22 ms·
Graham is arguing against an enormous straw man. Nobody is suggesting that we “prevent people from getting rich” or “end all economic inequality”. The most extr
by jacobolus 11y ago
Graham is arguing against an enormous straw man. Nobody is suggesting that we “prevent people from getting rich” or “end all economic inequality”. The most extreme proposals I’ve seen in America are ones like, “institute an unconditional basic income as an alternative to means-tested welfare programs,” or “allow every citizen/resident into a single-payer healthcare system,” or “go back to the tax structure of the 1950s–70s”, with higher capital gains taxes, higher inheritance taxes, and higher top marginal income tax rates, etc., plus a lot of proposals that seem to be pure common sense in a democracy such as “limit anonymous spending on political campaigns”, but nothing like a reprise of the French Revolution or early Maoist China or whatever Graham is on about.
- GavinMcG 11y agoOn that note: the most offensive economic inequality isn't the 1% vs. the 99%, which successful startup founders would find themselves on the wrong side of. It's more about the 80 individuals with more wealth than half the world's population [1] – which, yes, does include "startup founders" such as Gates, Ellison, Bezos, Zuckerberg, Page & Brin, etc. But the vast majority of successful startup founders aren't in this group. Even if they were, the proposals are to keep people from becoming quite as obscenely wealthy, as you've pointed out. [1] http://fivethirtyeight.com/datalab/meet-the-80-people-who-are-as-rich-as-half-the-world/ http://fivethirtyeight.com/datalab/meet-the-80-people-who-ar...
- pluckytree 11y agoWhy is that more offensive? What if they were all startup founders or created companies that made profound and positive change? At what point is the cross-over between being reasonably and unreasonably wealthy? If they have too much money and give most of it away, is that better than continuing to create new ventures that could make a difference? This economic inequality feels similar to racism. Why should a very wealthy person be pre-judged to be worse than others without knowing the whole picture? You seem to be singling out startup founders as being OK, it’s just the others that are bad? Sure, income distribution is unequal, but it doesn’t have to turn into villifying those at the top of the heap.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- hwillis 11y agohttps://i.ytimg.com/vi/rMhvYeQPOcE/maxresdefault.jpg https://i.ytimg.com/vi/rMhvYeQPOcE/maxresdefault.jpg People with more money pay taxes at a lower rate than people without. It's very easy to pick obvious cutoffs where people are wealthy to the point of absurdity compared to their "peers".
- ghufran_syed 11y agoThe chart you presented doesn't show the value created, just the value captured by a given segment. Wouldn't that be an important consideration? It's estimated that innovators, the group that Dr Graham is talking about, only capture around 2% of the value they create, with the rest going to society [1]. That's the whole point of the essay, that maybe reducing the 'absurd' levels of wealth will also lead to reduction in the levels of value creation that society currently benefits from. [1] http://www.nber.org/papers/w10433 http://www.nber.org/papers/w10433
- GavinMcG 11y ago> Why should a very wealthy person be pre-judged to be worse than others without knowing the whole picture? Who said anything about judging them? Bill Gates is obviously a good person. That has nothing to do with whether or not we as a society want to allow unlimited financial returns for success in business.
- geofft 11y agoThese sorts of discussions always go downhill because they very quickly turn into defending (and attacking) people as if their identity is inextricably linked to their wealth, which means that policy discussions are read (and sometimes written) as personal attacks. Can we do better than that, please? I don't see a claim that any of these folks are bad people for their money. Gates, for instance, is doing extraordinary good in the form of philanthropy; it's a stretch to imagine that the "offensive economic inequality" is a judgment of his character (although you may be correct that parent's choice of word "offensive" was risky). There are grounds to criticize his richness based on the anti-competitive actions of Microsoft in the '90s, but his richness per se isn't valid grounds to condemn him. What is to blame, what is "offensive," is a society that allows people to become fantastically wealthy like this. What would the harm for society be if, through whatever means, it was much more difficult to become this wealthy? Maybe it is high taxes on the ultra-rich, maybe it is an unwillingness to allow high CEO salaries, maybe it is a serious estate tax, etc. Is it really true that Gates, Zuckerberg, Page, Brin, etc. were motivated primarily by money to found Microsoft, Facebook, Google, etc.? If they had a 99% marginal tax rate once they have assets of $500M (on any form of gaining wealth), would we have a weaker Microsoft or Facebook or Google doing less good for the world because they wouldn't be working as hard? Would the good done to people on the lower end of the scale not outweigh any possible harm here? That seems hard to imagine. And it is precisely because these people could be less rich that the comparison to racism feels ill-placed. A society biased against people of a particular race cannot make existing people cease being of that race, and preventing new people of that race would be grossly immoral. A society biased against billionaires can in good conscience make fewer people billionaires, and it can even prevent hereditary billionaires without any particular immorality (although I think most of the people on that list are self-made).
