5 ms·
Ellison on IBM: "In databases, they are a decade or so behind us."
- wglb 17y agoEntertaining back-and-forth, but are there independent performance numbers published backing up either claim?
- derwiki 17y agoPure numbers aren't the important thing here, IMO. How many college students are playing with DB2 or IMS on System Z? It's going to be a very low number, for a few very good reasons: * while reliable, System Z is incredibly hard to work with as a programmer or sysadmin * in my experience, IBM flat out refuses to give any of their "serious" products to universities. They say "Oh, download DB2 Express-C" and that's the end of the discussion. If I know there are 1000x more people in the field with Oracle experience on common hardware than DB2 on System Z, I'm going to go with Oracle. Hardware is cheap. Good engineers/sysadmins aren't.
- acangiano 17y agoThere is actually a great number of college students playing with DB2. They usually do so with DB2 Express-C, because it's free and production ready, so it's ideal for students and startups (even though we have large corporations who use it as well). DB2 Express-C is easy to work with, easy to administer, and has the same core code as commercial versions used by the largest companies in the world. System Z provides a nice hardware/software combo, but don't be fooled into thinking that DB2 LUW (Linux/Unix/Windows) is not "serious" or anything but great, really. DB2 provides many useful innovations that are not available to Oracle users. And thanks to DB2 Express-C, many of these benefits are available for free. DISCLAIMER: I work for IBM in the DB2 team.
- sharms 17y agoThis sounds suspiciously like marketing speak. I graduated in 2006, and we never even spoke of DB2 in my time at the University of Michigan. For curiosities sake, specifically to your post: What makes it ideal to startups (any cool examples)? What innovations exist in DB2 that are not available elsewhere?
- abossy 17y agoFrom acangiano's profile: "I'm a Software Engineer & Technical Evangelist at IBM in Toronto, Canada."
- 9oliYQjP 17y agoCollege in Canada has a different meaning than in the U.S.. Here, it means community college. The equivalent term in Canada for an American college would be university. In Canada there are no universities that I'm aware of that have DB2 on their curriculum. There are definitely community colleges that do have it though.
- acangiano 17y ago> This sounds suspiciously like marketing speak. As some of you here may know, I'm a technical evangelist for IBM. I try to remain factual, but I may occasionally be a tad biased. I disclose my (IBM) affiliation in my profile, but edited my comment and added a disclaimer there as well. > I graduated in 2006, and we never even spoke of DB2 in my time at the University of Michigan. We have a "DB2 on Campus" initiative (started in July 2006) [1] that has spread to over 250 universities worldwide so far, with about 30,000 students and teachers participating in the program. > What makes it ideal to startups (any cool examples)? What innovations exist in DB2 that are not available elsewhere? Unlike different "express" editions provided by other vendors, DB2 Express-C doesn't impose limits on the size of the database, the number of users that can be connected, and so on. This means that a startup can begin using DB2 Express-C for free, while taking advantage of a fast, secure, rock solid, very scalable database that's already being used by large corporations for mission critical work. If you were to hit the jackpot and become highly successful, DB2 would be able to scale with you from your VPS box all the way to a cluster of instances running in parallel within a huge cloud environment. The free edition will use up to 2 CPU cores, and 2 GB of RAM, regardless of the hardware installed on your server. This is usually plenty, if you consider that many smaller startups don't even have a dedicated database VPS with 2 GB of RAM. For less than three grand a year, you can also obtain 24/7 technical support from IBM as well as the ability to access further features, like the possibility of setting up a fail over server through the so-called "High Availability and Disaster Recovery" (HADR) feature. This upgrade also enables DB2 to use 4 CPU cores, and up to 4 GB of RAM. IBM directly implements and supports APIs for various languages, including PHP, Ruby, and more recently Python. When you have an issue with any of those, you have people accountable for, and well paid to solve your problems. If you are wondering, those are open source, too, in case you like doing things DYI style. And we offer advanced tools like IBM Data Studio, free of charge as well. [2] Learning DB2 is fairly straightforward, and there is a great deal of free information. Amongst which you'll find a course that was extracted from the DB2 on Campus program [3] and free ebooks [4]. Regarding features, DB2 introduced something called pureXML. This allows you to natively store huge quantities of XML data and query it through SQL/XML, XPath, XQuery. It's amazingly fast. [5] The autonomic features of DB2 are also unmatched, enabling DB2 to self-tune itself, while limiting the amount of work required to administer and optimize DB2. There are also more "enterprisey" features like DPF, very advanced compression capabilities, pureQuery, InfoSphere Warehouse powered by DB2, and so on. But these are typically of less interest to early stage startups. 1. http://www.ibm.com/software/data/db2/express/students_programs.html http://www.ibm.com/software/data/db2/express/students_progra... 2. https://www14.software.ibm.com/webapp/iwm/web/preLogin.do?source=swg-idssa https://www14.software.ibm.com/webapp/iwm/web/preLogin.do?so... 3. http://www.ibm.com/developerworks/wikis/display/DB2/DB2+on+Campus+videos http://www.ibm.com/developerworks/wikis/display/DB2/DB2+on+C... 4. http://www.ibm.com/developerworks/wikis/display/DB2/FREE+Book-+Getting+Started+with+DB2+Express-C http://www.ibm.com/developerworks/wikis/display/DB2/FREE+Boo... 5. http://antoniocangiano.com/2008/11/04/benchmarking-db2-purexml-against-1-tb-of-xml-data/ http://antoniocangiano.com/2008/11/04/benchmarking-db2-purex...
- hga 17y agoDB2 LUW is serious and great (or it was in the mid-late '90s, and a heck of a lot less painful to set up and administer than Oracle), but isn't mainframe DB2 a different code base with a variety of differences and quirks? And how many people know how to do System Z administration or applications programming?
- derwiki 17y agoSystem Z DB2 is written in a completely different language than Express-C. I'm not sure there's even code overlap.
- acangiano 17y ago> IBM is so far behind, they don't have any chance at all. In databases, they are a decade or so behind us. I'm serious. FUD.
- hga 17y agoIt was my observation that this was largely true in the '90s. Has anything changed? DB2 get MVCC? SQL Server did for the 2005 version. Are people buying Oracle RAC or IBM's equivalent offering? How much do IBM's higher end offerings require running them on their mainframes, which continue to be more and more alien to the IT workforce? I'm not following this closely, but I don't get the impression that IBM is catching up.
- raganwald 17y agoIBM is busy playing defense, trying to extract as much money from legacy customers for as long as possible, not playing offense and trying to win new customers away from rivals. they won't implement anything until convinced that they will lose customers and their fat maintenance contracts doing so. Until then, a dollar spent playing golf will do far more to retain customers than a dollar spent implementing features.
- hga 17y agoHmmm, yes, the fate of products in a services company is iffy at best and generally dire (been there, done that).
- acangiano 17y agoReg, I always value your opinion, but I'm afraid that's an outdated perception of IBM - or a limited one at the very least. IBM is a huge organization, and while some departments may be more conservative than others, there is plenty of innovation happening every day at the labs. Each release of DB2 keeps innovating and adding useful features. Often these are not in response to something else that's already available on the market (aka, competition), but rather to what our customers will find beneficial (pureXML is a prime example of this). If you think about it, the very existence of a free edition doesn't quite fit in with the picture you painted. I assure you that IBM is interested in acquiring new customers as much as keeping large, existing ones. How do I know? I'm paid to focus on the former.