3 ms·
> the torque curve in a typical gasoline vehicle follows the horsepower curve It does that because the laws of physics require it. Diesel is not exempt from th
by ars 11y ago
> the torque curve in a typical gasoline vehicle follows the horsepower curve
It does that because the laws of physics require it. Diesel is not exempt from the laws of physics: horsepower = torque * rpm. This is not an approximation, it's an exact relationship, diesel works identically.
You can put different gearing on diesel or gasoline to make them work however you like - the only thing that matters at the end of the day is horsepower, once you know the horsepower torque and rpm can be traded off against each other.
> Had they been willing to accept slightly lower MPG numbers, they would have been in compliance with the law.
If it were so simple to just change the programming VW would have released a fix already for their illegal cars. But they have not because what they are trying to do (clean diesel) actually appears impossible. It's not the simple MPG change you are trying to make it out to be.
> But this whole idea that diesel is doomed seems very off kilter to me. Diesel produces fewer greenhouse gases, converts hydrocarbons to kinetic energy most efficiently of all internal combustion engines, has fewer emissions from ancillary chemicals than gasoline like acetone and toluene (both unregulated at present).
Now it's you that is trying to mislead people.
They are only efficient if allowed to pollute! If you restrict them from polluting they are NOT more efficient than gasoline. (Which you touched on just one paragraph before, and then seemed to immediately forget.)
You simply can't have it both ways, and making clean gasoline is much easier than clean diesel.
> has fewer emissions from ancillary chemicals than gasoline like acetone and toluene
Maybe less of those, but far more of much much more harmful stuff. Both of those have very short lives in the atmosphere and cause very few problems. Acetone is actually pretty much non-toxic, it's made naturally in the body. And Toluene is only mildly toxic - I'll take both over what diesel produces.
- CodeWriter23 11y agoI think you may wish to consult some actual charts like I did. Gasoline Engine: http://paultan.org/images.paultan.org/uploads/2006/08/a4test_2tfsitorquecurve.jpg http://paultan.org/images.paultan.org/uploads/2006/08/a4test... Diesel Engine: http://g35driver.com/forums/attachments/g35-sedan-v36-2007-08/141825d1312931616-traded-g35-tigtorq1.jpg http://g35driver.com/forums/attachments/g35-sedan-v36-2007-0... > They are only efficient if allowed to pollute! [Citation Needed] Industry mags are predicting the MPGs will meet the EPA Window Sticker and the emissions requirements. http://www.edmunds.com/car-news/how-the-volkswagen-diesel-scandal-will-affect-your-tdis-mpg-rating.html http://www.edmunds.com/car-news/how-the-volkswagen-diesel-sc... https://www.cars.com/articles/vw-diesel-owners-should-get-epa-mileage-after-fix-1420681342830/ https://www.cars.com/articles/vw-diesel-owners-should-get-ep... Wired's informal testing shows less than a 10% decrease in fuel efficiency when tricking the ECU into going into "test" (and therefore NOx-compliant) mode: http://www.wired.com/2015/10/vw-diesel-cheat-mode-mpg-performance/ http://www.wired.com/2015/10/vw-diesel-cheat-mode-mpg-perfor... Of course, the actual results remain to be seen. You might want to check out the tdiclub.com forums, there are some top techs on there that explain what is really going on.