- marcoperaza 11y ago>"More wealth than half the world's population" That's such a disingenuous statistic. A huge number of people, including a huge number of very well off people, have a negative net worth due to debt. I don't have a car payment or a mortgage, so I have more wealth than at least 30% of America, over 100 million people, combined! It's disappointing to see that FiveThirtyEight has now become just another outfit twisting the truth for their political agenda. I expected better from them.
- baddox 11y agoAre we talking about net worth, or income? I thought we were talking about income initially.
- marcoperaza 11y agoI'm just talking about the statistics that GavinMcG was citing. We were talking about income inequality, but the sensationalist statistic he cited is not.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- GavinMcG 11y agoIt's one metric. And yes, one of its weak points is that my student loans making me less wealthy than the debt-free homeless person is (of course) not the whole story. But that's one narrow slice. On the scale of 80 people with billions upon billions vs. half of everyone else, it's hardly a disingenuous statistic.
- marcoperaza 11y agoThe only reason to use net-worth for such a statistic is to have demagogic sound bites. Most people have negative or very low self-worth because of totally normal and serviceable debt, regardless of whether they're poor or well off. Net worth, i.e. wealth, ignores future earning potential, which is most people's main asset. Repeating the statistic again doesn't change that.
- rayiner 11y agoI disagree. Those people having a lot of wealth doesn't affect ordinary people much at all. The inequality that affects ordinary people is the kind that drives up housing prices and drives out long-time residents, or those that bid uo healthcare or educational costs. The thousands of Facebook employees making six figures contribute more to inequality in practice in their communities than Zuckerberg.
- mikeash 11y agoAt that level it ceases to be about things like housing costs, and starts to be about how the whole country is run. Wealth brings power. Look at that list and you'll see a lot of people who are screwing with the political system for their own benefit.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- dmoo 11y agoIs there any danger that such levels of inequality reach a tipping point where the have nots band together and say why don't we take some of that for us. We have the numbers to either change the law or take by force. Such things are not unknown in history...
- hackerboos 11y agoNick Hanauer believes so... https://www.ted.com/talks/nick_hanauer_beware_fellow_plutocrats_the_pitchforks_are_coming https://www.ted.com/talks/nick_hanauer_beware_fellow_plutocr...
- zo1 11y agoI'd argue it's been happening at a stead pace already. It happened at a "manageable" level when progressive taxation came into place for example. Sin taxes, luxury taxes, property taxes, estate taxes, emigration/exit taxes... All of these things are arguably a form of "have nots band[ing] together and say[ing] why don't we take some of that for us."
- vezzy-fnord 11y agoThe most extreme proposals I’ve seen in America are ones like... The most extreme proposals I've seen in America are a federal job guarantee and a permanent incomes policy similar to the Nixon wage and price controls of the early 70s. Post-Keynesians and MMT proponents are very enthusiastic about them, and they reject the idea of the basic income FWIW.
- WalterBright 11y agoThe Nixon wage-price controls were a disaster. They also precipitated the oil crisis, which persisted until Reagan finally cancelled the oil price controls.
- vezzy-fnord 11y agoI'm not advocating either of these policies in the slightest. I'm pointing out their increasing popularity in light of a heterodox renaissance post-2008.
- minimuffins 11y agoI'm not aware of the relationship between Nixon era wage policies and the oil crisis. Do you have some info on that?
