3 ms·
I'm also confused about whether the connection between the two is more meant to be "both Yardley and Snowden told the public about signals intelligence activiti
by schoen 11y ago
I'm also confused about whether the connection between the two is more meant to be "both Yardley and Snowden told the public about signals intelligence activities because they thought the government was doing the wrong thing" or "because Yardley was so indirectly successful at making the U.S. government aggressively spy on communications, it was inevitable that people working in that field would some day be disturbed and frightened by the scope of surveillance". (Or both?)
- danso 11y agoYeah I read through his Wikipedia page...granted, it was before I had coffee, but I didn't see anything where it was said he did it out of conscience. The Wikipedia entry claims he couldn't get a job in U.S. government so he ended up working for the Canadians. I felt as if the article was trying to make it sound like it's unfair that Yardley is in the NSA hall of heroes while Snowden is in exile. First of all, Yardley was inducted decades after his death; we don't know how things will change with Snowden. Second, Yardley actually contributed to "the cause"...that is, codebreaking for World War II...in fact, according to the OP, he led it. The problem was when he decided to write a book for it to make some money. And of course, he did it during a time when giving up cryptography secrets was not seen as treasonous (was it still too new?), which is a big factor.
- qubex 11y agoYardley was active during World War I (aka ”The Great War” before we had to number them), not World War II — a minor typo I'm sure but relevant for the comprehension of the comments by a cursory reader.