4 ms·
Given that several of my local taxi services already cover a lot of this with their apps - Ordering, payment, GPS, invoices, account management, fares etc - it'
by Nursie 11y ago
Given that several of my local taxi services already cover a lot of this with their apps - Ordering, payment, GPS, invoices, account management, fares etc - it's my guess that there's already an enterprising software house out there selling skin-able apps for most of this.
Hooking it into multiple systems would be the technical challenge, the rest seems a solved problem.
Oh, and some folks (probably mostly Europeans) don't really like the driver-ratings thing. It's an end-run around little things like employment rights. A ratings scheme for the individual taxi companies providing the services perhaps is useful, but not individual driver ratings.
- TeMPOraL 11y agoDriver ratings seem fine from customer POV - they let you appreciate good service or take revenge on the driver if you didn't like something about it. Most people don't know that it may take one negative review to get the driver fired (or whatever Uber calls it, since because they're not employees they can't be technically fired). What's the minimum allowed average score now? It used to be somewhere around 4.3 - 4.6 out of 5.
- Nursie 11y agoI guess that's my real problem with them. It's not like the rating goes back to head office who bring in Bob or Kate Taxidriver and ask if they need some training, or how they can help them improve the service, or if they're happy working for Bob&Kate's Taxi Service, it's "your ratings dropped, bye".
- JoshTriplett 11y ago> Hooking it into multiple systems would be the technical challenge, the rest seems a solved problem. There's a massive non-technical challenge as well: getting the companies to cooperate when both sides (the taxi companies and the unified service) would rather cut out the other intermediary, and when both the drivers and the passengers would benefit from fewer intermediaries (lower costs and higher consistency for the passengers, higher percentage of the fare going to the drivers). > Oh, and some folks (probably mostly Europeans) don't really like the driver-ratings thing. It's an end-run around little things like employment rights. A ratings scheme for the individual taxi companies providing the services perhaps is useful, but not individual driver ratings. How are driver ratings an employment rights issue? What's wrong, precisely, with recognizing when someone repeatedly does an unacceptably bad job? They're absolutely necessary, and a big part of maintaining consistency and quality. I've almost always had good experiences, but the few times I haven't (e.g. a driver going on a racist tirade), I've been glad to be able to provide a rating, and for that matter receive an actual response from a human. That would do a lot less good if that rating only applied to a taxi company, rather than to a specific driver. Why not give the taxi company enough information to recognize their good and bad drivers?
- Nursie 11y ago>> There's a massive non-technical challenge as well: getting the companies to cooperate when both sides (the taxi companies and the unified service) would rather cut out the other intermediary Yet it happens in some places, there are now apps in many major cities that do just this across multiple firms. >> How are driver ratings an employment rights issue? Your ratings have dropped, you are no longer eligible to contract for Uber, goodbye. >> Why not give the taxi company enough information to recognize their good and bad drivers? I suppose I don't object to that, it's fine. It's the Uber strategy of kicking people off the books that's objectionable.
- JoshTriplett 11y agoSo you're OK with recognizing bad drivers, but you want to force a service to keep contracting with them anyway despite their poor performance?
- lmm 11y agoI want an employer to fulfill the responsibilities that go with employing a human being. That doesn't mean not firing anyone ever, but it does mean following a process, giving them access to (union) representation, and (in cases of simple poor performance rather than gross misconduct) giving them an opportunity to improve before firing them. If you just go by raw customer ratings, what prevents e.g. racists/sexists/homophobes from deliberately getting people fired?
- JoshTriplett 11y agoI would expect that they do have a process, and that it operates uniformly for all drivers. Drivers handle a large volume of customers; unless the rating system is badly broken, a single customer could not single-handedly swing ratings enough to get someone fired. I would also hope that the service contracting the drivers would not accept a single unsubstantiated account as unassailable evidence, and would look for a corroborated pattern instead. Given that drivers can see their own rating, and the rating thresholds for drivers are well-known, getting close to that point would serve as fairly clear warning of needing improvement (if there isn't an explicit warning to that effect). So there's an opportunity to improve. Apart from that, I'm not going to comment further on the already extensive volume that has been written about the merits of "contractor" versus "employee"; the arguments there are already quite well known and don't need further rehashing.