- WalterBright 11y agoNixon enacted price controls on oil in 1971. This meant that US prices for oil could not rise, and the oil from non-Arab sources got shipped to other countries who outbid the US. Price controls prevented finding new sources of oil. There's more, a thorough treatment is in George Reisman's book "Capitalism" pg. 188.
- WalterBright 11y agoOne of the first things Reagan did when inaugurated was, by Executive Order, rescind the oil price controls. The gas lines vanished overnight and never returned in the 35 years since, despite all kinds of gyrations in the oil business. It's rare that we have such a clear example of the deleterious effects of price controls.
- WalterBright 11y agoOn paper, the tax rates were higher in the 50s. What isn't mentioned is that was the age of the tax shelter, the 3 martini lunch, etc. It is doubtful anyone actually paid those rates. Reagan's deal to lower the tax rates included repealing all those deductions and tax shelters.
- SilasX 11y agoRight, it just meant (as mention in pg's parallel article today) that more compenation got rebranded as a corporate expense or non-taxable fringe benefit.
- samastur 11y agoYou are welcome to try to eat and drink through tens of millions of dollars, but I doubt you can do it. Even if you can, there will be a lot of happy waiters and cooks serving you ;)
- tomjen3 11y agoAnd you don't think the mechanics, aviators, etc who keep the billionaires flying are happy to have jobs now?
- samastur 11y agoSure they are, but that was not the argument I was half-jokingly making. What I was saying was that you can't hide meaningful amount of difference in tax rates between then and now in business lunches (which to the best of my knowledge are still around). On a more serious note though I would consider the law of diminishing marginal utility and its impact on economic activity.
- WalterBright 11y agoTax sheltering investments were huge.
- mtgx 11y agoI agree, Paul Graham sounds like the solution to fixing extreme inequality must be communism (the Marxist type). I'm a little surprised he is making this argument.
- rdtsc 11y agoHe is defending what he is doing and what Y-combinator has been doing. One of the most important roles of a leader is to create vision -- build a story that explains and interprets reality based on it. In general, startup world lives on hopes and ideals. More so than other industries. Founders have to have a "burning desire to change the world". It could be building a better future, moving the technology forward, making people happier, more productive, healthier, etc. Early employees are sold on hopes of changing those 10000 options into billions of dollars during the exit or the IPO in exchange of a decent salary etc. There is talk of getting paid less but "you are compressing you career of 30 years into 5", so working nights makes sense. Investors hope the company will grow a horn and hooves and become a unicorn. Etc, etc. So it is important to have a story that interprets how startups are related to inequality. Whether we agree or not with that is a different story.
- lisper 11y ago> He is defending what he is doing and what Y-combinator has been doing. But that is the straw man. Those of us who think extreme economic inequality is a bad thing do not think that YC is a bad thing, notwithstanding that it does contribute to economic inequality. The problem is not YC, the problem is that extremely rich people use their money to buy political power, which they then use to create laws that allow them to extract rents (by, for example, paying lower marginal tax rates than less wealthy people). It's the positive-feedback effect that this creates (more money -> more political power -> still more money) that is the problem, not YC, nor (obviously) the creation of wealth.
- twoodfin 11y agowhich they then use to create laws that allow them to extract rents (by, for example, paying lower marginal tax rates than less wealthy people) How is someone who pays 10x, 100x, 1000x the taxes of the median taxpayer "extracting rent"?
- rdtsc 11y ago> But that is the straw man. That was my point -- consider the source and the motivation of the author. I see I got downvoted after a while, wonder if that idea didn't come out as clear.
- xiler 11y agoThere's nothing wrong with someone getting rich provided they contribute a proportional amount of value to society. Problem is that since the post-WII period (also called the Golden Age of Capitalism) such rewards have been happening less and less [1,2]. In fact, I think reducing inequality is essential for promoting productivity. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Post%E2%80%93World_War_II_economic_expansion https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Post%E2%80%93World_War_II_econ... [2] https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/7/73/US_productivity_and_real_wages.jpg https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/7/73/US_produ...
- branchless 11y agoAlso how many of these people are preserving their wealth by diverting their justly earned income into rentier activity, such as property? In addition many patents are rentier activity. They are taking collected human knowledge and ring-fencing an area to derive economic rent. I'm not even sure I'm interested in Graham's writings on lisp. Economics, forget it.
