4 ms·
To me as someone living in the UK, this is bizarre. Why would you need an deductables at all for it not to be expensive? This in itself indicates that your enti
by vidarh 11y ago
To me as someone living in the UK, this is bizarre. Why would you need an deductables at all for it not to be expensive? This in itself indicates that your entire healthcare sector is entirely dysfunctional.
In 2013/2014, the UK National Health Service spent $2928/year per person.
This is the average, and includes everything from the costs of births to the costs of expensive heart transplants or cancer treatments. General practitioners. Specialists. Hospitals. Ambulance services. Subsidized prescriptions (in England there are prescription charges of 7 pounds per prescription; in Scotland and Wales prescriptions are covered by the devolved governments).
Since I moved here 15 years ago, I've been to A&E (accompanying my ex) and hospitals (same) several times; I've had a son; I've been to the doctors many times. The care has been excellent, and fast. We've never had to fill in a single form that is not purely medically motivated. Never had to take out my wallet other than the occasional few coins for a prescriptions (I'm Norwegian, and while Norway also has an excellent socialized healthcare system, being able to just walk straight out without going to reception to pay after seeing the doctor was a novelty to me too - things like general doctors visits carry a low co-pay in Norway). Best spent $2928 I could make.
Where is all this money going in the US? Surely someone, somewhere is making ridiculous profits that must have investors drooling and looking for contenders.
The US welfare system, or lack of one, is one of the reasons I'd never consider moving to the US. It seems so totally barbaric and arbitrary.
- ars 11y agoPeople have written about this before, but basically the US subsidizes medical expenses for the entire world. That was able to happen because, unlike virtually anywhere else in the world, medical insurance in the US is private. If the US changes that (which will never happen) I would expect medical costs to go up everywhere else to compensate, either that or research slows down. One thing that might, might, help is forbidding medical companies from advertising at all, that might save some money. But the law of unintended consequences tells me it would have other effects that might not be so great.
- erkkie 11y agoDo you have any sources for this based on actual data?
- laurencerowe 11y agoIt's true that the US has historically been a leader in medical research, but that largely comes from the federal government through the NIH ($32 billion in 2016.)
- rlpb 11y ago> US pharma companies like Pfizer gets more than 50% of their revenue from foreign markets. To be fair, this statement doesn't really tell us anything. Pfizer's foreign market profit might be 2% of sale price, and their US profit 98% of sale price. So despite that figure, the majority of their R&D investment might still come from sales in the US.
- vidarh 11y agoThat's massively exaggerated. US industry accounts for ~60% of US medical research. The rest is NIH, donations etc. US pharma companies like Pfizer gets more than 50% of their revenue from foreign markets. Thus if we split research contributions by region, only about 30% of US medical research is likely to come from US healthcare expenses. Even if you took away all of that funding you still wouldn't account for the cost differences. But that's not the whole story: US sales costs are substantially higher, as in many non-US markets you can't legally advertise, so the net contribution of US healthcare funds to US medical research is likely less, It may still be true that the US pays more per capita for to medical research than most, but it simply doesn't make up all that large a proportion of overall medical research.
- sparkzilla 11y agoYou've had a good experience, many others haven't. I personally had two family members die from NHS incompetence, and no compensation. There are horror stories like mine every day. I'd much rather have the US system, with all its flaws.
- KaiserPro 11y agoCan you elaborate? two deaths in the same family for negligence with no recourse to get compensation sounds sounds wrong.
- sparkzilla 11y agoMy mother's second husband's stomach trouble was misdiagnosed. Because of the long waiting times to see a specialist, the cancer was too far gone by the time they found out what it was, and he died when he was 50. My wife's sister was taken to hospital with a gallbladder infection. Despite being extremely weak, the staff let her walk and she fell. She broke her pelvis, but they missed it. Despite being in severe pain and being very weak that they let her walk again, and she fell again and her condition deteriorated. She died a few days later, aged 36. Their incompetence killed her. The case was referred to the Ombudsman and the family got an apology, but no compensation for their mistakes. I do understand that horror stories also occur in the U.S. but the faster time to treatment, and better testing, would have saved my mother's husband, and the fear of lawsuits would have saved my wife's sister. As I said above, there are horror stories like these in the newspapers every day. Many, many more cases like ours are simply not reported.
- DanBC 11y ago> but no compensation for their mistakes. You sue to get compensation.
- sparkzilla 11y agoYou can sue them but it is a long process and you won't get U.S.-style amounts for payouts. That's if you can get that far. The staff cover for each other and use processes like the Ombudsman to delay and obfuscate. Also, the UK is not a litigious culture and my mother and other family members simply didn't want to go through more trouble.