3 ms·
The only thing I'd disagree with is the statement 'we're nowhere near there' with regard to oligarchy and societal collapse. I think we're quite close. We hav
by zepto 11y ago
The only thing I'd disagree with is the statement 'we're nowhere near there' with regard to oligarchy and societal collapse. I think we're quite close. We have an entire generation where a tiny proportion have great prospects and the rest have steadily diminishing prospects and increasing stress, and we have educated people who grew up in the west going to join an expressly suicidal terrorist organization. We have a significant proportion of the population willing to vote for a demagogue whose positions are clearly nonsensical because he represents their (legitimate) anger at their lack of prospects the status quo affords them.
The descent from here isn't going to be linear.
- drzaiusapelord 11y ago>I think we're quite close. USA: 5% unemployment, GDP per capita of $55,000, 78.74 years life expectancy, Human Development Index: 8, etc. EU: 9% unemployment, GDP per capita $38,000, 78.82 years life expectancy, Human Development Index: 6 average, etc. Yeah, we're not "close." Meanwhile countries like the BRIC nations, especially authoritarian autocracies like China or Russia, with terrible inequality and 100x the problems the West has strangely get a free pass from these discussions. HN your bias is showing.
- zepto 11y agoI said it isn't going to be linear. {seriously - downvotes? This is HN - surely people can conceptualize non-linear processes such as dams being punctured by small holes that lead to a collapse, or the rapid collapse of an animal population when a new predator is introduced, or the disruption of incumbents when a new technology is introduced e.g. Nokia with the iPhone}
- astazangasta 11y agoThis wealth is based on social cohesion, which can fall apart in a generation or two. Genghis conquered half of Asia and built an empire of great wealth and high culture, but lack of cohesion tore it apart not long after.
- drzaiusapelord 11y ago>Genghis conquered half of Asia Are we really comparing this to a country that's nearly 240 years old and is a global superpower that has weathered everything from civil war, a major depression, defeating communism, a moon landing, inventing the internet and all the technologies you're using right now, the largest economy by GDP, the most powerful military in history, etc? This is like saying the The Who or The Stones should have broken up by 1970 because the Dave Clark Five did. I think youre purposely selling short the USA and citing election hysteria that happens every four years is far from convincing. If anything this kind of discourse is healthy and good in a democracy.
- zepto 11y agoYes - why not? Are you saying that civil war and defeating communism means that the US is immune to internal problems? There are many previous examples of societies that survived a civil war and defeated similar sized opponents, but later collapsed. Why not this one?
- astazangasta 11y agoWhat's a better comparison? Tsarist Russia? The Ottoman Empire? Rome? What goes up must come down. Sometimes it is fast, sometimes slow.
- vezzy-fnord 11y agoI'm not sure about defeating communism. I'd say communism was destined to defeat itself from its inception, and it did.
- vixen99 11y ago- and heavily in debt to the rest of the world.
- cmdkeen 11y agoI think there is a better (though still rather disanalogous) comparison between the US with the decline of the Roman Republic into the Principate. Some of the same arguments apply to the EU. In both cases a large (and roughly similar) number of people with different cultural splits (Red & Blue/North & South European) are increasingly feeling like their governmental structures are failing to represent them. Perhaps X00 million people is simply too many for our existing legislative structures to accommodate at this point in history.
- jdmichal 11y agoExcept that's the "official" unemployment number. Here's how it's calculated, cribbed directly from the Bureau of Labor Statistics [0]: * People with jobs are employed. * People who are jobless, looking for a job, and available for work are unemployed. * The labor force is made up of the employed and the unemployed. * People who are neither employed nor unemployed are not in the labor force. Think about those points very carefully. They mean that: * People who would like a job but have given up actively looking for one are not counted. * People who have a job but would take more work if available -- the underemployed -- are not counted. [0]: http://www.bls.gov/cps/cps_htgm.htm#concepts http://www.bls.gov/cps/cps_htgm.htm#concepts
- snowwrestler 11y agoThis is the way unemployment is calculated all over the world, so it does not affect the parent's point, which is comparative.