- replicatorblog 11y agoPatents are VERY different than property in that they expire in less than 20 years (at least in the US).
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- prostoalex 11y agoIf intellectual property protections present an economic constraint, then countries with weak intellectual property protections would outperform countries with strong intellectual property protections. Yet for some reason countries with weak IP protection do not present the world with abundance of new technologies or pharma.
- cko 11y agoBut is it wrong for a rich person to hoard wealth, or to spend only on luxuries for themselves? Why do they have to "contribute to society"? I'm by no means wealthy, and at my age of 29 I've donated more money than many of my coworkers. And I'm all for a portion of tax dollars supporting the underprivileged. But when I read about Larry Ellison's yacht-racing hobby, I think to myself, "good for him." He can spend his money on whatever he wants, right? I don't see that he owes anyone anything just because he has more.
- stale2002 11y ago"Nobody is suggesting that we “prevent people from getting rich"" Yes they are. Don't you remember all the articles about Zuckerberg's charity, and how it is bad that rich people have so much control over society, and that the solution shouldn't be charity, it should be to prevent people from becoming so rich in the first place? That shit was all over the place.
- fweespeech 11y agoZuckerberg isn't really engaging in charity. Its basically buying political influence is one of his stated goals. I'm not sure why people keeping thinking he is engaging in charitable activity when what he really said he was engaging in investment & nonprofit activity.
- nickbauman 11y agoI don't understand why you're being down-voted. It's eminently clear this is what he's doing: it's right out there in the open. http://fortune.com/2015/12/02/zuckerberg-charity/ http://fortune.com/2015/12/02/zuckerberg-charity/
- minimuffins 11y agoYeah, that was widely reported in publications spanning the political spectrum (excluding most of the tech press).
- nickbauman 11y ago"That shit" could be interpreted this way: Having "obscene" wealth accumulate with one or a few persons means the decision-making about using that wealth becomes idiosyncratic and volatile at worst, generally misdirected at best. In market-fundamentalist terminology, huge actors cannot result in optimal results. Markets work best with broadly-held wealth and millions or billions of small bets, lowering the criticality of market failure.
- stale2002 11y ago
- runesoerensen 11y agoI think you're taking this too literally. For instance, "ending economic inequality would mean ending startups" might be translated into something like: "Implementing policies that marginally reduce economic inequality would marginally reduce incentives to start a startup, and consequently reduce the number of founders that will start a startup in this country ever so slightly". Sometimes it's easier to understand the consequences of doing something by pointing out extremes. It also makes for better reading, but the price you pay is that some people may think you're an extremist.
- Futurebot 11y agoEven those in what remains of America's radical left don't make this argument (the few that do aren't taken seriously by their fellow leftists anymore); even in Europe, which is far more generous in terms of social welfare provision has some level of wealth inequality. So it's definitely a huge strawman. PG makes several statements which shows that he understands important parts of the problem (poverty, mobility), but it's incomplete (and credit to him for writing a thoughtful piece on the issue - more people in power should be doing the same.) Instead, the picture looks more like this: 1) Massive wealth inequality distorts policies towards the preferences of the rich (http://faculty.wcas.northwestern.edu/~jnd260/cab/CAB2012%20-%20Page1.pdf http://faculty.wcas.northwestern.edu/~jnd260/cab/CAB2012%20-..., http://www.demos.org/stacked-deck-how-dominance-politics-affluent-business-undermines-economic-mobility-america http://www.demos.org/stacked-deck-how-dominance-politics-aff..., Affluence and Influence), so reducing inequality does more than just give people more mobility; it allows government to more accurately reflect the will of the people. It's democracy-enabling. Massive inequality in wealth breeds massive inequality in political power. No amount of mobility or opportunity can fix this one, only inequality reduction itself. 2) As Hayes discusses in "Twilight of the Elites", we've learned that basically everyone in the US has accepted the current notions of meritocracy, social mobility, and equality of opportunity. What is currently not well-accepted is that in order to achieve anything like equality of opportunity and social mobility, you need more equality of outcome in the first place. One can express this as "reducing poverty", but that's just a _reframing the same idea_. We are in fact talking about redistributing money from the very rich and giving it to the not-rich, one way or another, to improve EoOpp and SM. That reduces inequality by definition. 