4 ms·
Counterpoint: http://linuxfonts.narod.ru/why.linux.is.not.ready.for.the.desktop.current.html http://linuxfonts.narod.ru/why.linux.is.not.ready.for.the.de... N
by nickpsecurity 11y ago
Counterpoint:
http://linuxfonts.narod.ru/why.linux.is.not.ready.for.the.desktop.current.html http://linuxfonts.narod.ru/why.linux.is.not.ready.for.the.de...
Note: I use Mint. I'm just pointing out there's still so many issues that anecdotal articles have no weight due to variance in user's experience largely determined by hardware and apps used. I will also note that it disturbs me that some of these problems were in UNIX Hater's Handbook a long, long time ago. Still there.
- arfar 11y agoIs this your blog? Just thought you might like to know that "Trend Micro OfficeScan" detects this website as a "fraud page or threat source"
- nickpsecurity 11y agoNo it's not. Mine wouldn't be as apologetic to those repeating same mistakes for decades. It also would be low risk as I use text files and HTML 3.2. ;)
- anonbanker 11y agoGotta vehemently disagree with one of the issues listed: If you used OSSv1 or v2, or v3, you would understand why OSSv4 failed: You had to _pay_ for sound card drivers in linux. I had an Opti OPL3-SA sound card. The card cost $19 new. In order to use it in linux, I had to pay 4Front $25 to use the damn thing in linux. if I didn't pay the ransom for hardware I already owned, I was limited to 30 minutes of sound output. then I had to not just modprobe, but wipe cruft from my filesystem and reinstall. It cost $5 more to buy a Yamaha sound card than I would've paid 4front, but they didn't deserve a dime of my money, and Yamaha's drivers were free. Alsa may suck, but it's free and good enough. and 4Front doesn't deserve to have its code in the linux kernel.
- nickpsecurity 11y agoI could see why that wouldn't be popular. But you're also saying it was unacceptable that people didn't do a lot of work for you for free. As in, FOSS crowd isn't doing it, almost no market for it, someone does it for a fee, and it isn't acceptable due to the fee. Kind of like buying a Yamaha bike, demanding different steering + tires, them saying no due to costs vs demand, offering to do it for a fee, and you say "why would I pay for the mod if I already bought the bike?" Then they stare at you confused.
- anonbanker 11y agoif OPTi had written the drivers, sure, I might have paid. Just to show that linux support is appreciated. In fact, this is a decent driver model, if companies actually wanted to make us put our money where our mouth is. However, 4front held people for _ransom_ on a free operating system. that's way different. that's Bitkeeper-made-git-happen levels of different.
- nickpsecurity 11y ago"However, 4front held people for _ransom_ on a free operating system. that's way different. that's Bitkeeper-made-git-happen levels of different." What do you mean by that specifically? You're fine with people charging for drivers but they apparently did something specific that was worse.
- digi_owl 11y agoI keep reading and i keep finding that his references either do not back his point, or are basically a problem because of intransigent proprietary suppliers (see Torvalds "fuck you Nvidia"). Then again there are no singular "desktop". There is the media consumption desktop, the media production desktop, the gaming desktop, the office production desktop, etc etc etc. In the end though, the basic problem is that unless some company pulls an Apple and start selling Linux preinstalled out of physical stores with knowledgeable staff for walk in support, the market will be stuck with Windows. This simply because that is what everyone tests against, because that is the largest market, and you got your catch 22 going. Never mind that MS have a history of playing lip service to standard definitions (embrace, extend, extinguish anyone?).
- nickpsecurity 11y agoI recognized many personally and clicked on some but not most or all. Now that you mentioned it, I click on more to find that your right: some references straight up contradict the claim being made. Wth... Might have to make a revised version of it. Many of them are hardware-related but you can't solely blame it on proprietary hardware. The times where work was put in got things done. Tons of work has been put into Linux with all kinds of features and fixes. There's even enterprise distro's aimed at business desktops bringing in revenue. Yet, core functionality for desktops has problems it's had for a long time that can only be explained by lack of effort. So, author's (and my) point still stands even after knocking out bad references or ignoring truly hardware-specific problems. If you doubt it, just check out autotools to see the state of software maintenance that sometimes shows up in FOSS UNIX's. ;)