3 ms·
A lot of MS software design has been historically clueless about network latency, I'll grant you that. I sometimes joke about imagining a world where the web is
by barrkel 17y ago
A lot of MS software design has been historically clueless about network latency, I'll grant you that. I sometimes joke about imagining a world where the web is built on top of DCOM, where the view in your browser is rendered via object-oriented RPC calls from the server, etc.
Apple are a much more insidious threat, though, in my opinion. One of the reasons I first got into programming was because one of the first computers I got didn't have any I/O other than the keyboard, the monitor and speakers - the tape drive was broken. A flashing BASIC prompt (ultimately MS licensed) greeted me at every power-on. The only way I could do anything with the machine was to write the program myself; and I could keep nothing of what I wrote, and had to write it all again if I wanted it again. Every night I wrote an alarm-clock program to wake me up in time for school the next morning.
Now if I were that age again today, and had an iPhone or iPod touch in my pocket, or god forbid an iPad in my bag, I couldn't even write a program on it, much less save it on the local file system. Apple is almost intrinsically hostile to software engineers, as I see it. Developers are like rodents to be trapped by promises of a slice of market willing (and hopefully forced) to pay for software; but the trap is far tighter than anything MS has ever lain.
- jodrellblank 17y agoIt might be a threat to your/our way of life, but I'm not convinced it's a thread overall. You can't write a program for your TV or Wristwatch, microwave or land line phone, LCD screen menu system or DVD player. People can't do surgery without planning years in advance and studying for years in specialised schools, and this has been the case for hundreds of years, yet children still grow up to be doctors and surgeons; and all sorts of other professions which don't have free-home-tinkering-kits available. If "everybody" wants an iPad and "nobody" cares that they can't program on it, then we're the minority in a tyranny of the majority situation and the only way out is having enough money to pay a company to design your own alternative. It feels like something is really being lost - a lot of humans world wide growing up as content consumers, not realising that if they could shape the right forms, they could do the same kinds of magic themselves - equals not subservients[1]. But is anything really being lost? If you were a kid today would your nightly alarm clock program have the same charms when run up against your mobile phone's built in alarm? Maybe it's time for software development to grow up and realise the days you could build a spreadsheet in your home are gone with the days you could make cough syrup from home, and the industry needs to become a more professional, 'trained adults only' kind of industry. In the early days of machine code, software was the electric circuits that rich eccentric people built in their labs. Basic was the valve radio circuits that Feynman puzzled over as a kid. C was the 555 timers and 74xx logic gates. We were hoping that software would be a new kind of material to work with altogether, each iteration building on the previous work so that as it gets more powerful it still presents a small surface area, stays easy for beginners, kids, curious people to put modules together. Instead, modern software is the integrated circuits that need years of training to use. It didn't become drag-and-drop coding, it became NSDocument printDocumentWithSettings:showPrintPanel:delegate:didPrintSelector:contextInfo: Instead of an OLPC which is both hackable device and the result of hacking at itself, we get iPad - you hack on your specialist hackstation (Mac/PC/...) and view in the iPad browser. Like you make 3D renderings in Blender and view them in a picture viewer, or a nationwide phone exchange which ends in a handset with a pad of numbers, like you design paint in a large chemistry lab and it ends up in a small pot with a brush. Like many other industries. [1] I twigged the other day that this is a major difference between me and a hobbyist friend of mine. He treats things with interest as if he is an equal and has every right to learn about them, willing to dive into a subject and believe he can get results. I treat things as nuanced and designed by experts, full of details to be cautious of and traps for the beginner, something to worry about and avoid. I like his style.
- barrkel 17y agoMy PC is my TV and DVD player combined. I don't know what an "LCD screen menu system" is. I don't have a land-line phone; but I can write a program for my phone, and without needing to pay yearly for the privilege. Or printing: "SampleForm.Print;" in my case, at the extreme (Delphi). The microwave, I'll grant you. It's handy for heating up tea that's been brewing long enough to cool down too much; that's about it.
- ido 17y ago> I couldn't even write a program on it, much less save it on the local file system. Can you not save text files on the iPad? That's pretty much the only thing you need for a js application that runs in safari (which these days has a wicket fast js interpreter and supports the canvas, webgl, audio & video tags).
- barrkel 17y agoNo, it's not obvious to me how one writes a JS application, saves it, and runs it on the iPad.
- jodrellblank 17y agoAbout the only thing I can think of would be: A website that you go to with a live JS edit/run cycle, saved on the server on the fly, EtherPad style. An option to have it email the code to your iPad email address as a clickable link which is a javascript bookmarklet. An option to have it save the javascript as a bookmarklet/link which you can on the home page. This is a hack on the iPhone - encode a PDF into a Javascript bookmark and sync it to Safari's bookmarks (i.e. http://pimm.wordpress.com/2007/07/18/how-to-read-pdf-files-on-iphone-via-safari-instead-of-lame-email-attachments/ http://pimm.wordpress.com/2007/07/18/how-to-read-pdf-files-o... ). Maybe if the server had a way to remember or reopen and tidy your code it would be closing in on PG's RFS#5. You can't cron-job anything, and you can't work with any language other than Javascript unless you make a server side to->Javascript compiler for it. Another user suggested that there is now or soon to be inter-app file transfer, so depending on how that is implemented it might open other venues.
- DannoHung 17y ago2.5 years of a closed phone platform is an insidious threat? Where were you for most of the 2000's? I predict that within 2 years the iPhone OS will allow you to run unapproved apps provided you click through enough, "Hey, we're warning you! Don't come crying to us when you manage to blow up your dock connector", messages.
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- barrkel 17y agoiPad isn't a phone. iPod Touch isn't a phone. To the degree that these devices are successful, they will be replacing user-programmable devices from the bottom up. It's all very well for you to "predict that within 2 years" everything will be fine. That's not the way it is today, and it's not the way it has been in the past. Everything I know about Apple tells me they have no love for developers whatsoever, and that their rise is one of the worst things that could happen to this industry in terms of open platforms. Apple likes their monopolies much, much more than MS does.
- DannoHung 17y agoSomething is only user programmable insofar as the user has the capability to program it. An open device today still wouldn't be user programmable because most people would not have the ability to do so even if they had the desire. For those people (read >95% of the market), functionality and ease of use are so, SO much more important than theoretical freedom.
- bitwize 17y agoMaking things friendly to developers necessarily introduces holes and seams. And seams make the Steve very angry. Very angry, indeed!