3 ms·
Define "communist", and we can have a meaningful debate. This is the point: The US right tries to label anything they perceive as to the left of it socialist o
by vidarh 11y ago
Define "communist", and we can have a meaningful debate.
This is the point: The US right tries to label anything they perceive as to the left of it socialist or communist and by extension to equate all of these ideologies with Soviet or Chinese inspired socialism with total disregard for the fact that while it also includes related ideologies, this spectrum also encompasses ideologies that are further apart than Republicanism and Stalinism.
It just becomes comical when e.g. European style social democrats gets lumped in with Stalinists, ignoring that Stalin himself ordered all Komintern member parties to treat the social-democrats as fascists (more precisely they were deemed to be "social fascists") and to oppose them with the same urgency as they opposed Hitler, effectively destroying any chance of a united opposition to Hitler, and draining both.
And it just becomes ridiculous when libertarian and moderate socialists who fought the Bolsheviks authoritarian tendencies tooth and nail and often lost their lives also gets lumped in with them: Millions of socialists and communists and anarchists were amongst the 10 million dead during the Russian Civil War - fighting alongside the White's to oppose Lenin. Thousands died in the Kronstadt rebellion, demanding reinstatement of free speech. Rebellion after rebellion against the Bolsheviks were arranged by SR, Left SR, the Mensheviks and other left wing groups, leading to executions after executions, and starting in 1922 a concerted campaign of political show-trials. Tens of thousands of them were murdered after the Moscow Processes by Stalin in the 30's - at that point Stalin was even purging opposition inside the Bolshevik party.
Many, many more perished in labour camps or had been wiped out together with other political opponents in the years before for standing up for democracy.
So, if you define what you consider socialism and communism, we can nail down which of these groups you are including, and how many of them were actually actively opposing the mass murders you are referring to and/or were victims of them.
- Turing_Machine 11y agoOh, the Soviet Union, Mao, Pol Pot, the Kim dynasty? You've heard of those people, I take it. You're trying to set up a "No True Scotsman" argument. Won't work.