4 ms·
We Cooked a Peacock
- 33W 11y agoI listened to this earlier today - and had to head directly to their site to see pictures. A little odd, even for planet money, but a good way to start my day.
- nosefrog 11y agoOur children will look back on the callousness we had when we killed others the same way we look at the overt racism and sexism in our grandparents' generation. There is no moral or right way to kill someone that doesn't want to die.
- ayushgta 11y agoI'm not sure why you are getting downvoted. I, for one, completely agree with your accessment of how future generations could look at this. The comparison with racism and sexism also does not seen far fetched to me. I imagine reading articles like this from the perspective of an intelligent alien species who do not kill other sentient beings for sustenance, and for whom the idea is, well alien :) Now imagine someone from that alien species looking at articles which casually talk about how a glorious peacock must be freshly killed or inject humouous anecdotes about the process. Imagine them looking at TV shows, magazines and articles which go over details of skinning recently living beings and talking about the right temperature to fry or bake their flesh. When I look at cooking shows from that perspective it gives it a completely different coloring. It starts feeling kinda horrifying and at the same time morbidly funny.
- underbluewaters 11y agoAnimals eating other animals is the basis of much of life on this planet. If a fish eats crustaceans or other fish, is it less "good" than one that eats only algae? How about a killer whale, which clearly understands the suffering it wrecks?
- nosefrog 11y agoMorality is a human tool to think about human behavior. Applying it to nonhuman animals is a distraction.
- oh_sigh 11y agoWhy do we have all the equipment and desire to eat other animals? Let's take your assumption that eating animals is not moral. If humans needed to eat animals for some reason, would it still be not moral to eat them?
- clort 11y agoIf a being does something bad to another being that it did not need to do with the knowledge that it was bad and unnecessary, then morally that is not ok. If a being does something that it needs to do in order to survive then that is morally ok, even when that thing is ultimately fatal to other beings. There is a whole world of options between those positions, of course. We have the equipment to eat other animals because we evolved that way and in the past we needed to do that in order to survive. That we may no longer need to do so is where the moral quandry comes into play.
- ayushgta 11y agoI view this conversation as having three facets: 1. Evolutionary disposition. We do have canine teeth and like underbluewaters said "Animals eating other animals is the basis of much of life on this planet.” This is also alluded to in oh_sigh's statement "we have all the equipment and desire to eat other animals”. 2. Social conditioning. Many humans have been eating meat for generations. They have been eating it some form since they were born. The society en masse around them does not see anything wrong with it. There is an inadequate opposing force in social conditioning to a balance positive bias towards eating meat. Social conditioning plays a huge role. For example. there is social conditioning and bias against eating dogs or horses. Pigs, cows and lamb.... not so much. 3. Intellectual choice. Unlike other animals, humans are intellectually evolved and we act guided by our moral compass. Furthermore, as the most intelligent species on this planet, we have a fiduciary responsibility to other species that we share this planet with. Not always but often enough, the right intellectual choice is against our evolutionary disposition and social conditioning. If you take evolutionary disposition and social conditioning out of the picture and view killing and eating other sentient beings purely on the basis of intellectual merit, where does your moral compass point to? When framed that way, I feel that the signal-to-noise ratio is improved in framing the morality question.
- ultramancool 11y agoThe only way I can see this seriously happening is if lab-grown meat becomes extremely successful and we're able to replace farming entirely with it. As with other things, we'll only have a "moral" revolution if it's easy and low cost enough for us to do so. Morality in this sense is a cheap luxury, not something most people do (or should necessarily) care about.
- gtk40 11y agoWhat makes a "one"? Is it excusable for other carnivores/omnivores, or only humans the immoral ones by such a definition?
- nosefrog 11y ago1. Peacocks are sentient. 2. Morality is a human tool to think about human behavior.
- dexwiz 11y agoThe farmer at the beginning hit it head on. Have you ever met a peacock? If so, you don't have any qualms about eating one.
- sabujp 11y agoI wouldn't even eat a bald eagle, probably full of toxic chemicals.
- dmckeon 11y agoJudging by the ingredients and the cooking directions, both the peafowl pie and the claret recipes read more like overdone status signaling by the "spice barons" than anything like tasteful fine dining. This is the culinary equivalent of "how to gold-plate the brand badges on your Mercedes, and then fuse rainbow glitter to them."