5 ms·
U.S. Federal Individual Income Tax Rates History, 1862-2013
- ck2 11y agoJust a reminder that modern wars are done off the books without "pay fors" that congress insists on for everything else or your taxes would be absolutely insane. Like the $2 Trillion Iraq War.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- MCRed 11y agoI'm not sure about the "pay fors" you're talking about, but I believe your sentiment is correct-- and effectively, that $2T came out of the economy via the hidden tax of inflation. While people would be mad to see the $2T in direct taxation (what you called "Absolutely insane") they do not realize it when it is done via inflation. (Eg: your gas prices, food prices, everything else is higher, because the government just printed the money to spend on the war, increasing the debt and devaluing the dollar.) From The Economic Consequences of the Peace: “Lenin is said to have declared that the best way to destroy the Capitalist System was to debauch the currency. By a continuing process of inflation, governments can confiscate, secretly and unobserved, an important part of the wealth of their citizens. By this method they not only confiscate, but they confiscate arbitrarily; and, while the process impoverishes many, it actually enriches some. The sight of this arbitrary rearrangement of riches strikes not only at security, but at confidence in the equity of the existing distribution of wealth.” John Maynard Keynes
- jpgvm 11y agoGenerally when new spending is proposed it needs to be budgeted and either money repurposed from somewhere or new taxes introduced. This is sometimes referred to as "pay-fors".
- hihithere 11y agoGod Damm, 90% tax rate!!
- ceejayoz 11y agoMarginal tax rate. That's an extremely important distinction. A lot of people think moving up in to a higher tax bracket means their entire income is taxed at that rate, but it's entirely untrue. The top US tax bracket for 2015 starts at $413,201, but if you make $413,202 only the last $1 is taxed at that top rate.
- hsitz 11y agoWell, then, "God damn, 90% marginal tax rate!" For ultra-high income people, say making ten times the income where 90% rate kicks in (or around $10M in 2013 dollars annually in this historical data) the marginal tax rate can end up very close to their overall tax rate. Remember also, that historically the rates for capital gains and dividends were identical to those of ordinary income. All this is what people need to reference when they talk, e.g., about the rich having manipulated a redistribution of wealth over past decades. The sad thing is tiny percentage of current populace (including the rich) have no idea that current income taxes are extraordinarily low historically. Formerly it was generally understood that progressive taxation was a good thing and made sense. America's "glory days" somehow happened with tax rates that conservatives now call "socialist".
- DigitalJack 11y agoTaxes discourage work. In the 70's it was common for just one member of a family to work, because if another person worked, all their dollars would be taxed at the 50-70% rate. The cost of working in terms of taxes, owning a car, gas, etc., got to the point where if a second person worked, the household would actually lose money, which of course leads to economic stagnation and recessions. I agree progressive taxes make sense. The argument that a flat tax is fair by virtue of already being proportional fails to take into account the relative value of a dollar to the owner of that dollar.
- applecore 11y agoJust a reminder: due to the exceptional circumstances following World War II, the top marginal individual tax rate was around 90%. (The effective rate was really about 70% for the highest incomes since so few paid actually the top rate.) This was largely to prevent war profiteering, though it lasted until 1964 when the top marginal tax rate was lowered to 70%. It's not really relevant to our times unless you're forecasting another global war, in which case all bets are off.
- ceejayoz 11y ago> It's not really relevant to our times unless you're forecasting another global war, in which case all bets are off. According to http://www.csmonitor.com/Business/new-economy/2011/1025/Iraq-war-will-cost-more-than-World-War-II http://www.csmonitor.com/Business/new-economy/2011/1025/Iraq..., the Iraq war will wind up costing "more than the $3.6 trillion the US spent to fight World War II, even after adjusting for inflation". Add in Afghanistan and the ongoing airstrikes and likely expansion into other areas of extremism, and maybe we should start talking about Americans at home paying a bit for the militarism in the form of higher tax rates.
- MCRed 11y agoIs that an argument for higher tax rates or lower ones? After all, if you are anti-war, would you really say tax rates should be higher so that we can have more wars? The weird thing seems to be that the people who are most anti-war want higher tax rates for things that are not war, and then when the money gets spent on war, they want even higher tax rates for the things they were originally promised but didn't get. Looking at tax history it seems like a repeating game of bait and switch.
