4 ms·
> As a lifelong supporter of social justice, the new wave of “social justice warriors” and their denunciation of healthy debate has come as a horrifying shock t
by golergka 11y ago
> As a lifelong supporter of social justice, the new wave of “social justice warriors” and their denunciation of healthy debate has come as a horrifying shock to me. Until recently, I believed that the fight for equality would herald a new age of empathy, diversity and understanding. Instead, many of my previously liberal allies have been taken over by the cult of victimhood and a collective fear of rejection. Like teenagers, they constantly check in with each other to affirm whether what they think is acceptable – and who can blame them? The consequences of dissent are excommunication from the tribe.
Seriously, latest season of South Park seems the best depiction of this phenomenon that I've seen so far.
- venomsnake 11y agoIt is mostly signaling + one upping each other. But they managed to turn me from moderate liberal (in the EU sense, I guess I am raving socialist by US) to complete nihilist. I want to see Trump elected just to piss them off.
- golergka 11y agoLabels are stupid anyway. I got detained by police on a demonstrations in support of gay rights and democratic elections. But at the same time, I believe that flat tax (not flat tax rate as in % of income, but flat tax as in constant amount of money per month) is the most just form of taxation. Not even remotely feasible, of course, and it would be very stupid to even try to implement it, but still, the most just in theory. Now — does it make me left or right?
- iMark 11y agoCould you expand upon your definition of flat tax? Is, for example, the constant amount of money you mention the same of every member of the populace regardless of income? If so, it bears semblance with the UK's poll tax (or Community Charge as it was officially labelled), an early 90's tax which was disastrously received (riots in the streets across the country). It introduced by a right wing government, and subsequently repealed
- arethuza 11y agoAnd it's not like it was just people who are "naturally" on the left who thought the Poll Tax was unfair - the Duke of Westminster (one of the largest landowners in the UK) apparently paid the tax for lots of his employees as he thought it was unfair that he should pay the same amount of tax as them.
- golergka 11y ago> Is, for example, the constant amount of money you mention the same of every member of the populace regardless of income? Yes. > If so, it bears semblance with the UK's poll tax (or Community Charge as it was officially labelled), an early 90's tax which was disastrously received (riots in the streets across the country). I didn't know about it, but it's exactly how I imagined it would turn out in reality.
- js8 11y ago> Now — does it make me left or right? I think it makes you confused. :-) Which is an OK state to be in, and it's up to you if you want to change that. Let me explain. I think left vs right means how much you care about people when it comes to their relative power and social status in society. If you don't like power inequality, then you're on the left. If you enjoy it or are indifferent to it, then you're on the right. Now democracy is a distinctly leftist concept, because it explicitly gives everybody the same political power. Gay rights, well, it's a little aside from this classification but basically equal rights for everybody is in the same ballpark (that's why most equal rights movements are considered leftist). On the other hand, supporting flat tax is somewhat alluding to the idea that money do not influence power relationships in society. Which is AFAICT empirically false. I do however think that you can recognize flat tax as being just under that assumption. You do seem to care about distribution of power in society, which makes you leftist. So I think the question is, do you believe in that assumption, that income has no influence on political power (and it cannot, for instance, limit personal freedom of other people)?
- Canada 11y ago> Now democracy is a distinctly leftist concept This one dimensional left vs. right can't accurately describe anything. Even the subject of wealth redistribution is too nuanced to be properly described or debated with this oversimplified left/right paradigm.
- js8 11y agoThey are broad categories, I agree, but my definition is consistent with the historical usage. Left/right originated in the French parliament, where on the left were proponents of political equality (you could perhaps, with a stretch, call them democrats), while on the right were proponents of keeping the hereditary privileges of the nobility. The definition of left/right I gave describes a very general moral principle. Of course there are many flavours of left and right, depending on the exact interpretation, and they don't agree in many things. However, you didn't give any argument why is democracy not leftist, according to the above, historically accurate, definition. GP asked if he is left or right, I gave an answer.
- TeMPOraL 11y agoPolitical labels are a total disaster. First of all, they promote this kind of ultra-low-resolution discussion where people pattern-match what other say to some political ideology and then dismiss it because that ideology is obviously bad. What we desperately need is to talk about details - whether this or that particular solution is good for that particular problem. For instance - should we internalize emission externalities by instituting a CO₂ tax? If so, then how high and why? Should we offset increasing automation with basic income or something else? Etc. Labeling it all as "communist" and dismissing it wholesale is about the most idiotic thing a human being can do in a discussion. Secondly, they promote this lunacy in thinking. Instead of trying to understand problems and picking ideas that may work, people adopt ideologies wholesale. "I am a libertarian, therefore I support free market everywhere", whether it makes sense or not. Or conversely, others want to regulate everything because their reasoning is basically "regulation is good". This is not science. It's not even religion. It's mindless tribalism. I see no other choice for humanity to move forward than trying to isolate that kind of politics from anything meaningful, just like we mostly did with religion in the West. If people want to endlessly debate who patternmatches better to one of their favourite history villains, fine. Let's just keep that type of thinking away from the process of deciding where to build a new nuclear power plant.
