3 ms·
On the surface I want to support BI, I really do. But how does it work other than as a replacement (not supplement) to existing social welfare programs? Give so
by pc86 11y ago
On the surface I want to support BI, I really do. But how does it work other than as a replacement (not supplement) to existing social welfare programs? Give someone enough money that they can rent a room, buy food, and cover their healthcare (whatever cost that may incur). The numbers required to do this in the US when you eliminate all social programs seem doable. Most people pay less in taxes, money gets distributed directly to the people, and it seems fine.
So what happens when someone uses their entire BI allowance on Fireball and lottery tickets? The two choices seem to be "they die" or "we don't actually eliminate social service in exchange for a guarantee BI."
- mikeyouse 11y agoThe BI proponents typically forget that there's some average amount of money that would work for everyone, but there is clearly a power-law at the expensive end of social services. As an example, I have an extended family member who was born happy and healthy but contracted meningitis at 5 years old and was severely mentally handicapped afterwards. For the past 20 years, his parents have provided his extensive care buoyed by social security disability, but they won't be around forever, so then what? Giving him or some agent on his behalf $12k/year isn't going to come close to paying for the level of support that he needs. There are millions of people in similar situations that could not survive without significant amounts of money which is almost entirely funded by the government. Just assuming that this will be covered by any basic income is silly.
- pc86 11y agoSo at that point it basically becomes a "you only get BI unless you need more," which is really just what we have now but everyone gets a $12k/yr kicker on top, right (to use your figure).
- SomeCallMeTim 11y agoThrow in single-payer to cover health issues (and include mental health issues) and you'll cover 98% of the problem. People play PowerBall to extremes and similar because they're desperate. I doubt $12k/year would be sufficient, BTW. You want people to be able to live a decent, if spartan, life on BI, and at $12k I think they'd be forced to decide between starving or extremely poor living conditions. Probably $18k/year would be an absolute minimum, plus allowances for kids (how to handle kids is a HUGE question, well outside the scope of this post). The amount you earn could vary by chosen living area, in proportion to living expenses. Maybe not 100% proportionally; if an area has 150% of the cost of living, but only pays you 125% more than the nominal amount, there would still be a pressure to move to less expensive areas, but more expensive areas wouldn't de facto exclude people on BI. There needs to be extended discussion on the details. I don't know nearly enough to be able to have all of the answers. But it seems like the answer is out there, if enough people get together to work on it.
- SomeCallMeTim 11y ago>power-law at the expensive end of social services. Single-payer health care that extends to psychological services and mental handicaps would cover this, right? Some people need to be institutionalized, or otherwise supported 24/7. BI allows us to close most government assistance programs, but there still would need to be subsidized health care. Maybe there's a serious co-pay for living arrangements, deducted from BI, so that people don't just claim psychological problems to get free housing. But the problem is solvable.
- murbard2 11y agoNo, even then they really don't, do the math. 300M people, $2T total federal budget. Everyone is so obsessed with discussing whether or not this would create disincentives to work that the gigantic cost is barely mentionned. The moral ground has moved so far left that even the right-wing doesn't dare critic it as a massive forced, wealth redistribution scheme. Instead they fixate on barely relevant questions, such as whether it makes people lazy, or if the money is "deserved". This drives me nuts. The problem is never giving money to people. Technological progress has the same effect. The problem is taking it away from others!
- toomuchtodo 11y ago> This drives me nuts. The problem is never giving money to people. Technological progress has the same effect. The problem is taking it away from others! If automation is driving people out of work, I need not take anything from you to give to others. Quite the contrary, you yourself will have nothing of value to "take" in the long term. What technology giveth, it taketh away.
- murbard2 11y agoI wasn't trying to make a point about the disruptive effect of technology. My point is that people getting free money is functionally equivalent to them having access to more goods and services, which is something technology does (in the medium run) and that no one seriously worries about.
- pc86 11y ago> The moral ground has moved so far left that even the right-wing doesn't dare critic it as a massive forced, wealth redistribution scheme. BI that replaces all social welfare programs is about as libertarian as you can get without veering into an anarcho-capitalist wet dream hellscape.
- murbard2 11y agoIf I include things like Medicare, Medicaid, Social Security, Education, etc... all social welfare programs add up to maybe $1.5T a year. There are about 320M people in the US. Let's leave out anyone under 18 (23%) that leaves us with about 250M people. Assume that somehow, all of these welfare programs are dismantled to be replaced by a BI. It's totally politically unfeasible, but let's imagine it happens. That leaves $1.5T to be distributed yearly among 250M people, which comes to about $500 a month. That's as a replacement of all medical aid, all social security, all public schooling, etc... Proponents of BI cite higher numbers, and political reality means many of these programs will stay. This suggests that BI will not come about without a dramatic increase in taxation.