5 ms·
There's no reason why Apple can't sell "sandbox" versions of this kit. The hardware would be 99% the same. The markup and the resulting margins would be very
by stcredzero 17y ago
There's no reason why Apple can't sell "sandbox" versions of this kit. The hardware would be 99% the same. The markup and the resulting margins would be very tasty to Apple.
EDIT: They'd still be selling the "Theme Park" version to the other 95% of us.
- ZachPruckowski 17y agoYou can spend $99/yearly and become an iPhone developer. Then you can put whatever you want on your iPhone (I assume iPad development will be similar). Ad-hoc distribution allows for like 500 "testers", and you could always just share source files with other developers and recompile them. EDIT: thanks for the correction on yearly vs. one-time.
- plinkplonk 17y ago" It could be $99/yearly." It is.
- hrabago 17y agoOnly if the SDK supports it. I can't, for instance, put widgets on the lock screen to see how many unread emails I have. Or have the locked device light up due to an event that my background process detected.
- cpr 17y agoYou probably can, if it's just for yourself. The jailbreaking world has reverse engineered a lot of these internals, like replacing SpringBoard, etc.
- coliveira 17y agoI think the reason is user experience. Future computers will be "theme parks", because non-geeks don't understand the proper limitations of hardware. For example, 99% of annoyances of computer users is that they install too much software for the resources of the machine they have. Then the computer starts suddenly working slower and slower -- and they don't know why. This happens with Macs and Windows. In a machine like the iPad Apple can control what software will run and make sure that it is adequate to the resources of the machine. Also, from what I see, they limit the possibility of concurrent running programs to interfere with the user experience.
- stcredzero 17y agoI think the reason is user experience. Future computers will be "theme parks", because non-geeks don't understand the proper limitations of hardware. Yes, but there is no reason why you couldn't sell the unlocked version of the same kit. If a non-geek has a bad experience, then let them downgrade the thing. Heck, a company other than Apple might charge them another fee for that.
- chaostheory 17y agoWhat's the point of officially supporting a jailbroken product, given all the new problems it will bring? To me it's like asking Apple to support Hackintoshes. Apple has been doing this for decades and it's nothing new. If you want freedom and flexibility, you should look elsewhere.
- stcredzero 17y agoWell, if Apple did it, it wouldn't be "jailbroken," would it? The point would be the same as Apple selling the Aluminum towers. If you want freedom and flexibility coupled with world-class design, then you do buy an Apple -- with top dollar, meaning high margins for them. Apple's been doing that gig for years.
- chaostheory 17y ago"Well, if Apple did it, it wouldn't be "jailbroken," would it?" It's still a jail, and if Apple officially removed it - you can still say 'jailbroken' but that's a minor point. "If you want freedom and flexibility coupled with world-class design, then you do buy an Apple -- with top dollar, meaning high margins for them." Not true. I can't officially run OS X on non-official Apple hardware with official Apple suppport. Not to mention if I didn't buy Apple hardware then it would most likely kill their margins ;) iPad will eventually have the same 'freedom' as OS X and iPhone. What most of us don't see right away is that there are financial costs for supporting freedom and flexibility. These costs are in marketing, support (reliability and usability), and security. Given the right target techie segment, these costs don't matter for freedom. Unfortunately if you're targeting the masses of non-techies, that's a completely different story. (FYI I am an OS X user)
- philh 17y agoI suspect what would happen is hardly anyone would buy the theme park. "Less powerful, but easier to use" is a hard sell. Then they wouldn't maintain their reputation for ease of use.
- stcredzero 17y agoI suspect what would happen is hardly anyone would buy the theme park. That's why you a) wait until the other environment is well established first and b) charge a $250 markup. "Less powerful, but easier to use" is a hard sell. But "Does the same stuff, is safer, and $250 cheaper" is an easy one.
- chaostheory 17y agoThat's what Chrome OS and Android are for; we'll get what we want in a few months or maybe even weeks. Selling an official hacker version will only serve to confuse the other 95% of customers. (Apple's philosophy of simplicity goes beyond just their UI design.) I don't think this makes a lot of sense either when members of the 5% will eventually jailbreak it anyway.
- stcredzero 17y agoI'm not positive that the jailbreaks will come as fast as they used to.
- crocowhile 17y agoThis urge of control has to do with apple philosophy; I own a macbookpro myself with a wonderful huge buttonless touchpad: if it were for OSX I would even be able to configure middle click with it (which I don't care because I run linux anyway but it says a lot about their point of view IMO).
- qubit 17y agoAre you able to configure the touchpad to support right-clicks under Linux? I'm curious because that's one thing that's been a pain for me when running Linux on an Apple laptops in the past.
- crocowhile 17y agoyes. one finger tap is single click, two fingers is middle click and three fingers is right click. All via synaptics.
- ynniv 17y agoThey do: it's called the Developer Program. (Expansion: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1084640 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1084640)
- pyre 17y ago> Whats truly amazing is that this is always how desktop development has always been done, except on Linux and Mac OS X. Pay your money, get your compiler, write your software, run your software. The Linux and Mac OS X crowd is up in arms because they have had GCC for at least 9 years, and $99 seems like a lot compared to free. This how it's always been done? Really? GCC: Initial release May 23, 1987 Commodore64: Release date August 1982
- gabrielroth 17y agoCosts: developing and supporting a new version of the OS, introducing confusion into their famously stripped-down product lines, complicating the product's reputation as an easy-to-use consumer-oriented device. Benefits: sales to the tiny minority of people who won't buy an iPad now, but would if they were more 'sandboxy.' Doesn't sound 'very tasty' to me.
- eru 17y agoThey could just make it easy to hack open, to achieve nearly the same effect without having to support it officially.
- ghshephard 17y agoDon't they already do this with the iPhone. :-)
- run4yourlives 17y ago>There's no reason why Apple can't sell "sandbox" versions of this kit. The hardware would be 99% the same. Why would you do that? To compete with every other sandbox vendor that can simply copy all the expensive work that you put into UI and design and sell knock-offs at half the price? Put yourself in the company's shoes. Your narrow interests are not in theirs.
- lallysingh 17y agoWe'll probably see some of the same tech make its way into the macbook/pro lines.