4 ms·
I claim that economic inequality at the scale we are seeing today, with Bill Gates, Mark Zuckerberg, Peter Thiel, Donald Trump, the Koch Brothers, the Walton fa
by jacobolus 11y ago
I claim that economic inequality at the scale we are seeing today, with Bill Gates, Mark Zuckerberg, Peter Thiel, Donald Trump, the Koch Brothers, the Walton family, et al. as plutocrats, and with Paul Graham and various other bourgeois pseudointellectuals as their kiss-up apologists, is per se bad. It erodes the broad social/economic power balance in our society, atrophies our civic institutions or coöpts them into quasi-fascist tools of the elite, breaks our journalistic institutions and cheapens our political discourse, diverts our resources into building wasteful things, and prevents us from tackling the serious challenges we face, while leaving millions of people struggling for basic survival.
I don’t see Paul Graham out there fighting in any concrete way for improvements to any of the “bad things that cause inequality” he hand-waves away. Where’s his work to improve labor rights, end police brutality, guarantee a functioning healthcare system, track down and close tax loopholes, expose and regulate industrial polluters, or figure out how to save the lives of all the people economically displaced by his startup “disruptor” buddies? Where’s his respect or help for teachers, social workers, doctors, policemen, civil rights activists, local politicians, garbage collectors, journalists, mail carriers, or any of the other people who keep our civil society functioning in return for regular wages. All I see is contempt for those “losers” (quoting from a recent tweet, https://twitter.com/paulg/status/672112234521231361 https://twitter.com/paulg/status/672112234521231361) who don’t want to become rich capitalists.
How does Paul Graham’s imagined perfect society work? If everyone is a startup founder, who is left to be the employees at all these startups, much less do any of the other work we all need for things to keep running.
- tptacek 11y agoArguments that put Bill Gates, Mark Zuckerberg, Peter Thiel, Donald Trump, and the Koch Brothers on one "plutocrats" team are probably the reason Paul Graham keeps writing dubious posts about income inequality.
- jacobolus 11y agoHere Thomas, read this: http://www.nybooks.com/articles/2015/12/17/reimagining-journalism-story-one-percent/ http://www.nybooks.com/articles/2015/12/17/reimagining-journ... They’re not on one “team”, but these people have outsized wealth and influence without any kind of accountability to the public. By virtue of having so much money, they can drive the funding of political campaigns (now without any limits or accountability) with less and less counterbalance from the middle class, and do whatever they like to promote their own interests, whether those interests are aligned with the public or not. I claim this is per se bad, even in the case that the plutocrats care about their image or self-image and turn out to be relatively “enlightened”. Even if Gates and Zuckerberg, e.g., are well meaning philanthropists, there’s no evidence that their interventions are better than anyone else’s would be. Indeed, since they tend to not have a priori knowledge of fields outside whatever made them wealthy to begin with, and they tend to have led relatively charmed lives protected from the struggle of those at the bottom of the social pyramid, their interventions often look like bumbling stabs in the dark, and sometimes cause more harm than they prevent. In education policy for example, Gates and Zuckerberg’s efforts (and the efforts of the Waltons and other billionaires) have mostly been disastrous distractions pushing policy in the wrong direction. https://www.dissentmagazine.org/article/got-dough-how-billionaires-rule-our-schools https://www.dissentmagazine.org/article/got-dough-how-billio... Beyond that though, all the good that Gates can do is undone multiple times over by folks like the Koch Brothers, who have explicitly decided to turn their wealth to subverting democracy. It would be better if we had publicly financed (or small-donor financed) elections, more transparency/accountability for advertising and PR spending of all kinds, and if these folks were taxed at (let’s say) the same rate they were during the Reagan administration, and there’d be plenty of public money to fund whatever charity projects in a publicly accountable way.
- idlewords 11y agoThe plutocrats have a deep bench. They're totally going to take the pennant, like they do every year.
- nedwin 11y agoIs it Paul Graham's job to fix those problems that cause inequality? I don't think it is. I do think that it's great that people like Bill Gates invest their billions into improving the healthcare system globally, and the Zuckerbergs have invested large amounts into improving education.
- jacobolus 11y agoIt is not Paul Graham’s job to fix any particular set of problems. However, given that he hasn’t to my knowledge ever engaged with such problems at all, and he has apparently himself led a charmed life in a bubble insulated from the day-to-day concerns of regular people he keeps dismissively handwaving away, I don’t see why he has any basis on which to pontificate about the state of the society in general, or tell everyone else how they should think.
- throwawaymaroon 11y agoNo, but he should shut up about it if he's not going to take it seriously.
- pw 11y agoLargely agree, but since when was PG merely "bourgeois"?