6 ms·
>But economic inequality per se is not bad. This is the controversial assertion, and it's not argued for here. So I'm not sure how this can help. edit: As oth
by foldr 11y ago
>But economic inequality per se is not bad.
This is the controversial assertion, and it's not argued for here. So I'm not sure how this can help.
edit: As others have clarified, of course there are few people who would object to any degree of economic inequality whatsoever. In the context of this discussion, 'economic inequality' refers to economic inequality on (at least) the scale that we see at present in the US and other wealthy countries, since this is what pg is defending.
- emmett 11y agoGreat point! That sounds like a genuine disagreement. Can you expand a bit on why economic inequality is intrinsically bad, rather than instrumentally bad?
- foldr 11y agoI could, but that whole discussion was already had on the thread for the original article. You can find a summary of the main arguments by googling e.g. "why economic inequality is bad". I don't mean this in a snarky way, it's just that so much has already been written on the topic that I don't see the point in trying to summarize what economists, philosophers and any number of others have already said.
- emmett 11y agoThe previous thread had lots of reasons economic inequality is instrumentally bad. I really saw nothing about how it's intrinsically bad, and I was looking. Can you link to a specific comment maybe?
- foldr 11y agoI'm not sure exactly what distinction you're making with instrumentally vs. intrinsically. People pointed out that economic equality as such has certain bad consequences. For example, wealthy people become disproportionately powerful. Here's an ok list turned up by a simple Google query: http://ideas.ted.com/the-4-biggest-reasons-why-inequality-is-bad-for-society/ http://ideas.ted.com/the-4-biggest-reasons-why-inequality-is...
- emmett 11y agoIntrinsic wrongness of inequality is basically argument #4 from your link. It's the idea that the split of wealth is just inherently unfair, not because of any bad consequence, but because of something being wrong with having wealth too unevenly distributed whether or not it actually has any bad effects. Claims 1-3 from your link are claims of instrumental wrongness of inequality claims 1-3 from your link. They point at bad consequences (rich people will control the media, rich people will corrupt the government, rich people will have unfair advantages for their children). As the author of the article you links points out: "In principle, these effects could avoided, without reducing economic inequality, through such means as the public financing of political campaigns and making high-quality public education available to all children". It's not that inequality necessarily must cause these consequences, it's that it will tend to under some (most?) given policy regimes. I think I misunderstood your original comment...when you said that "Inequality is not per se bad" was incorrect, I assumed you were making argument #4, which I did not see debated hardly at all. Most people were making some variant on arguments #1-#3. In which case, I would respond to you: Paul does talk about the bad consequences and bad causes of inequality, and claims that you should address those causes and consequences directly rather than attempt to limit inequality in itself. The argument against this has to come in some form of "well yes, in theory it's possible to limit the bad consequences of inequality, but in practice it's too hard because X and thus we should directly attack inequality". I didn't see anyone really saying that, everyone seemed to believe Paul thinks inequality doesn't have bad consequences or that he thinks we shouldn't address those bad consequences.
- foldr 11y agoI don't think it's possible to effectively address the bad consequences without limiting inequality. It certainly doesn't seem possible right now, in the U.S. (do you expect to see publicly financed political campaigns any time soon?) If pg wants to be taken seriously he needs to make a serious proposal about how we can have tons of economic inequality without the seemingly inevitable bad consequences of it. And I note that some of the proposals you mention (e.g. lots of public funding for education) are merely redistribution in disguise and do in effect take money from the rich and give it to the poor. Truthfully, pg doesn't care about the consequences of inequality because they don't affect him or his buddies, so he likes to pretend that some pie-in-the-sky scheme can magically make everything ok without actually changing the status quo.
- scarmig 11y agoIn the strictest sense, inequality per se isn't bad or actionable: if the residents of Kepler-186f start out poor compared to those of Sol-3, it shouldn't influence our actions at all. And if they suddenly become far richer a century later as they stumble upon technological riches untold, it still shouldn't change how we live: all we can say is that in a theoretical utilitarian sense, the universe is a lot better off than otherwise. The issue is that the human rich and the poor don't exist on separate planets (yet?). One plausible theory, though one I don't argue for or against here, is that as economic power ends up concentrated in fewer and fewer hands, so does political power and the will to change the crappy situation of the poorest, despite the hand-wringing of the more civic-minded rich. This would lead to a world that many people would rank lower than a world with less poverty and more equality. The details are everything here: if evidence supports the idea that increased inequality raises the economic floor, then we shouldn't worry too much about it. But the people arguing otherwise aren't jealous of their next door neighbor's new car in itself but are worried that, in the actually existing world, increased economic inequality inherently leads to negative social effects.
