4 ms·
"lower class are basically slaves" You're going to compare working graveyards at 7-Eleven to slavery? You should read a little bit about slavery and human tra
by paulddraper 11y ago
"lower class are basically slaves"
You're going to compare working graveyards at 7-Eleven to slavery?
You should read a little bit about slavery and human trafficking. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Slavery https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Slavery I suspect most slaves would not agree with you.
- jgord 11y agoyes - in order to say something that is true, I need to say something that is false. You'd be right to call me on it, and I'd have it no other way.
- PaulHoule 11y agoBack in the days of slavery you were expected to provide some care when they got old. If you're an employee you can be cast away to go die in the street.
- lolc 11y ago"Fifty dollars reward, for the negro Jim Blake--has a piece cut out of each ear, and the middle finger of the left hand cut off to the second joint."
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- md224 11y ago> in order to say something that is true, I need to say something that is false. What does this mean?
- jgord 11y agoI use the term 'slavery' because its descriptive, not because its literally true. I do understand that 711 shift workers don't have their feet cut off if they leave. When I say things like "we need a bit of Socialism right about now" .. I don't mean hardcore enforced-total-equality Socialism, I mean nice Socialism like the kind Bernie Sanders has been raving about.
- chimeracoder 11y ago> I don't mean hardcore enforced-total-equality Socialism, I mean nice Socialism like the kind Bernie Sanders has been raving about. It's taboo to point this out, especially on HN, but I'm feeling bold today: You can't discuss the socialist policies of Western European countries without addressing their wealth. And you can't discuss the current wealth of Western European countries without acknowledging the process by which they acquired that wealth. The "nice socialism that Sanders has been raving about" is the kind that is practiced in countries with a long history of colonization and slavery[0]. During this timeframe, they "earned" a massive amount of money by extracting resources from people that they literally enslaved. This started before the 17th century and continued into the 20th century. Those people who were colonized and enslaved (and their countries) are still feeling the effects of that today, and they would not be so quick to describe that kind of socialism as "nice". [0] Denmark and Sweden are the two that Sanders has called out specifically by name.
- marshray 11y agoMany countries in Western Europe have been destroyed and rebuilt multiple times since the 19th century when slavery was practiced.
- chimeracoder 11y ago> Many countries in Western Europe have been destroyed and rebuilt multiple times This doesn't change the fact that the current economic status of Denmark and Sweden today is directly linked to their status as colonial powers and slaveholders from the 17th-20th century. > since the 19th century when slavery was practiced. This entire subthread began with the claim that being "low-class" in the US is tantamount to slavery. If that's the case, there should be no problem with accepting colonialism, as it was practiced by Sweden into the late 19th century and Demark into the early 20th century, as a form of slavery, since it resembles slavery far more closely than being a member of the working poor in the US.
- wfo 11y agoLanguage can be used in a rigorous, technical way with definitions and as close to accurately as possible. Like in a technical manual or programming language. Or it can be used in an expressive way, the way that normal people write and talk and communicate, where people say things that are technically inaccurate but express meaning and and allow the listener or reader to understand the position, emotions, facts, thoughts and experiences of the speaker or writer. For example, "I'm starving, let's get a bite to eat." Do you say "No you aren't, that's technically inaccurate, how dare you minimize the concerns of the starving multitudes across the globe" or do you say "Okay." because you understand what he means? That first response is how the "that's not real slavery!" thread of discussion here looks to the rest of us. I think what he meant by that was he is communicating in the second, expressive way.
- abalashov 11y agoChurch. I wrote a blog post recently that somewhat excoriated the technical community for a blunt and mechanistic approach to argumentation along these lines: http://likewise.am/2015/12/06/nitpicking-is-the-lowest-form-of-criticism/ http://likewise.am/2015/12/06/nitpicking-is-the-lowest-form-...
- nickbauman 11y agoMasters actually bought slaves. They weren't cheap. So they had to, you know, feed them and care for them somewhat. Now when you aren't needed at the 7/11 you can almost just go die in a fire: have you seen was homelessness is like in the US? I have.
- dnautics 11y agoYou do understand that this is basically the argument that slaveowners used to justify continuing slavery in the 19th century?
- marshray 11y agoExcept that no one is justifying slavery, it's just the opposite.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- horsecaptin 11y agoYou know it is a good time to re-think the current economical distribution when the slavery looks like a valid alternative to the status quo.
- nickbauman 11y agoIt would be a mistake to say I'm advocating slavery by making this comparison. The slave to a master is just like an automobile: you have to put gas into it to make it go. Turning a human being into something the equivalent of an automobile is an abomination. But I don't really think wage slavery is really all that different at the end of the day. My point is both are abominable.
- dnautics 11y agothat may have not been your intent, but it does reveal the error in your thinking. You may call both abominable, but do you not see the fundamental reason why one is categorically worse than the other? If not then you are doomed to advocate for the very problems that were the root of the atrocity of slavery, just in other, possibly more cryptic and slyly paternalistic forms.
- chimeracoder 11y ago> I suspect most slaves would not agree with you. No kidding! Believe it or not, even in 2016, there are tens of millions of people around the world living in actual slavery[0]. Most of them would probably still literally give a kidney to trade places with one of these lower-class people in the US. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Contemporary_slavery https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Contemporary_slavery
- calibraxis 11y agoBoth have in common the order-giver and order-obeyer. Of course, I agree wage slavery is better than chattel slavery. Better to have some choice of master than one imposed on you. (Though slaveowners made the interesting argument that they must take care of their workers because they own them, unlike the capitalist who merely rents them.) In the US, the prison system replaced slavery as the mechanism to control the black population. So the US has not improved much in that regard, with even children killed in broad daylight by the state.
- Fjolsvith 11y ago> In the US, the prison system replaced slavery as the mechanism to control the black population. So the US has not improved much in that regard, with even children killed in broad daylight by the state. Source?
- staunch 11y ago> You're going to compare working graveyards at 7-Eleven to slavery? > I suspect most slaves would not agree with you. The abolitionist and former slave Frederick Douglass initially declared, "now I am my own master", upon taking a paying job. But later in life, he concluded to the contrary, "experience demonstrates that there may be a slavery of wages only a little less galling and crushing in its effects than chattel slavery, and that this slavery of wages must go down with the other" https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wage_slavery https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wage_slavery
- paulddraper 11y agoIt's true that post Civil War blacks weren't doing well. (Actually, a lot of whites weren't doing well either.) But it's a real stretch of the imagination to say the current United States (especially post income tax and Social Security entitlements) is anywhere even close to post Civil War circumstances.
- hitekker 11y agoHis point was not about blacks, whites, or even the Civil War. > Wage slavery refers to a situation where a person's livelihood depends on wages or a salary, especially when the dependence is total and immediate. It is a pejorative term used to draw an analogy between slavery and wage labor by focusing on similarities between owning and renting a person. There is a difference between "slaves" in the popular sense (chains, beatings, whips, rape), and "slaves" in the economic sense, but both are premised upon the unjust abrogation of freedom at the hands of another. This article describes the latter case quite well: http://www.buzzfeed.com/jessicagarrison/the-new-american-slavery-invited-to-the-us-foreign-workers-f#.rx4lD3qvr http://www.buzzfeed.com/jessicagarrison/the-new-american-sla...
- paulddraper 11y agoThe quote was from Frederick Douglass, a black man living during the Civil War. Impossible to know for certain, but I suspect he wouldn't be terribly pleased with a comparison of the current "lower class" to real slaves.
- JabavuAdams 11y agoWhy derail this over a word? Wage slavery is a well-known and widely-used term that is useful.