum of blockchain, for their own database projects. Which is fine, but shouldn't get confused with blockchain innovations.
- mikeyouse 11y agoThere can be proof-of-stake blockchains, proof-of-use, proof-of-minimum-aged-time, etc. etc. The blockchain is just a chain of blocks, there are innumerable ways to protect it, verify it, and distribute the data.
- wmf 11y agoBut a bunch of the "blockchain blockchain blockchain" startups don't use proof of anything.
- brighton36 11y agoIf the blockchain is just a chain of blocks, then every database designed after 1985 is also a blockchain. Is that what you believe? Also- proof of stake always forks due to work attacks, so that's probably not a secured database.
- mikeyouse 11y agoI think the core value of a blockchain (as opposed to any general database) is that the most recent blocks contain a hash of the state of the system up to that point. This provides a tamper-resistant historical record of what's occurred previously. I think your second point is what some of the critics of the bitcoin obsession are talking about. Not every blockchain needs to be as attack-resistant as the bitcoin network. Many of the speculative blockchain uses like for the Internet of Things could benefit from a history of all transactions but don't depend on it. Proof-of-stake might work fine for many cases.
- smokeyj 11y ago