- Canada 11y ago> I want to see Trump elected just to piss them off. Me too. Many times over the past 6 months I wish I had a "TRUMP 2016" T-Shirt. Really, I don't even like the guy. I don't respect him. It's not as if he has a coherent philosophy anyway. It's just that he best represents the contempt I feel for the whole political process, all discourse surrounding it, and especially for the people who buy into the bullshit of anyone in the running.
- seivan 11y agoOnly moderate liberal? I've gone to the deep end of the right. Though I still advocate the regular progressive stuff: abortion, LGBT rights and immigration. I think Pim Fortyn was the last person who'd share my sentiment, but he got killed by a "social justice warrior". It's funny to see LGBT-right advocates side with radical islamists. I guess gay rights doesn't mean shit when you can get a huge muslim voting cattle.
- golergka 11y ago> It's funny to see LGBT-right advocates side with radical islamists. After talking to these people, I've repeatedly heard arguments like "well, they have been born in Ramallah, not Florida". Which is the worst kind of racism: thinking that certain groups of people just don't have to adhere to the same standards, essentially, treating them as kids and not responsible adults. Kids that attach people to trucks and drag them through the streets for being gay. But hey, they're oppressed themselves, so it's not really their fault.
- erikpukinskis 11y agoWho is really denunciating healthy debate? The notion that this is some sort of social cancer strikes me as completely out of touch with reality. I've seen maybe a handful of failed attempts to allow students to opt out of university course curricula. Is that what you are so horrified about? Or is it the mostly failed attempts to get people fired for saying things that some people found abhorrent? I've yet to see anyone imprisoned for their speech by SJWs. Frankly, the anti-SJW stance reads to me as quite ironic: people horrified that someone they disagree with might be allowed to have a voice on the national stage. I thought the whole point of free speech was that people get to voice ideas you find abhorrent? What's really frightening is how often posts like yours, which are completely devoid of specifics, get voted up. It's like a frenzy of anger that rises to the top of these kinds of threads, totally detached from any history. I'm assuming there is some history behind your post, but you didn't reference it. Someone like Salmon Rushdie stands up and says he's terrified of the witch hunts, without providing any specifics, and it makes national news with thousands of people chiming in about how scared they are too. But scared of what, exactly? People rarely say. "SJWs". The South Park episode is beloved because it's all straw men. If you had to reference real events, it would become clear that it's mostly straw feminists and students who actually didn't cause any particular reign of terror. As if wild-eyed college students haven't been making accusations that are beyond the pale for... well, forever. That said, maybe I'm out of touch with the news and there are some events I missed. I would love to learn of such events, because it would make this debate much more interesting. As it is I find it kind of frightening how much anger seems to be building up around what appears to be a fabricated danger.
- TeMPOraL 11y agoYou're out of touch with the news. Over the last few years there's been many, many cases of people whose lives or careers have been destroyed by SJW social media outrage - sometimes over a single stupid tweet, sometimes over a single stupid whisper to a friend that got overheard, and sometimes just out of virtue of being in the vicinity of the actual target. People have been bullied to suicide, but since it wasn't anyone prominent, it isn't even talked about. And those are only the most direct results of the general undertone that if you're a white person who even looks in a general direction of a woman or minority member, you might be crucified. The biggest chilling effect coming out of this is that you never know. Whole big areas of discussion topics have been turned into minefields. You may voice your opinions for months and only have intelligent audience discussing them with you, and then your irrelevant comment somewhere gets posted to Twitter and your life is over. The reaction is sudden and so out-of-proportion that it's like government nuking the city because of a speeding driver. > As if wild-eyed college students haven't been making accusations that are beyond the pale for... well, forever. They were. The difference is that now they're being listened to. It's probably the side effect of PR being the most important thing for companies and academic institutions.
- seivan 11y agoLee Kuan Yew understood early on that the call for "social justice" was essentially just a bunch of marxists trying to take power. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Operation_Spectrum https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Operation_Spectrum > His "key man" in Singapore was Vincent Cheng, a full-time Catholic Church worker in the Justice and Peace Commission Oddly enough I trust the dead Lee Kuan Yew more than I trust any "social justice" advocate... or the Swedish government. Sometimes I think the craziness of "social justice" sociopaths is on design, in order to push people to the far right. It certainly worked on me. Guess I'm weak minded enough to buy it. If we can look back in history and compare with national socialism growing, I am sure we can do the same with socialism/marxism. The way Singapore handled both islamic and marxists threats is incredibly useful to read about: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Operation_Coldstore https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Operation_Coldstore
- golergka 11y agoWell... Let's say that there's certain political movement A. And that certain _other_ political forces B are seeing that this political movement can be beneficial to them, so they infiltrate it and help it. Does it really mean that everyone who supports A is really covertly working for B? Don't you allow the possibility that a lot of people supporting A don't even think about B and are sincere in their support of the issue?
- seivan 11y agoOh yeah absolutely. I remember Occupy Wall street had the right idea until it got filled with AFA-filth and other shit. I still think Occupy Wall street had/has a point.