3) Massive inequality itself increases social distance, which is partially reflected in #1. When all one sees, knows, meets, etc. are other wealthy people, one may wind up becoming disconnected from the plight of the non-wealthy. They become an annoyance, invisible, or irrelevant, which is reflected not only in policy, but also in self-reinforcing cycles of disinterest and disconnection in the realm of social relations. Inequality has to be reduced somewhat to reduce that social distance. 4) When we speak of inequality reduction, it can be understood as "wealth range compression." The top go down, the bottom go up. Many analogize chopping off the top and putting it at the bottom, but the compression metaphor works better IMO. 5) Some worry (like Acemoglu) that US inequality subsidizes other nations in terms of innovation. I think Edsall and others have completely demolished the argument, and its was largely facile in the face of facts like Sweden having invented the ultrasound, the pacemaker, and AIS (an advancement of GPS) or Denmark having invented the loudspeaker, Bluetooth, and Insulin. You could even argue the opposite: a society that gives people a better safety net (Peltzman effect again) combined with an entrepreneurial culture will produce more, not less innovation. The recommendations for remedying this are fairly tame in the European / Scand. context, mostly because fewer of them have internalized ideas like "taxation is theft" or "everything that happens to you is your own fault." We should regard the following as non-controversial (some a restatement of your list items): - Marginal tax rates at the top of 50% (France is even higher and still has rich people) and policies to make sure the rates stay progressive. - Closing tax loopholes, forcible repatriation of stashed offshore assets, fully funding the IRS, and eliminating (for real) tax havens and their usage. - Debt-free higher ed (full rides, living stipends, the works) - A real universal health system - No games with inheritance taxes - Non-punitive, non-humiliating policies to help the poor like a GBI or expanded automatic welfare provision - Not gutting social security If we were to implement the whole of Sanders' platform, for example (most of which I agree with, a few items I think are questionable), we'd still be to the right of a Denmark or Sweden(!) We'd be slightly to the right of what we had during the Great Society. It's a return to sanity, basic living standards, and mobility. Hardly the stuff of Galtian nightmares.
- golergka 11y ago> go back to the tax structure of the 1950s–70s”, with higher capital gains taxes Wouldn't it just push capital outside of US?
- jellicle 11y agoJust like the 1950s, which we all know were a disastrous time for US industry?
- golergka 11y ago1) The capital is much more mobile now 2) If the US taxes in 1950s were lower, it indeed would make US an even more attractive place for capital. However, the US was going through an industrial boom because of variety of other factors then, unlike any other country in the world. Now, situation both in US and other countries is quite different, and tax factor is more important. Basically, when you have the best goods on the market, it's OK to ask high prices, but when you get competition, it's not such a wise move to keep them high.
- dpeterson 11y agoI think it is great, with everything Paul Graham has to lose, knowing comments like these will be at the top of something he helped create, he still has the courage to say what he believes. Yes, there are many people/politicians that will use other well meaning people to prevent others from competing with them by eliminating the ability to get rich.
- graeme 11y agoYou might be arguing against a straw man. I don't think PG was saying "Current, actual proposals will significantly dent inequality". I think he was saying "People misunderstand the issue. They're concerned by inequality, but think that reducing inequality amounts to the same thing, and inequality is per se bad." Reading this in combination with other essays, pg is likely worried that a seemingly innocuous change could have an outsize impact on startup formation, precisely because they're so marginal.
- apsec112 11y ago"Nobody is suggesting that we “prevent people from getting rich” or “end all economic inequality”." FWIW, I've met tons of people who suggested this. Eg., at Google, I had a co-worker who was probably the best programmer on our team. He loudly and repeatedly argued for socialism (he literally used the word "socialism"), and for government seizure of all private property over some low-ish threshold per person. He very strongly believed that no one could ever earn the right to be rich, and that rich people were so bad for democracy that well-run countries shouldn't have any.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- x0x0 11y agoYeah, that one dude's argument totally characterizes the entire progressive wing of the Democratic party...
