7 ms·
What Happens When Virtual Reality Gets Too Real
- hellbanner 11y agohttp://www.amazon.com/gp/product/0441005667?keywords=forever%20peace http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/0441005667?keywords=forever... Forever Peace: sci-fi written by a Vietnam War veteran. US Military uses robots for fighting that include mind-to-mind communication.. but bans links longer than N Days. After N days, a human with such an immediate connection to another becomes irrevocably pacifist.
- vdaniuk 11y agoThat's great SciFi but maybe don't do the spoiler thing and edit your comment? The main side effect of mind-to-mind communication doesn't get revealed until the end of the story.
- hellbanner 11y agoSorry, I can't (too late to edit).. wanted to discuss the idea and doubted much of HN had read it. Thanks though!
- jkot 11y agoI think there is similar and older book written by Harry Harrison or some other veteran.
- cfcef 11y ago> In the Stanford lab, researchers have found even a single experience can affect people. In one test, researchers found that test subjects who had just cut down a virtual tree used fewer paper towels when cleaning up a spill after the experience than subjects who hadn’t cut down a tree. Oh great. More priming studies.
- ForcesOfOdin 11y agoIt's testing whether the virtual reality experience can 'prime' people for a behavior change. It was intentional priming and I don't see an inherent flaw there. The experiment does sound weak though. How reliable is the control on the amount of spilled, how accidental it seemed, and the timing for each group who had different events preceding the spill? Also, what does the behavioral difference matter if they do not carry that behavior beyond the single experiment or if the ones exhibiting that behavior were already more paper towel conscious without the VR. I find the article really weak because of a lack of substantial examples, and the examples given lack detail.
- endergen 11y agoThis is a great problem to have. I'd rejoice.
- Animats 11y agoI've heard that professor speak in EE380 at Stanford. The VR lab at Stanford isn't in the CS department; it belongs to the "communications" (marketing, PR) department. They have some scary results: They have a VR simulation of swimming with dolphins. They let little kids try it. Then a few months later, they ask the kids about their experience of swimming with dolphins. A sizable fraction think it really happened, and add details as if it were real. It's possible to use VR to implant false memories. They have the capability of mapping one face onto the video image of another person, and can construct, using morphing software, combinations of two faces. They've discovered that, if they construct a face which is weighted 1/3 or so of the subject's face and 2/3 of some politician's face, and play a campaign speech, people still recognize the politician but agree with them much more. Coming soon to an ad near you. [1] https://vhil.stanford.edu https://vhil.stanford.edu
- curuinor 11y agoI was in Jeremy's lab as an undergrad and master's student. There was a team of student RA's which was from the communications department and a team of student programmers who were CS, EE and Symbolic Systems. Many of the grad students were also in technical fields. Probably the scariest stuff, phenomenologically to me at least, is the gaze studies. Human gaze can be manipulated in VR to create very scary perceptions, avatars and agents can be made to seem as if they are staring at you unblinkingly and following your gaze whereever you are going, etc etc. Isopraxis, which is important to persuasion, can be done trivially and perfectly (that is, noisily), and social space manipulated also trivially.
- Swizec 11y ago> It's possible to use VR to implant false memories. What's even scarier is that it's possible to use traditional advertising to implant false memories. http://www.wired.com/2011/05/ads-implant-false-memories/ http://www.wired.com/2011/05/ads-implant-false-memories/
- Terr_ 11y agoI don't think it's usually part of the debate, but IMO it actually makes a lot of sense to justify ad-blocking as a mental-security measure, especially as more and more advertisers are deliberately setting out to try to hack your brain in a way that does not involve your conscious mind.
- ItsDeathball 11y ago>...the technology could affect users’ outlook and viewpoints more than other once-new technologies — such as televisions, the Internet or mobile phones — because it creates more lifelike experiences and often makes users active, rather than passive, participants. Hasn't this exact same thing been claimed about videogames for the last twenty years or so, by people who want to regulate game content, with no conclusive evidence?
- _asdf_asdf 11y agoWow, this VR simulation looks and feels EXACTLY like I'm sitting still in a chair, in an air conditioned room, with two pounds of earmuffs and safety goggles strapped onto my face! Wait, what's that smell? It smells like stale coffee that someone brewed only just a few hours ago... This is so realistic!
