4 ms·
So you're OK with recognizing bad drivers, but you want to force a service to keep contracting with them anyway despite their poor performance?
by JoshTriplett 11y ago
So you're OK with recognizing bad drivers, but you want to force a service to keep contracting with them anyway despite their poor performance?
- lmm 11y agoI want an employer to fulfill the responsibilities that go with employing a human being. That doesn't mean not firing anyone ever, but it does mean following a process, giving them access to (union) representation, and (in cases of simple poor performance rather than gross misconduct) giving them an opportunity to improve before firing them. If you just go by raw customer ratings, what prevents e.g. racists/sexists/homophobes from deliberately getting people fired?
- JoshTriplett 11y agoI would expect that they do have a process, and that it operates uniformly for all drivers. Drivers handle a large volume of customers; unless the rating system is badly broken, a single customer could not single-handedly swing ratings enough to get someone fired. I would also hope that the service contracting the drivers would not accept a single unsubstantiated account as unassailable evidence, and would look for a corroborated pattern instead. Given that drivers can see their own rating, and the rating thresholds for drivers are well-known, getting close to that point would serve as fairly clear warning of needing improvement (if there isn't an explicit warning to that effect). So there's an opportunity to improve. Apart from that, I'm not going to comment further on the already extensive volume that has been written about the merits of "contractor" versus "employee"; the arguments there are already quite well known and don't need further rehashing.
- lmm 11y ago> I would expect that they do have a process, and that it operates uniformly for all drivers. Maybe. Or maybe management fires people who they don't like, or who point out illegal practices, or who are more expensive to them for some reason. The European requirements to document the process and for the employee to have access to representation are not excessively onerous, and they're there for a reason. > Drivers handle a large volume of customers; unless the rating system is badly broken, a single customer could not single-handedly swing ratings enough to get someone fired. I would also hope that the service contracting the drivers would not accept a single unsubstantiated account as unassailable evidence, and would look for a corroborated pattern instead. I'd hope that too, but plenty of companies do dumb things from time to time (if they do enough dumb things they'll eventually go out of business, but in the meantime it can still be catastrophic for individual employees). And if there is systematic racism/sexism/etc. then averaging a number of ratings wouldn't prevent it.
- Nursie 11y ago>> So you're OK with recognizing bad drivers, but you want to force a service to keep contracting with them anyway despite their poor performance? If you want to put it that way, yes. Employment rights were hard won and a lot of people, myself included, do not enjoy the likes of Uber undermining them in the name of (slightly) lower prices and (maybe) better service. As I said elsewhere - in a regular job there would be dialogue with management, chances to improve, formal warnings etc.
- JoshTriplett 11y ago> If you want to put it that way, yes. So should you be forced to use a plumber with poor reviews? Or eat at a restaurant with terrible food? Or do you have one set of rules for individuals and another for "evil" corporations?
- Nursie 11y agoI have one set of rules for people and another for companies, yes, so does the country I live in and most other countries I know of. Exactly where the boundaries are for this is a grey area, as is much of law and ethics.