- Futurebot 11y agoI agree with your sentiment but I don't think sarcasm is going to get you anything but downvotes. The person you're responding might be underinformed and/or hasty generalizing, but probably deserves a more constructive reply.
- x0x0 11y agoNutpicking deserves to be mocked. There are plenty of progressive economists, spokespeople, or empowered politicians; any of them are fair game for criticism.
- Futurebot 11y agoCriticism, yes, I just think a more enlightening reply would do more for the conversation. The way I like to think of it is that you're refuting an argument for the benefit of other readers of the comment who may not be well informed / are persuadable, rather than to oppose the person you're replying to. Think of it as communicating a thoughtful missive to someone (who honestly doesn't know) that has asked you "what's wrong with that comment?"
- chroma 11y agoI don't think PG is attacking a straw man at all. In my career as a software engineer, I've run into a significant number of outright communists. Like most of us, they keep their political opinions to themselves most of the time. But occasionally, they let slip how they would welcome revolution. I don't want to name names or expose people who don't want to be exposed, so I'll just give one prominent example. Steve Klabnik is an extremely talented programmer. He's a core developer of Rust and is the main author of The Rust Book[1]. He is also a communist. (Edit: This is not 100% accurate. Klabnik is better described as anti-capitalist. See downthread for details.) Don't take my word for it. He wants people to know this. Read his blog[2]. Look at his Twitter[3]. Judging from his follower count, he's not exactly alone in his opinions. I wish you were right. Communists should be straw men. If there's any societal system that has been shown not to work, it's communism. That experiment has been tried so many times, in so many countries, with varying cultures, geographies, and levels of development... and not one of them was successful. Yes, capitalism has had failures, but at least it's had successes. 1. http://doc.rust-lang.org/book/ http://doc.rust-lang.org/book/ 2. http://words.steveklabnik.com/an-introduction-to-economics-under-capitalism http://words.steveklabnik.com/an-introduction-to-economics-u... At the end: "…this post is basically my own little summary of Capital, Volume I, chapters 1-7, by Karl Marx." 3. https://twitter.com/steveklabnik https://twitter.com/steveklabnik
- graeme 11y agoI haven't read through the links you cited, just the excerpt. A lot of non-communists cite Marx. My economics professors in University certainly did, including one who advocated eliminating corporate taxes.
- chroma 11y agoOut of everything I said, I'm surprised this is the thing that's contested. Just scroll through his Twitter feed. Here are a few recent ones: https://twitter.com/steveklabnik/status/682787891936948224 https://twitter.com/steveklabnik/status/682787891936948224 https://twitter.com/steveklabnik/status/682788969843658752 https://twitter.com/steveklabnik/status/682788969843658752 https://twitter.com/steveklabnik/status/682787609446330368 https://twitter.com/steveklabnik/status/682787609446330368 https://twitter.com/steveklabnik/status/682787371235016705 https://twitter.com/steveklabnik/status/682787371235016705 He retweeted this: https://twitter.com/kantrn/status/683385220167368704 https://twitter.com/kantrn/status/683385220167368704 https://twitter.com/steveklabnik/status/682759650362658816 https://twitter.com/steveklabnik/status/682759650362658816 https://twitter.com/steveklabnik/status/682759288012554240 https://twitter.com/steveklabnik/status/682759288012554240 Heck, his Twitter profile pic is a communist logo. His Twitter bio says, "Every loss for a worker is loss for all of us and every gain for a part of the working class is a victory for all." That's a quote from the Industrial Workers of the World[1]. I don't know how much more communist one can get. 1. http://www.iww.org/content/iww-greece-announcement-regarding-referendum http://www.iww.org/content/iww-greece-announcement-regarding...
- clarkmoody 11y ago> pure common sense in a democracy Does not exist. Democracy means that 51% of the people can destroy the life/liberty/property of the other 49% whenever they feel like it.
- bduerst 11y agoIt does too. That scenario typically leads to civil war and two democracies, at least for a period of time. Sometimes it works out, as with the U.S. democracy declaring that people are not anothers property.
- legulere 11y agoThat's a very theoretical approach to democracy. Real democracies are less about the majority deciding things than keeping the people that do decide things in check. Just look at what the majority of the people think. There are so many wrong things that the majority of people believe, you wouldn't want those beliefs made real through politics. Also nobody can be even interested in all topics decided.