- curuinor 11y agoThe quality of being realistic in a mediated environment is called telepresence, or presence. There's a journal for it. It's a small journal, although pretty old for a CS journal (not at all old for a social science journal) so I read an appreciable piece of the thing for an aborted attempt at my master's thesis (my actual thing was way more formal). They've thought of all the stuff you just thought of. Even smells, in an Iraq War PTSD study or five (because they only have to simulate a few smells), and in some failed commercial products. The head-mounted displays began with the "Sword of Damocles", which was named that because it weighed 150 pounds and was dangled over your head and rendered a princely 100 polys/sec. So everything will get better, don't worry.
- startupfounder 11y agoWhy do we fear technological advancement? "Fire will get to hot and burn our villages", "the wheel will crush our children", "guns kill people", etc. Tools and technology are neither good or bad, it is what we humans do with these tools that create our reality. Yes, we could fill children's heads with a false reality, but on the contrary we can also provide education that is 100x better to the entire planet.
- rm_-rf_slash 11y agoPeople have a good reason to be cynical. At the early horizon of the Internet, people believed utopia was right around the corner. What they found was more income inequality while the biggest payouts in Silicon Valley went to people sucking up more of our information to sell us more ads. So yes, we certainly can do amazing things, but more often than not, someone in the boardroom will eventually ask: "where's the profit?" Just think of Facebook's Open Basics. They could afford to provide the extreme poor with the full internet, but they chose not to, since using Facebook at least would help the company collect more data and sell more ads. That was a deliberate choice.
- Thriptic 11y ago> So yes, we certainly can do amazing things, but more often than not, someone in the boardroom will eventually ask: "where's the profit?" That's because these entities are businesses, not charities. Their primary purpose is to generate profit, and the board is there to ensure that they do that. To expect a business to act like a charity is not reasonable.
- ProAm 11y ago> To expect a business to act like a charity is not reasonable. This is why we fear such leaps of technology, because the people doing it lack empathy and sympathy in place for profits.
- stcredzero 11y agoAt the early horizon of the Internet, people believed utopia was right around the corner. Here's the thing. What one generation imagined as "Utopia" keeps on happening in limited contexts. But by the time it becomes reality, the conception of "Utopia" has changed. It's a moving target much in the same way hard AI is a moving target. Today, I live in a world where I not only have to worry about getting enough to eat, I even have to worry about getting too many calories. In my society, poor people worry about that more! I don't have to worry about physical safety. I don't worry about disease. I have access to almost any information I want, including entertainments that even kings and queens could never have imagined. Pick some level of baseline security for some 1st world industrialized nation. If you described that to Sir Thomas More or John Stuart Mill, and told them how many millions have it, they'd think you were talking a pipe dream. Inequality is always the big problem, of course.
- jackgavigan 11y agoI played VRLympix' Ski Jump game[1] recently, which isn't at all photorealistic but the vision and motion control is spot on. Looking over the virtual edge of the ramp was a bit discombobulating but bearable. However, when I got up to speed and was approaching the jump, my lizard brain nearly panicked at the prospect of a potentially death-dealing jump/fall/crash, even though my higher brain knew that I was standing safely on a solid, flat floor. My brain seemed to trust the visual reference points at least as much, if not more than my inner ear and I had to lift the headset to stave off the feeling that I was going to fall over. 1: Here's a video of someone else playing it - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wtZgRqQw2uI https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wtZgRqQw2uI
- strictnein 11y agoClearly this: http://vrmaster.co/wp-content/uploads/2015/04/virtual-rality-and-fear.jpg http://vrmaster.co/wp-content/uploads/2015/04/virtual-rality...
- cbd1984 11y agoI never got how that was supposed to be so much worse than someone in ratty clothes in a ratty apartment reading books. Do people think any new technology is automatically The Matrix?
- mschuster91 11y agoWhat's missing is material feeling, like you see a switch, you see your hand touching the switch and you feel something. Could that be done using e.g. a metallic powder held in an oscillating magnetic field? If so, then shouldn't it also be possible to coat the particles with plastic, wood etc for a more realistic feel?
- ZenoArrow 11y ago> "What's missing is material feeling, like you see a switch, you see your hand touching the switch and you feel something." Take a look at this, I think it could be the start of what you're looking for. http://www.wired.co.uk/news/archive/2015-07/03/haptic-japanese-holograms http://www.wired.co.uk/news/archive/2015-07/03/haptic-japane...
