5 ms·
Who is really denunciating healthy debate? The notion that this is some sort of social cancer strikes me as completely out of touch with reality. I've seen may
by erikpukinskis 11y ago
Who is really denunciating healthy debate? The notion that this is some sort of social cancer strikes me as completely out of touch with reality.
I've seen maybe a handful of failed attempts to allow students to opt out of university course curricula. Is that what you are so horrified about? Or is it the mostly failed attempts to get people fired for saying things that some people found abhorrent?
I've yet to see anyone imprisoned for their speech by SJWs. Frankly, the anti-SJW stance reads to me as quite ironic: people horrified that someone they disagree with might be allowed to have a voice on the national stage. I thought the whole point of free speech was that people get to voice ideas you find abhorrent?
What's really frightening is how often posts like yours, which are completely devoid of specifics, get voted up. It's like a frenzy of anger that rises to the top of these kinds of threads, totally detached from any history. I'm assuming there is some history behind your post, but you didn't reference it. Someone like Salmon Rushdie stands up and says he's terrified of the witch hunts, without providing any specifics, and it makes national news with thousands of people chiming in about how scared they are too. But scared of what, exactly? People rarely say. "SJWs".
The South Park episode is beloved because it's all straw men. If you had to reference real events, it would become clear that it's mostly straw feminists and students who actually didn't cause any particular reign of terror. As if wild-eyed college students haven't been making accusations that are beyond the pale for... well, forever.
That said, maybe I'm out of touch with the news and there are some events I missed. I would love to learn of such events, because it would make this debate much more interesting. As it is I find it kind of frightening how much anger seems to be building up around what appears to be a fabricated danger.
- TeMPOraL 11y agoYou're out of touch with the news. Over the last few years there's been many, many cases of people whose lives or careers have been destroyed by SJW social media outrage - sometimes over a single stupid tweet, sometimes over a single stupid whisper to a friend that got overheard, and sometimes just out of virtue of being in the vicinity of the actual target. People have been bullied to suicide, but since it wasn't anyone prominent, it isn't even talked about. And those are only the most direct results of the general undertone that if you're a white person who even looks in a general direction of a woman or minority member, you might be crucified. The biggest chilling effect coming out of this is that you never know. Whole big areas of discussion topics have been turned into minefields. You may voice your opinions for months and only have intelligent audience discussing them with you, and then your irrelevant comment somewhere gets posted to Twitter and your life is over. The reaction is sudden and so out-of-proportion that it's like government nuking the city because of a speeding driver. > As if wild-eyed college students haven't been making accusations that are beyond the pale for... well, forever. They were. The difference is that now they're being listened to. It's probably the side effect of PR being the most important thing for companies and academic institutions.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- golergka 11y agohttp://www.nytimes.com/2015/11/10/us/university-missouri-protesters-block-journalists-press-freedom.html http://www.nytimes.com/2015/11/10/us/university-missouri-pro...
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- adekok 11y agoOr see https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=G5MPzQnokMU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=G5MPzQnokMU In which SJWs physically shove a journalist around, all the while claiming the moral high ground. And a professor at the university shoves a journalist, and then calls for "muscle" to eject him. Or https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6KpdL8UuntA https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6KpdL8UuntA In which SJWs in masks claim that trying to shut down other peoples speech with megaphones is their "freedom of speech". If "freedom of speech" means preventing others from talking, I think they've got the definition wrong.
- adekok 11y ago> people horrified that someone they disagree with might be allowed to have a voice on the national stage. You haven't been paying attention to events of the past few years. The SJWs have been very clear that the only permitted voice is theirs. That anyone who questions them deserves to be shunned, censored, shut down, vilified, and attacked. > As it is I find it kind of frightening how much anger seems to be building up around what appears to be a fabricated danger. You're out of touch with events. In the 1940's we had 18-20 year-olds go "over the top" in France. D Day, Iwo Jima, etc. Now, we have 18-20 year-olds hug pillows in "safe spaces" because someone who disagrees with them is giving a presentation in another building. I submit that exchanging bravery for cowardice is a net loss for society. You're getting downvoted because your comments are at odds to most peoples experiences. See the witch-hunting that went on with the University of Virginia rape accusation. Or the Duke Lacrosse team. In both case, self-proclaimed SJWs found the groups guilty. And demanded sanctions, bans, "forced education", public shaming, etc. Later, of course, the accusations turned out to be false. The prosecutor in the Duke Lacrosse case was disbarred for his activities in what can only be called a witch hunt. I submit that the rule of law is better than public lynchings. That careful analysis of events is better than knee-jerk reactions. Try joining an SJW group and asking questions, or raising a dissenting opinion. You'll see group-think enforced with a speed and efficiency that rivals communist party meetings. And see the public statements by people who've left SJW groups. Olivia Benson led the charge against "double plus ungood" thinkers. No tactic, no matter how slimy was beneath her. After she left, she publicly said that the SJW attacks on her were worse by far than the attacks from the people she opposed. When the "evil" groups act nicer than the "good" groups, I submit that you have your labels reversed. And lastly: > I've yet to see anyone imprisoned for their speech by SJWs. See https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Guthrie_vs._Elliott https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Guthrie_vs._Elliott He's on trial for "criminal harassment". An examination of the public facts shows that no such thing occurred. He publicly disagreed with SJWs. They then worked together to find ways to get him charged. His bail restrictions have destroyed his life. The judge could have forbid him from using twitter, or having contact with his accusers, or making public statements about the trial. Instead, as a self-employed graphical designer, he was banned from using the Internet for until the trial was over. Whatever the result of the trial, the SJWs have succeeded in using the criminal justice system to destroy an opponent. I submit that such behavior is unethical, reprehensible, and fundamentally opposed to anything resembling "justice". That's why you're getting downvoted. You're saying such behavior isn't that bad, and that the anti-SJWs are terrible people. No, no, they're not. The SJWs have a long track record of evil behavior. And of shaming, shunning, lying, and attacking anyone who disagrees with them.