- aflinik 11y agoBeing a Pole, I wish more people understood that. :( We're in the process of dismantling our democracy by removing all of the checks you mentioned, while supporters of the ruling party argue that democratically elected majority is within full rights to do it.
- pdonis 11y ago> Graham is arguing against an enormous straw man. This is a very hard case to make when Graham's money quote, at the start of the essay, is from a Nobel-Prize-winning economist saying, pretty much in so many words, that rich people get rich by taking stuff from poor people--which is exactly the claim Graham is arguing against. > Nobody is suggesting that we “prevent people from getting rich” or “end all economic inequality”. I think you're missing Graham's point. His point is not that people explicitly suggest these things, but that the discussion is framed so that they are implicit assumptions, so far in the background that nobody even thinks to question them. Judging countries by their Gini coefficient, and the criticism the US has gotten because its Gini coefficient is too high, is an obvious example. Everybody argues over what Gini coefficient is "too high" and requires action to correct; nobody even asks whether the Gini coefficient is the right thing to judge by. > institute an unconditional basic income as an alternative to means-tested welfare programs A key argument for which is that unconditional basic income would do better at reducing income inequality than means-tested welfare programs. > allow every citizen/resident into a single-payer healthcare system This I agree is pretty much irrelevant to reducing income inequality; it is aimed more at reducing the impact of income inequality on access to health care, without doing anything about the inequality itself. > go back to the tax structure of the 1950s–70s A key argument for which is reducing income inequality by taxing more of what rich people make. The point being that none of these measures ask why certain people have more income, which is a key piece of information. Graham's point is that if one person makes more than another because they're more productive, you don't want to "fix" that, because it's not a problem, it's what fuels economic growth. It's true that there are other ways for people to make more than others, which are not based on wealth creation, and Graham explicitly says he wants those to be shut down. But after you've shut them all down, you won't have "fixed" the "problem" of income inequality, because people's productivity will still vary, and the more technology advances, the more the variation will be amplified, so the more unequal incomes will be.
- jshen 11y ago"Graham's point is that if one person makes more than another because they're more productive, you don't want to "fix" that, because it's not a problem, it's what fuels economic growth." I do not believe he said this, and it's a non sequitur
- totemizer 11y agoI am actually suggesting that we end all economic inequality. The only reason I don't argue for "end all inequality" is that it's physically impossible as much as we know it. Economy should be about what is good for everyone, it shouldn't contain anything which can be used to exploit other humans due to their "economic circumstances". The current system does allow it, and as long as you can attach a number to any person to get their value or "worth", there will be no change towards equality, maybe less inequality. Which is not enough because while the possibility is open, it will always fluctuate.
- patrickaljord 11y agoYou cannot end all economic inequality without removing freedom. A free society where people can freely express their full potential will create inequalities by default. Even if we manage to give equal opportunities to everyone, some people will manage better than others. Some people are born to be Mozart and Newtons. That is just how it is, and when you are one of these people, with greater potential, you will accomplish more and people will be happy to give you more of their money to enjoy your work, making you unequally richer than they are. There is no way around that. You could have given me a billion to get started and I would still not have written the magic flute or written a revolutionary algorithm. Societies who tried to remove all inequalities managed to create living hell where everyone was equally poor and unfree and not able to express their full potential while the ones with great potentials tried to flee such society. Just be careful what you ask for. For having grown up in a socialist hell myself (Syria), I wouldn't go back to such a place (even without the war).
- ap22213 11y agoAnd, some people are born Mozarts and Newtons, and we never hear of them because they they lack connections, access, leisure, and opportunity. I don't know what true socialism feels like, but I do know that whatever mixed system the U.S. has certainly doesn't feel like freedom. Whatever we have, I'd like to try something new because it's not working.
