4 ms·
I guess the concept of a cap seems odd, when one could let the market decide. Not that I'm the sort that believes that the market always results in optimal out
by Nursie 11y ago
I guess the concept of a cap seems odd, when one could let the market decide.
Not that I'm the sort that believes that the market always results in optimal outcomes or anything, but it does seem weird.
- mmarx 11y ago> I guess the concept of a cap seems odd, when one could let the market decide. Keep in mind that, like busses and trams, taxis are considered part of the public transport infrastructure in Germany. One particular consequence is that taxi drivers are not allowed to refuse fares, and that fare prices are fixed.
- Nursie 11y agoYes that is the same where I live (at least the fixed prices). Come to think of it, I have no idea if we have a cap here!
- novalis78 11y agoWell, not for Germany, where the free market is always eyed suspiciously when a superior government bureaucracy could tell you what's in your best interest. I hope the Sarcasm was noticable.
- coldtea 11y agoI didn't notice it. But then again, I've seen time and again markets come to awful end results without regulation.
- Brakenshire 11y ago> I guess the concept of a cap seems odd Yeah, it does initially to me as well, but I suppose it's just another public policy lever for transportation, and acts a bit like congestion charging. For instance, in a lot of very busy streets in London, due to congestion, pollution, and desire to improve public space, there are debates about pedestrianization, or allowing through only buses, or allowing only buses and taxis, or allowing that plus local access. For instance, Oxford Street (which has half a million pedestrians each day) shifted some years back to only allow through buses and taxis, to improve throughput and reduce pollution, and the new mayoral candidates are now thinking about pedestrianization. Ultimately, one person siting in a cab occupies the same space as 10-15 pedestrians (at Oxford Street densities), or perhaps 5 bus passengers. Further east, Tottenham Court Road is getting a new Crossrail station (a new tube line), and is going to widen the pavements, and ban private cars, in order to deal with the massive expected increase in passengers. Taxis are more efficient than private cars, but much less so than other options, so it just depends on the context for the city centre, or the city as a whole, or for particular streets, as to how appropriate they are. One niche that major taxi app services could fit into, in these contexts, is by enabling a system for pooling / shared-use. A London taxi with 4/5 people is probably no less efficient than a bus, and to do something like that takes scale and serious optimization work.
- mschuster91 11y ago> A London taxi with 4/5 people is probably no less efficient than a bus It is far less efficient. A bus can hold 60 passengers and more, with one driver and one engine. The same amount of passengers would require ten cabs, ten drivers and ten engines.
- Brakenshire 11y agoOn reflection, you're right. Perhaps three taxis occupy the same road space as one bus, if they're full that might mean 15 people, compared to perhaps 30 on a single-decker, and 60 on a double-decker bus. But still, I would say there's potential for high-occupancy taxis to play a role. In the future it may well be that the distinctions between buses, taxis and Uber-style service gets blurred. I remember reading that there are already trials in Finland for on-demand buses which dynamically alter their route to pick up and deliver passengers.