- mschuster91 11y agoAwesome, kind of looks like a miniature holodeck. But I think with this technology it wouldn't be possible to convey the behavior of materials (e.g. metal feels cold to the touch, wood not)... The alternative would of course be direct neural manipulation a la Matrix but I highly doubt that research in this direction will happen due to ethical concerns...
- ZenoArrow 11y ago> "But I think with this technology it wouldn't be possible to convey the behavior of materials (e.g. metal feels cold to the touch, wood not)..." Perhaps, though consider what makes metal cold to the touch, is it not just due to the way our brains interpret a certain set of electrical impulses received by our skin? If that's the case, perhaps we could combine the haptic holograms with sensory gloves, e.g. the holograms provide the physical resistance of the virtual item, and the gloves mimic the electrical signals that convey the other physical properties of the item.
- mschuster91 11y agoHmm yeah, that could help... but one problem remains, if you want to display an holographic forest, you'll need a holo-room the size of the forest.
- pshc 11y agoAnecdotally, I experienced mild depersonalization in 2014 after too many sessions in the DK2. (Other life stresses were also a factor though.) Very disorienting at the time. But I know what that dissociation feels like now and can manage it, so I'm looking forward to pushing boundaries with CV1!
- danharaj 11y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hyperreality https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hyperreality Think about how many concepts are social fictions that everyone takes for granted as real. Hyperreality is already here in more subtle ways.
- stcredzero 11y agoSummary: VR will change morality. The change won't be the end of the world. Most likely, some changes will be highly disturbing. I enjoy computer games. I played FTL until I had all the ships and all of the achievements, so perhaps I qualify as a gamer. I volunteer at a videogame museum. I have many friends who are avid gamers. That said, I seem to keep on meeting young people have a moral system along the lines of, "If the laws of physics and the laws of the government where I reside allow it, I can do it, and it's moral." The world isn't going to end, and it won't result in an instant Mad Max post-apocalyptic world, but technological changes do have an effect on morality. Pre 1400, insisting that people be on time to the minute, or even to 15-20 minutes would have been considered quite crazy. Birth control had a tremendous effect on what society considers moral. When music had to be distributed as manufactured objects, the technology brought about one set of moral standards with regards to the selling/owning/distributing of music. Now that all media exist as bits, we are now seeing a different set of moral standards come into being. (One of which is, "Pics or it didn't happen.") So VR is clearly going to influence what society considers "moral" -- probably in ways we can't easily forsee. Many of alive today -- even typical members of the HN community -- are going to find some of these changes quite disturbing.
- golergka 11y ago> That said, I seem to keep on meeting young people have a moral system along the lines of, "If the laws of physics and the laws of the government where I reside allow it, I can do it, and it's moral." How is it anything new? > When music had to be distributed as manufactured objects, the technology brought about one set of moral standards with regards to the selling/owning/distributing of music. Are you referring to copyright? I believe these changes happened earlier, when printed scores started to sell big numbers.
- stcredzero 11y agoHow is it anything new? There were always contexts where people could think, "Here's what people think is proper, but what can we actually do?" However, virtual spaces of the early 21st century are particular in the degree to which social/nonverbal cues are almost nonexistent or completely gone, and where consequences are so very skewed towards an amoral stance of, "What can we get away with?" New VR technologies may well be a reversal of these conditions. So, it's nothing completely new at the most simplistic level. But if you look more closely, it's the unintended consequences arising out of the details that are the most interesting and significant. Are you referring to copyright? I believe these changes happened earlier, when printed scores started to sell big numbers. Printed scores are manufactured objects. If you go back even farther, to when you had to have your own instrument and enough talent to learn music quickly by ear, you'll find a set of moral standards around the "ownership" of music similar to the one developing from today's environment of easy digital copying.
- have_faith 11y agoGene manipulation, advanced AI, advanced immersive VR, expanding population, a rush to control essential assets (water, food, power), internet with speeds that makes measuring the speed unnecessary, future Google Glass, quantum computing, further class inequality, further technological advancement with no effect on reducing the work day. I for one welcome our Ghost in the Shell/Matrix/Blade Runner future.