7 ms·
Inheritance taxes on their own will do nothing to change the situation because then you'll simply concentrate all the wealth in corporate structures that transc
by zepto 11y ago
Inheritance taxes on their own will do nothing to change the situation because then you'll simply concentrate all the wealth in corporate structures that transcend the death of their owners.
Even if you make it impossible to 'pass down' these structures as property, you will have de-facto inheritance through nepotism and clan structures.
- dangerlibrary 11y agoI agree (and I suspect tomp would as well - it's generally best to give others the benefit of the doubt when they've been silent on an issue) that estate taxes are insufficient. I disagree with the implication that they are not a critical component of a solution.
- zepto 11y agoThey may be a critical component of a solution, but given what I said earlier about nepotism and clans, I'd argue that they would make things worse because they would further reduce the ability of the poor and middle classes to gain traction against those with corporate power. This is not dissimilar to the Soviet situation. So, even if they are a critical component, they are irrelevant unless someone can articulate how these other components would work.
- ThomPete 11y agoMaybe not but it's a fair tax especially for those who apply to the "just work hard and reap the benefits" Also you can actually guard against that even in corporate structures. Denmark is doing it. However it's not IMO a good thing (and not fair as it taxes the company and removes capital from that company)
- pc86 11y agoOf course it's not fair. Someone works hard and earns a million dollars. At that point they've paid just about every tax imaginable on the money other than sales tax. What is the "fair" argument to taxing it again just because they die? If you honestly believe that governments should tax every dollar every time any event happens to it, that's a valid opinion, but let's not pretend it has anything to do with "fairness."
- barrkel 11y agoMy concept of fair is strongly related to my concept of justice, and I use Rawls' veil of ignorance as my standard thought experiment for judging just (and fair, WRT laws that are applied universally) scenarios. If the return to capital is much higher than the return to labour, then people who inherit a lot of wealth may gain more than people who expend the sweat of their brow. If society is very unequal, then this process may be highly exaggerated and the gains limited to a select few. From a veil of ignorance, not knowing where in the income distribution I would end up, would I like that world? Or would I prefer one that reduces the disparity (but not so much that it steeply dissuades people from trying to achive things)? The probability that I'd turn out in the very top end of an inequal distribution is slim; so naturally, what I, from a position if ignorance as to my actual position in the world, think is fair is a certain amount of tax, and yes, that includes - especially includes - inheritance tax.
- ThomPete 11y agoYou are not taxing them again (since they are dead) you are taxing their children/relatives who get the money without having done anything for it. Plus if you are rich enough a lot of those money were not taxed like a normally family but most probably through things like capital gains or just appreciation (real estate) which rarely is a product of your specific work but rather societies work to turn an area into something thats valuable by building infrastructure etc. When I buy something for my taxed money, whoever I give purchase it from is also being taxed on those already taxed money. So by your logic its not fair to tax that either either. If you buy the argument that we should tax businesses for the things they sell you are basically approving taxation of inheritance too.
- pc86 11y ago> you are taxing their children/relatives who get the money without having done anything for it. Is your argument anything other than "they got money and I want the government to take some!" > if you are rich enough a lot of those money were not taxed like a normally family but most probably through things like capital gains "We probably didn't get it right the first time around so we'll take another whack at it after you die." Capital gains tax being lower than it should be is not an excuse for other different taxes. > When I buy something for my taxed money, whoever I give purchase it from is also being taxed on those already taxed money. So by your logic its not fair to tax that either either. Just proof that you have no idea what my argument is in the first place, because that's ridiculous. We're talking about changing the name on a bank account. Property moving from parent to child or brother to sister. It's not a business transaction. > If you buy the argument that we should tax businesses for the things they sell you are basically approving taxation of inheritance too. wat
- tomp 11y ago> because then you'll simply concentrate all the wealth in corporate structures that transcend the death of their owners. That's OK, as long as the ownership of these structures is dispersed (as seems to be the case now for many public companies, which are owned by pension funds and/or sovereign wealth funds). That would also prevent nepotism.
- samstave 11y agoTake a look at how the masters pull this off. I'm not claiming everything in this article is true - just pointing out how it is surmised that some families protect wealth in a way that transcends both death and taxes: http://www.icij.org/offshore/secret-files-reveal-rothschilds-offshore-domain http://www.icij.org/offshore/secret-files-reveal-rothschilds...
- adevine 11y agoThis doesn't make sense to me. At the end of the day, all stock must be owned by actual people, even if it is through a network of other corporate entities and trusts. A corporation may transcend the death of its owners, but if I own 50% of a corporation, and I gift my shares to an heir (or even let them purchase it at a discount), the government will still take their cut.
- sjg007 11y agoYou have them owned by a trust and you replace trustees when they die.
- adevine 11y agoIt doesn't really work that way, at least in the US. While there are different ways to use trusts to minimize estate taxes, it's not like you can put all your assets in a trust, maintain control, and then when you die someone else is named the trustee and they get off tax-free.
- sjg007 11y agoYou have them owned by a trust and you replace trustees when they die.
- zepto 11y agoSure - let's assume for a moment that inheritance tax does work to distribute ownership. That simply removes 'ownership' as the instrument for control, positions within the corporate structure would then become the 'title' to the assets, and these would be passed down through nepotism and clan structures as I mentioned.
- adevine 11y agoWhile I'm not a lawyer, it doesn't really work this way, at least in the US. The law defines "ownership" pretty clearly based on who has real control over an asset. You can't really pretend someone else is the owner if you have the real control over the disposition of an asset.
- bko 11y agoInter-generational wealth is often wasted and doesn't last more than a few generations so perhaps it's not as big a problem as some make it out to be > Indeed, research shows that family money rarely survives the transfer for long, with 70 percent evaporated by the end of the second generation. By the end of the third? Ninety percent [0] [0] http://www.wsj.com/articles/SB10001424127887324662404578334663271139552 http://www.wsj.com/articles/SB100014241278873246624045783346...
- unprepare 11y agoEven if its only 10% (and 10% of a billion is still 100 million dollars) do you really think its reasonable that 100[1] years after my death my family should still be spending the money that I myself earned? To put that in perspective, people who died in 1916 are: Hetty Green - the 'witch of wall street' one of the first ever successful women investors Charles Taze Russell - the creator of a religion that would later be called 'Jehovahs Witnesses' Saint Albert Chmielowski - a Polish religious leader who was made a saint in 1989 Grigori Rasputin - a faith healer and friend of the last Tsar of Russia Nicholas II So we are talking about the modern day descendants of these people, still holding 10% of any wealth amassed over 100 years ago. If you honestly think it would be reasonable for the descendants of these people to still be living off the wealth amassed by their forebears, I guess I just disagree. [1]Wikpedia says a generation is in the low 20's in years, i'll assume 20 to keep from being seen as inflating the numbers
- cLeEOGPw 11y ago> do you really think its reasonable that 100[1] years after my death my family should still be spending the money that I myself earned? Your thought process seem to be like this: a man earns huge amounts of money, then he has children who live ordinary lives, except they don't work, just spend money earned by father/grandfather. A real situation: a man creates a business that generates profit, his children inherit the business and continue working on/are shareholders of said business/ but the value of the business decreases over time. If you think it's unfair that someone can live rich life without working, while you can not, how would it be fair if someone earn money, but is not allowed to give it to his children? It just sounds like you are jealous.
- ZeroGravitas 11y ago> Even if you make it impossible to 'pass down' these structures as property, you will have de-facto inheritance through nepotism and clan structures. There is another theory which states that this has already happened. (credit/apologies to Douglas Adams)