- jdmichal 11y agoCountry A has 5% "official" unemployment. But 20% of the population has simply given up seeking employment, lives at home with their parents, and plays video games all day. Another 30% of the population is employed part-time and barely covers their bills, even though they would like full-time work. Country B has 5% "official" unemployment. Everyone who would like to work is either employed or seeking employment. And everyone who is employed is employed to their desired level. You argue that A and B are equatable for the purposes of this discussion, because the 5% "official" unemployment is calculated the same way. I argue that they are not, because things excluded from that calculation have a very real impact on the economic stability of the population.
- snowwrestler 11y agoThe numbers are equatable, even if they don't measure what you would prefer they measure. But if you'd like to supply alternate unemployment data, I'm sure many readers would appreciate it. As it is, your post is hypothetical. And anyway, unemployment has been measured the same way for decades. If the question is whether we stand on a societal precipice right now, then criticizing how unemployment is measured is not relevant. Of course it has shortcomings. But it has had the same shortcomings for a long time, so the shortcomings themselves are not proof that we stand on a precipice now.
- ogrisel 11y ago5% unemployment does not mean that the majority is happy with their employment(s) or not stressed by it. GDP per capita is an average and does not reflect how the wealth is distributed.
- ThomPete 11y agoThe 5% is meaningless since it's based on how the government define it. Being unemployed means actively looking for a job. So there is a waste amount of people who are not in that statistics. Also a lot of the jobs people have don't pay for their basic expenses.
- mtgx 11y agoWell, at least this Princeton study seems to disagree with you that US is not already an oligarchy: http://www.bbc.com/news/blogs-echochambers-27074746 http://www.bbc.com/news/blogs-echochambers-27074746 When you have Congress listen to an infinitely larger degree to the powerful and the "will of the people" has a meaningless effect on their decisions, I think that pretty much defines oligarchy. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5tu32CCA_Ig https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5tu32CCA_Ig And before you say "wait a minute - didn't we stop SOPA?", I remember an interview shortly after SOPA was stopped, with Darrel Issa, one of the two most aggressive politicians in Congress wanting to stop it (along with Zoe Lofgren), and he said that what got everyone else to change their minds about SOPA, too, was actually having the big companies join the fight and lobby against it - such as Google, and so on. That's what apparently got Congress to change its mind about SOPA. There were millions of calls indeed, but a good chunk of those were pushed by Google and Wikipedia on their home page, so I think he's at least half right about that. If you ask me, I think only two things can change the way the US is right now: 1) a more democratic and representative voting system (IRV/RCV seems good enough for mayors/governors/presidents, and multi-winner RCV/STV for Congress (as well as local councils, etc) would also fix the gerrymandering problem which is a huge issue on its own with American politics and would provide a more representative multi-party government - the end of the two-party system, in other words). https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/in-theory/wp/2015/10/23/lets-move-beyond-winner-take-all-elections/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/in-theory/wp/2015/10/23/... As long as the US has the FPTP voting system, people will keep voting for the "Lesser Evil", because they "don't want Mr. Evil" to win (whoever that may be). That's just a terrible way of electing someone democratically. People should have a system that makes them vote with the candidate they like most. Anything else should be thrown out. The FPTP is also what will help Republicans keep winning a majority in Congress with only 40% of the votes, as it tends to happen wherever FPTP exists. Also a terrible way of having a "representative democracy" (even if every now and then it will be the Democrats that will win 51% with 40% support). 2) campaign finance reform (time to end or at least equalize the "money vote", which right now greatly skews the "voting power" in the favor of those with the most money. The vote is supposed to be "equal", but the "money vote" is a sort of parallel voting system that skews who can win and who the winners listen to. Not very democratic at all). I'm not sure which is more important, but I think the first one could pass more easily, and then over a period of years, people can start electing more representative candidates despite the money the "establishment" candidates will receive. And then those more representative candidates can start supporting changing the campaign finance system as well. These two changes in the end should be enough to put the US on a more democratic path once again, and act as a catalyst to fix many other political issues, too, whether it's social issues, immigration issues, health issues, copyright issues, and so on. There's only one candidate that supports changing the voting system (to IRV/RCV) right now (as well as real campaign finance reform), and that's Bernie Sanders (just FYI).