- 11y ago
- dojomouse 11y ago| Graham is arguing against an enormous straw man. Word. I don't know anyone who understands enough to actually have a discussion (e.g. isn't some back to nature hippy) and seriously thinks we should attempt to minimise the opportunities to create new wealth. Everyone I know who argues for reduced economic inequality favours increased minimum wages and/or redistributive mechanisms (income/wealth tax). I don't know if Graham has encountered people who seriously argue against permitting opportunities to create wealth, or just thinks those people exist, or has some sort of anti-redistribution agenda (which would function to reduce the potential gains that could accrue to startup founders... though not significantly). I was particularly struck by this suggestion: "And if there are people getting rich by tricking consumers or lobbying the government for anti-competitive regulations or tax loopholes, then let's stop them. Not because it's causing economic inequality, but because it's stealing." Stealing is an extremely imprecise and emotive word, and he makes no effort to clarify. Which is usually what you do when you want a lot of people to feel like they agree with your arguments even when they might not if you went into detail. But the weirder part of the statement (ignoring the fairly broad 'tricking consumers', which would include most people who market their products) is that he specifically identifies tax avoidance (which I'd argue ISN'T stealing) as something we should eliminate... "not because it's causing economic inequality, but because it's stealing", even though the main reason we have tax AT ALL (and hence laws around when you do/don't need to pay it) is to reduce economic inequality! So... all our existing tax laws, and their economic-inequality-reducing redistributive effects, are wise and good and infractions should be rigorously prosecuted because they'd amount to stealing. But any NEW tax laws that might increase the redistribution of wealth to increase economic-equality would be bad and misguided? Because where we are, right now, is the perfect optimum, despite the widespread evidence of increased concentration of wealth and its negative consequences? Riiiight. Finally, last I checked there are various areas which have lower tax than the USA. Yet somehow plenty of startups are still formed in the USA. Which casts doubt on the 'the startups will move elsewhere if you change anything to reduce their direct rewards' argument.
- iaw 11y ago"Others will say I'm clueless or being misleading by focusing on people who get rich by creating wealth—that startups aren't the problem, but corrupt practices in finance, healthcare, and so on. Once again, that is exactly my point. The problem is not economic inequality, but those specific abuses." Given the 2001 dot-com fiasco and the frequency of ratchets in fundraising I'm surprised that Paul would make an argument that the abuses of finance are separate from the start-up world. In the current system, startups are frequently treated as an investment vehicle by specialized finance firms. There is a lot of moral hazard in the valley that Paul seems to ignore in his piece.
- questerzen 11y agoThere are two separate issues here and it is important to distinguish them clearly. PG is correct that there are two basic strategies for making money: rent and productivity. 1) rent, although it has a positive aspect (it helps to efficiently allocate scarce resources to where they are most valuable and provides an incentive to add scarce resources to the economy), provides an inherent redistribution of wealth which makes owners of capital richer at the expense of non-owners. Piketty etc. have noticed that capital owners have recently been able to gain a greater share of wealth. This is socially and morally a bad thing, especially when it keeps non-capital owners in a state of relative poverty. 2) productivity, in general, is more positive because it provides a net gain to the whole economy as PG points out. If the incentives to a small number of people are very high for adding productivity, then there is no particular problem with this. So in this sense PG is correct. However, this is largely irrelevant as the main problem is that productivity gains are predominantly going to NEITHER workers NOR entrepreneurs. Rather they are going to existing owners of capital. The biggest problem with massive wealth accumulation by founders isn't whether it was deserved, but that when people stop being productivity enhancers they become capital owners and CONTINUE to earn wealth excessively not due to further productivity gains but through rent. There are many solutions possible, but none of the sensible ones would affect new founders very much. PG can sleep easily on this account. The reason PG should feel "hunted" is not that he is a founder enjoying the rewards for benefits he has provided to society, but that as a successful former founder and now capital owner he is continuing to gain excessive wealth by extracting rent from his YC investments such as AirBnB, and even worse, helping PASSIVE YC investors to capture that rent also.
- karmacondon 11y agoThe hell are you talking about? The argument could easily be made that AirBnB exists because of the efforts of the YCombinator team. It's not like Paul Graham is personally just sitting back and collecting money. He works hard to advise and provide seed capital to hundreds of startups at year, at a stage when their success is far from guaranteed. For whatever you think about his views on income inequality, it's difficult to make the case that he's rent seeking.
- 11y ago
- jackarmstrong 11y agojacobolus is exactly right.