2 ms·
> I think left vs right means how much you care about people when it comes to their relative power and social status in society. If you don't like power inequal
by golergka 11y ago
> I think left vs right means how much you care about people when it comes to their relative power and social status in society. If you don't like power inequality, then you're on the left. If you enjoy it or are indifferent to it, then you're on the right.
So, you not only think that there's a universal definition of left vs right in politics but also that it's all about one single problem?
> On the other hand, supporting flat tax is somewhat alluding to the idea that money do not influence power relationships in society.
I don't support flat tax, it would be an insane and idiotic idea.
I just think it's the most fair and just tax scheme. But I don't even remotely support it.
> So I think the question is, do you believe in that assumption, that income has no influence on political power (and it cannot, for instance, limit personal freedom of other people)?
You intertwined a lot of very complicated issues with your comment. First of all:
1) Power inequality is not good or bad; it's too broad of a definition. In order to attach moral value to it, you have to look at a concrete example in context, not an abstract concept.
For example, I think you would prefer for a few of leading climate scientist to have more power over environmental policy than of people who don't believe in evolution, right? But this is power inequality, too.
2) Taxes are, in theoretically just world, should be a form of payment for government services. Government is an entity that provides us with invaluable services like justice system and other perks, from certification of medication to protection from foreign threats. It's good stuff, worth paying for. But in theory, I don't see any moral reasons for some people to pay more for these services than others.
You, on the other hand, want to use taxes as a tool to solve power inequality, because you decided that it's a bad thing. Not only this decision is rather strange (as I already discussed in point 1), but you're using a hack to implement a unrelated requirement with the help of a feature that was implemented for completely different reason. Once again, _in theory_ this makes no sense at all.
3) And finally, when you involve terms like "personal freedom" into equation, I can almost guarantee that we will end up arguing about what "personal freedom" really is, where it starts and where it ends, and will not able to come to a conclusion.
However.
You might have guessed that I separate the political theory of what just and what is not from political reality. In political reality that we have, democracy did not appear because of theoretical considerations of what is the best form of government: it evolved as a compromise between different parties who would've otherwise kill each other to determine who's right. So were the taxes. And our discussions about what is good and bad, in theory, have very little dent on reality, which is shaped by power struggles of millions of people acting of their self-interest; all we can hope to achieve is to solve these conflicts in the most peaceful way possible. Trying to construct the perfect government system out of theoretical considerations is futile if you're lucky, and if you're not, you get North Korea or Pol Pot's Cambodia.
- venomsnake 11y ago> But in theory, I don't see any moral reasons for some people to pay more for these services than others. If you have more property, you should pay more for protecting said property. So while life and limb protection should cost the same, property protection should be payed by people that actually have property.
- golergka 11y agoHuh, that's a really interesting argument. I would love to come up with a counter-argument, but I'll have to think about it for a while. Thanks.
- js8 11y ago> So, you not only think that there's a universal definition of left vs right in politics but also that it's all about one single problem? As I already explained elsewhere, I do believe that but with the caveat that the universality loses some explanatory power, of course. So yes, about a single problem, but the one that manifests in many ways throughout all human societies. > I just think it's the most fair and just tax scheme. I don't really see why you see it that way. From what moral principle does that follow? I personally think that "most fair and just" tax scheme is a consumption tax on natural resources. > For example, I think you would prefer for a few of leading climate scientist to have more power over environmental policy than of people who don't believe in evolution, right? But this is power inequality, too. I think it depends. I certainly wouldn't grant them unlimited power without any accountability (which may be, for example, they have to openly submit their conclusions for public review). But when you think about accountability, then the actual power differential is not so clear cut. You can have hierarchies and yet power equality. For example, Linus is ostensibly an absolute dictator when it comes to Linux kernel development, yet he has the same power as everyone else by the virtue of the source being generally accessible. > Taxes are, in theoretically just world, should be a form of payment for government services. If you understand government in that limited way, as a service provider, then yes. But government can also be understood as an executor of agreement of how to redistribute some resources within the society. In that case it's perfectly natural to have redistribution from wealthier to poorer. Take for example insurance. Is it fair that people who got lucky gave out effectively more than people who didn't? It's not just a payment for a service, it's a redistribution scheme. > I can almost guarantee that we will end up arguing about what "personal freedom" really is We can go into specifics, it's no big deal. What I meant, broadly, was circumstances like e.g. great potato famine, where if the society as a whole has the resources to help the poor, but they are in the hands of very few who don't want to give them up. I think it's hard to argue, then, the rich minority doesn't infringe on the personal freedom of the poor majority. > democracy did not appear because of theoretical considerations of what is the best form of government: it evolved as a compromise between different parties who would've otherwise kill each other to determine who's right I agree with that. But also, the very idea is embodied in the moral principle of equality. > And our discussions about what is good and bad, in theory, have very little dent on reality I don't think so. Theoretical analysis of moral principles may lead to interesting inventions, like democracy. I don't think humans have democracy inborn as a concept; it's a cultural thing they invented.