2 ms·
I tend to see the best in people, so I think Zuckerberg honestly believes Free Basics is a good idea, and not against net neutrality. I can see one way of this
by danpalmer 11y ago
I tend to see the best in people, so I think Zuckerberg honestly believes Free Basics is a good idea, and not against net neutrality. I can see one way of this coming about...
You start with an idea to give completely free, net-neutral internet to the poor.
Next someone tells you that you need to pipe that through something so that the ISPs don't charge for the data, fine, it's now free, but goes through a pipe, and since you have a company with lots of resources, let's make it a Facebook pipe, as it's easier. You ask services to just register with you so that you can let them through the pipe.
Then you realise that most people using this are going to be using it on devices that can't run Javascript and heavyweight CSS, so the content needs to be a little more basic. Facebook already does that, but you need other services to, so you run a few quick quality checks on their site when they sign up. Easy, better user experience, anyone can still do this, anyone can sign up to provide a service on free basics, so it's still neutral right?
Finally, you find out that lots of these countries that you're providing free basics in have random obscure laws about what you can and can't do online, so you add in a clause that lets you deny approval to sites that don't conform to the laws, just to cover yourself legally, you don't want to be sued out of the country by the government, otherwise you wouldn't be able to provide your service!
So that's it, you can now provide a net-neutral service to non-internet users.