- squozzer 11y agoThe concentration of wealth has some observable effects that we probably don't want - for example, real estate prices. Not that expensive real estate is bad in itself, but people who work in areas where they can't afford to live - for instance, a hypothetical cop in NY / LA / SF - have three obvious choices: 1> commute, sometimes for hours one-way. One could argue that policing outside of one's neighborhood is bad policing, but for the most part, long commutes are just a drag. And probably will last only as long as it takes for a job closer to home to open up. So now it's a turnover problem. 2> rent control or other "low-income" concession. Waiting lists are long, developers resist creating more supply, and always have to consider the risk of arbitrage. 3> extra jobs / graft - competition for outside security work is pretty tight, and I'm sure we can all agree another cop on the take is something the world doesn't need. We could try a variant of option 2 and provide housing subsidies for certain professions, something I think the FBI does for agents in certain areas, but then we run the risk of creating castes. I doubt anyone would entertain subsidizing a barista's rent just so they wouldn't have to commute 3 hours to a Starbucks in Beverly Hills. But it might happen for a cop (probably not.) The degenerate case is all the cops leave and the rich have the opportunity to fend for themselves.
- dominotw 11y agoThis was debated on Intelligence Squared podcast DECLINISTS BE DAMNED: BET ON AMERICA http://intelligencesquaredus.org/debates/past-debates/item/1251-declinists-be-damned-bet-on-america http://intelligencesquaredus.org/debates/past-debates/item/1...
- tptacek 11y agoI listened to that debate, and I while I remember inequality coming up a lot, I don't think it was really the theme; a disproportionate amount of time in the debate was taken up by Peter Zeihan talking up the mental MMORPG he plays to try to model global politics.
- carc 11y agoI don't really see how this is controversial. Do you want to reward talented people who work hard? Do you want to incentivize people to do great things? You need to allow some level of income inequality. The extreme level of income inequality we see now is a bad thing.. but that doesn't mean economic inequality is inherently bad. Most good things taken to an extreme cease to remain good things.
- the_gastropod 11y agoIt's controversial because it's largely a strawman. Income inequality is not a binary thing—it's a gradient. There exists a level of income inequality that any reasonable person would agree is bad. PG seems to be trying to muddle that fact.
- mrxd 11y agoJust because something motivates someone to do great things doesn't mean it is good to offer that reward. If someone was motivated by the desire to own slaves, etc. In light of the fact that increasing wealth has diminishing returns in terms of utility, what if the desire for extreme wealth is simply the desire for power? How much power inequality is acceptable in a democratic society? Couldn't you motivate people with fame instead?
- dsugarman 11y agoone example he gives for why economic inequality can actually be a good thing is that it causes people to want to create a startup. few founders would endure the journey without the possibility to become extremely wealthy. if startups create wealth and economic inequality is a requirement for startups to exist, then economic inequality can be a really great thing disguised as a really bad thing.
- darkmighty 11y agoActually I'd like some evidence on that. Do founders really care for money all that much? Does it make a world of difference for them if they make 100 million vs 1 billion from their startup (versus just the success of the company itself, i.e. how many users you reach)? I think the effect of valuation may not be so significant on the founders motivation, specially given how you have no idea how large the startup will get from the beginning.
- Kalium 11y agoIt sounds to me like what you're asking is actually "Do people and markets respond to incentives?". Broadly, I think the answer is yes. Yes they do.
- vec 11y agoI think the real question is "does the existence of unicorns provide an incentive to the average founder?", and I'd say that question's a lot less definitive. Sure, some founders have gotten filthy stinkin' rich off their startups, but those are lottery-ticket odds. Most founders seem to be aiming for either a self-sustaining small business or an acqui-hire, both of which are middle- to upper-middle-class career paths, but neither are by and large own-your-own-helicopter-class career paths.
- Kalium 11y agoI think you may have overlooked the power of optimistic biases. A fair number of young founders do believe they stand a good chance of becoming very much upper class and base their financial decisions on this. Failing that, some people are willing to play lottery-ticket odds even with full appreciation of the risks. That said, I think the answer hold even if you restrict the question to small self-sustaining lifestyle-businesses-size. You correctly state that there is no way of knowing how big a company will get at founding time. However, if there's an upper limit, then this may significantly affect risk evaluation. People will respond to the incentives they see, and you can't kill the incentives without affecting how people behave.