3 ms·
It's hard to take this seriously when pg asks us to believe, on the basis of a single out of context quote, that Stiglitz is a simple-minded victim of the "pie
by foldr 11y ago
It's hard to take this seriously when pg asks us to believe, on the basis of a single out of context quote, that Stiglitz is a simple-minded victim of the "pie fallacy". Stiglitz explicitly anticipates and addresses this criticism:
> One can think of what’s been happening in terms of slices of a pie. If the pie were equally divided, everyone would get a slice of the same size, so the top 1 percent would get 1 percent of the pie. In fact, they get a very big slice, about a fifth of the entire pie. But that means everyone else gets a smaller slice. Now, those who believe in trickle-down economics call this the politics of envy. One should look not at the relative size of the slices but at the absolute size. Giving more to the rich leads to a larger
pie, so though the poor and middle get a smaller share of the pie, the piece of pie they get is enlarged. I wish that were so, but it’s not. In fact, it’s the opposite: as we noted, in the period of increasing inequality, growth has been slower—and the size of the slice given to most Americans has been
diminishing. [my emphasis]
More generally, it's unclear what pg is attempting to do here. None of the arguments presented is at all original, and they are not presented in enough detail to be properly evaluated. So what are we meant to take away from this? That a rich dude is ok with income inequality? Quelle surprise.
- noobermin 11y agoThat still sounds like the pie fallacy. The idea is that wealth is not a global conserved quantity, but can be created by individuals. One need not "enlarge the pie" globally so that the poor can have more of it. It's more like the rich create more of it and the poor create/obtain less of it.
- foldr 11y agoHe doesn't say anything to indicate that he thinks that wealth must necessarily be globally conserved. He's just saying that at as a matter of fact, the period that saw a rise in inequality did not see a rise in the absolute wealth of the majority. That's a factual claim that's either true or false; it would make no sense to say that it's fallacious.
- nhaehnle 11y agoIt's interesting that you focus on the individual when it comes to wealth creation. This is not random, and it predisposes you to believe that there is a pie fallacy going on when in fact there might not be one. The truth is that almost no wealth creation is done by individuals. There is a vast range of levels on which wealth creation is a shared enterprise and it would be boring to trot them out again, but usually, all or at least most of society is involved directly or indirectly (if only by agreeing to the social contract of peacefulness towards one another). Because of this, the question of the rewards for wealth creation is one of distribution from the very beginning. Logically speaking, there is no single point in time where the startup founder's product can be declared to be just his or her own according to a universal philosophy.[1] There is no neutral default distribution that you can derive from first principles. Instead, in the example of startups, to what extent the overall benefit of the creation should go to the startup founder, and to what extent it should go to employees, the people providing the underlying tech stacks, and other parts of society depend on your value system and on your objective function. So, to make explicit what this has to do with the pie fallacy: Since wealth creation is generally not done by individuals, inequality is a concern even when the pie is growing, and even when each individual's absolute income or wealth is growing, because despite all this growth, the resulting distribution might still be unjust.[2] Graham tries to side-step this discussion, and unfortunately our society is generally not well-equipped to defend against such rhetoric moves. You may end up agreeing with him,[3] but I hope you at least recognize that if you do, you do not do so by purely applying logical deduction from first principles. There is necessarily a subjective value judgement that reasonable people with different values and objectives will disagree with. [1] It is also no accident that Graham chooses the example of a woodworker at the beginning of his essay. Since woodworkers have existed for millenia, including through time periods where people really were more self-reliant than today, it makes the reader subtly predisposed to be mislead into accepting the story of wealth creation by individuals. [2] And/or it might be inefficient, but that's a different can of worms. [3] And you may well be right to do so, depending on your values!
- noobermin 11y agoTo you and foldr, I was only responding to his comment, that such reasoning still sounded like the pie fallacy. If you really need my personal opinion, I believed that wealth inequality is a problem before I read pg's essay because it seemed persuasive. I still disagree with a bit of it, but I don't like shutting off others' ideas due to my biases[0]. You make an interesting point though, the idea of how wealth is distributed after does have an underlying value judgement, as you point out. To be fair to pg, he is responding to an often used argument that assumes wealth is a zero sum game rather than it being who gets more of the wealth created. He is right then to claim that given his values (and those shared by most people in America, remember, we still are center-right on most things) and within that moral framework where ownership determines who reaps the benefits, his logic is correct. However, with your values where it seems that benefits should go to those who invest more[1] should earn a proportional amount, it may be suspect. [0] At least the ones I can identify. [1] On second thought, many in America would agree this is a worthy moral framework. I do too.
- awakeasleep 11y agoI believe he wrote this as an example after someone reposted his article on "corn-pone thinking" to show how no matter who or how wealthy you are, your thoughts and opinions won't interfere with how you earn money.
- sparky_z 11y agoYou probably know this but just in case: That wasn't his article. It was an essay by Mark Twain that was hosted on his site (probably so he could link to it from somewhere).
- oidlkwdlkwqdn 11y agoThe argument of the "pie fallacy" is itself a fallacy. The rate of capital generation compared to the rate of capital transfer is actually quite small. Apple didn't pull its $200+B cash reserves out of thin air purely by creating value: it obtained them through capital transfer from its customers. Sure they created some value along the way, but that doesn't change the primary source of their money. Not only that, but an individual's ability to generate new capital is proportional to that person's existing capital stores. Therefore it is completely accurate to idealize the economy for the bottom 90% of citizens as existing in a zero sum state.