4 ms·
Instead of having all of these tax brackets, which for all of the smart people and companies they are meaningless anyway since they take advantage of the hundre
by mtgx 11y ago
Instead of having all of these tax brackets, which for all of the smart people and companies they are meaningless anyway since they take advantage of the hundreds and hundreds of loopholes (also called "deductions") so they don't pay the full amount, why not have a flat 15-20% income tax for everyone instead - rich or poor?
I think it would be simpler, more honest, more transparent, and more fair (slightly favoring the rich, but it more than makes up or it in other ways). You also wouldn't have these endless discussions about whether you should tax the poor 10% (because the tax affects them more) and the rich 30%, or the poor 30% and the rich 10% (because they are the "job creators")?
A moderately fair flat 15% income tax for everyone. No deductions for any special interest.
I'm not a huge fan of subsidies either, but if you really think you need to "make it easier" for some vital or up and coming industries, then you could give them some subsidies for a while. That would also be a more direct and more transparent approach than giving them lower taxes, because then you'd know exactly how much of the taxpayer's money is going into aiding an industry and there would be bigger pressure to end that subsidy eventually.
- chromatic 11y agowhy not have a flat 15-20% income tax for everyone instead - rich or poor? Because the marginal propensity to consume is very different between "rich" and "poor", to start.
- bicknergseng 11y ago>You also wouldn't have these endless discussions about whether you should tax the poor 10% (because the tax affects them more) >No deductions for any special interest. >I'm not a huge fan of subsidies either, but if you really think you need to "make it easier" for some vital or up and coming industries, then you could give them some subsidies for a while. Er.
- cpursley 11y agoEasy answer - it removes divisive politics from the equation. No more "the rich don't pay their fair share" from the left and "what's mine is mine" from the right. Both of those are powerful tactics that the bureaucrats employ to keep us bickering while them and their cronies rob us blind.
- cpursley 11y agoBy the way, a number of countries have a flat income tax: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Flat_tax#Countries_that_have_flat_tax_systems https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Flat_tax#Countries_that_have_f...
- cpursley 11y agoIt's interesting to get down votes for sharing link to wikipedia. Is taking a look at functioning flat-tax systems of other governments not even worth investigating, or does the very idea simply clash with some folks political agendas? Several of the nations are able to provide for both social welfare (including free secondary education and basic healthcare) as well as national defense on a (typically low) flat tax. Russia's 13% stands out for a large country and Estonia's 21% for a small country.
- mikeash 11y agoA flat tax disproportionately hurts the poor. Losing 15% of your income when you can barely make ends meet is much worse than losing 15% of your income when you're making a million dollars. It looks fair mathematically, but it's anything but. Of course, the current crazy tax structure ends up being fairly flat. Poor people pay different taxes, but the proportion is the same. But it would be better to fix that, not codify it.