- mtgx 11y agoInstead of having all of these tax brackets, which for all of the smart people and companies they are meaningless anyway since they take advantage of the hundreds and hundreds of loopholes (also called "deductions") so they don't pay the full amount, why not have a flat 15-20% income tax for everyone instead - rich or poor? I think it would be simpler, more honest, more transparent, and more fair (slightly favoring the rich, but it more than makes up or it in other ways). You also wouldn't have these endless discussions about whether you should tax the poor 10% (because the tax affects them more) and the rich 30%, or the poor 30% and the rich 10% (because they are the "job creators")? A moderately fair flat 15% income tax for everyone. No deductions for any special interest. I'm not a huge fan of subsidies either, but if you really think you need to "make it easier" for some vital or up and coming industries, then you could give them some subsidies for a while. That would also be a more direct and more transparent approach than giving them lower taxes, because then you'd know exactly how much of the taxpayer's money is going into aiding an industry and there would be bigger pressure to end that subsidy eventually.
- chromatic 11y agowhy not have a flat 15-20% income tax for everyone instead - rich or poor? Because the marginal propensity to consume is very different between "rich" and "poor", to start.
- bicknergseng 11y ago>You also wouldn't have these endless discussions about whether you should tax the poor 10% (because the tax affects them more) >No deductions for any special interest. >I'm not a huge fan of subsidies either, but if you really think you need to "make it easier" for some vital or up and coming industries, then you could give them some subsidies for a while. Er.
- cpursley 11y agoEasy answer - it removes divisive politics from the equation. No more "the rich don't pay their fair share" from the left and "what's mine is mine" from the right. Both of those are powerful tactics that the bureaucrats employ to keep us bickering while them and their cronies rob us blind.
- Animats 11y agoTake a look at 1953. Top rate, 92%. Consider the 1950s. President Dwight D. Eisenhower, the general in charge of winning WWII in Europe, a Republican, and very much into heavy defense spending. That administration developed, mass-produced and deployed nuclear submarines, B-52 bombers, ICBMs, aircraft carriers, A-bombs, and H-bombs. Bases were maintained all over the world, with large numbers of troops. Plus, the US paid some of the costs of putting Europe and Japan back together, and the interest on the national debt from WWII. Financial regulation was tight. There were commercial banks, which could take deposits and make loans, but couldn't trade in the stock market. There were savings and loans, which could make loans on houses and take deposits but not much else. There were stockbrokers, which could deal in stocks but not trade for their own account. Most stockbrokers were partnerships, such as Merril Lynch, Pierce, Fenner, and Beane, with the partners personally liable for losses. There were a few investment banks trading for their own account, such as J.P. Morgan. They were using their own money, and if they went under, that was their problem. Finance was very clearly subordinate to doing real stuff. The CEO of United States Steel made about $42,000 a year. The first billionaire had not yet appeared; John Paul Getty, a Texas oilman, broke through that barrier in the 1960s. Yet this locked-down economy produced the greatest economic boom in American history.
- moistgorilla 11y agoFighting for your life is a better incentive for productivity than money, who would have known.
- JonFish85 11y agoSide question: wasn't Rockefeller the first billionaire in the early 1900s?
- jordanb 11y agoPiketty points out that the post-WWII American confiscatory taxation regime was also a way to prevent the principle-agent problem[0] with corporate executives. Why, if I control the company, would I not just transfer all the valuable assets of the corporation to myself and leave the shareholders holding a sad sack of debt? Under postwar taxation, I wouldn't do that because I wouldn't actually personally end up with anything: it'd all go to the taxman. Now that the top marginal income rate is so low and the capital gains rate is even lower, we see top executives transferring vast amounts of corporate assets to themselves. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Principal%E2%80%93agent_problem https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Principal%E2%80%93agent_proble...
- mgalka 11y agoCool data source. Thanks for sharing. In case anyone is curious about the early history of the income tax, or why it is so spotty prior to 1913: The income tax was first imposed in 1861 to help pay for the Civil War. Prior to that, the government got most of its income from excise taxes and tariffs. In 1895, the Supreme Court declared the income tax unconstitutional, since it was not apportioned fairly between states, which is why the government added the 16th amendment in 1913, which gave it the power to impose an unapportioned income tax.
- brobinson 11y agoI still find it baffling that the USA has not had a Federal income tax for about half of its existence.
- mikeash 11y agoFor most of that time, the USA was more a collection of halfway sovereign states than a singular nation. It would be weird for the shared government to reach into the individual states and tax their citizens. The appearance of the federal income tax coincides with the gradual restructuring of the country to be a single strong government with geographical subdivisions.
- jordanb 11y agoDuring that time the US Federal Government was funded through tariffs and through selling land on the western frontier.
- brobinson 11y agoThis is interesting because the federal government still owns a lot of the land in the western half of the country. I saw an infographic recently (sourcing a federal agency's statistics) which said that 48% of California's and 88% of Nevada's land are owned by the federal government.