3 ms·
Your statement here: "he's mainly arguing that inequality is good" is contradicted by the second paragraph of even his simplified version: But economic inequa
by jseliger 11y ago
Your statement here: "he's mainly arguing that inequality is good"
is contradicted by the second paragraph of even his simplified version:
But economic inequality per se is not bad. It has multiple causes. Many are bad, but some are good.
His main point isn't that economic inequality is good, and he says as much.
- dangerlibrary 11y agoI would argue that a reading of the PG essay that doesn't describe it as a series of arguments for ignoring / tolerating / encouraging economic inequality is, at best, flawed.
- mattrepl 11y agoHe states some causes are good and some are bad.
- vasilipupkin 11y agothe problem with PGs logic is that the serious argument is not about LEVEL of inequality being > 0, but rather that inequality has been INCREASING in the US. Ignoring this distinction is what makes PG's essay flawed. Nobody is seriously and in good faith arguing that the right level of inequality == 0